Opinion Links: Opinion Home Page | Latest Expert Columns | Latest Blog Entries
Sidebottom: Looked a class apart
England got there in the end and it was fitting that Ryan Sidebottom, England's man of the series by some distance, should end New Zealand's resistance shortly after lunch on the last day to win by 121 runs.
Sidebottom, who took 7-47 in the first innings, has looked a class apart throughout the tour, rarely bowling a bad ball and always asking taxing questions of a batsman's technique. His rise from the wilderness to his country's spearhead in just ten months has been meteoric and should serve as a massive incentive for other county stalwarts.
Michael Vaughan, Peter Moores and the selectors deserve massive credit for acting swiftly after Hamilton to freshen up the bowling attack while simultaneously staying patient with the batsmen. I feel incredibly sorry for Owais Shah, who has not had a single opportunity all winter to show what he can do, but you can take nothing away from Andrew Strauss, after his international career-saving 177 in Napier.
A failure for Strauss would almost certainly have seen an extended stay in county cricket but he demonstrated his mettle just at the right time. People will point out that he was batting on a very flat pitch against an ordinary attack but as a batsman you can only score runs against what's in front of you and he's done enough to earn the right to play against New Zealand in the summer.
As for the other batsmen: Kevin Pietersen showed his class in Napier and is set for a big summer; the opening partnership of Vaughan and Alastair Cook, which showed good signs in Sri Lanka was disappointing but I like the right/ left combination and would leave well alone; Paul Collingwood looks like he belongs and is a fine team player but number six is not the spot to be batting with another Andrew Flintoff recovery around the corner. And here's my massive call of the week:
Ian Bell will be one of the three best batsmen in the world by 2011.
I'm not going to seek to justify the call particularly as it's based more on instinct than anything else. Suffice to say that I like the way he has seemed more prepared to play his shots this winter. He's got out a few times trying to hit spinners over the top but the intent and the desire to expand his game in a quest to be the best is laudable.
The bowling attack needs Flintoff back to give it the perfect balance but the axing of Steve Harmison and Matthew Hoggard has seen the emergence of Stuart Broad as more than just a great prospect. He might look 10 years old but everything he does demonstrates maturity and energy and he is a more than useful number eight batsman, too. Depth in a batting order is crucial: it would have been a very different series without the batting efforts of Broad and Tim Ambrose.
The jury is still out on the enigma that is James Anderson. There is no question that he's one of the best around when the ball is swinging and he's a great guy with a big heart. When atmospheric conditions are not in his favour, however, he comes on to the bat for the best in the world to murder. Matthew Hoggard used all his nous on the subcontinent to develop different deliveries to give his bowling variation. Anderson needs to do the same.
Panesar and Sidebottom are the class acts in the bowling department and if both can stay fit the rest of the attack can be built around them. A pace attack of Sidebottom, Broad, Flintoff and a fully fit and firing Harmison is a unit to rival the one that brought home the Ashes in 2005 but England are a long way from playing that standard of cricket and the two big men have a lot of work to do with Harmison in particular needing to silence his critics with performances rather than words.
New Zealand and England will do battle again in the early part of the summer but without Stephen Fleming it's hard to see the black caps making any sort of impression. Next time round England shouldn't just win - they should win well.
Gloucestershire ruined opening night at Glamorgan's new SWALEC Stadium with a six-wicket win in the Friends Provident Trophy clash.
Chris Tremlett pressed claims for a full England recall on day two of the Lions' tour match against New Zealand.
Jimmy Anderson pressed his claims for a place in the England side with a five-wicket haul as Lancashire thrashed Durham.
Ryan McLaren took 6-75 to leave Kent needing a further 115 runs on the final day of their LV County Championship clash with Notts.
Big centuries from Marcus Trescothick and Justin Langer helped Somerset turn the tables on Hampshire at Taunton.
Comments
Kris Desmond says...
Surely beating New Zealand playing 5/10 is better then scraping a victory playing at the peak of our game johnny bravo? The signs are good. all good teams play badly but still win so we should feel confident.
Posted 11:29 1st April 2008
Niall Hickman says...
Always good to hear from Fults! Hope to hear back from you. I agree entirely with some of your analysis but suffice to say, this being cricket, not all. I know it is easy to write off someone in sport and as a journalist I've been, er, occasionally guilty of that, but Fults, you've got to be kidding about Harmy and Anderson. Both have bags of talent coming out of their ears, but as you know that is where cricket is played, between the ears. Anderson simply cannot handle the increased discipline required for test match cricket and Harmy was bowling slower than Colly in his last game. They have both been given numerous chances in the test arena and as you mention in your copy about giving Owais Shah a chance, the selectors should move on. Ramps was a spellbinding county cricket but could not do it at the higher level and I suspect that is the case with Anderson. As for Harmy, I'm afraid he can't be given chance after chance after chance. Anyway, other than that, great stuff Fults. Apart from the fact you used the word 'massive' about 20 times!!!!! Keep in touch. Niall
Posted 15:56 30th March 2008
Adrian Shotbolt says...
I agree England have become an average side, victory over New Zealand at home in the test series should be straight forward however South Africa will give us a real test and my money would be on a comfortable victory for the proteas. The team needs a shake up Sidebottom and Broad should be certs to start but Anderson is not mentally tough enough for international test cricket, hopefully Flintoff will be back for South Africa to bolster the bowling options.
Posted 12:17 30th March 2008
Darren Cricket says...
Johnny, South Africa beat New Zealand at home. NZ are a decent side at home and we should just be happy we won 2-1 after all its a series win. England are very strong at home and I think will beat NZ 3-0 and SA 2-1. John its clear you know nothing about cricket.
Posted 00:10 29th March 2008
Richie Dodds says...
I agree with Johny..its great to see the press build them up again into worldbeaters.it will be difficult against South Africa...lets see what the opinion is after that ..........
Posted 17:39 28th March 2008
Andy Cunningham says...
South Africa aint that good, and they are built around one man, Kallis. He has a sound technique for most pitches/bowling. With the rest, they are flat track bullies, but get them on good pitch against the swinging ball, and they are suspect. In the bowling dept. Steyn has still a lot to prove, and I will be interested to see how he manages against a Pietersen on 100+ and I am not sure he will hold it together. That said, I am not impressed by the current Australian bowling and if I can equally make a bold prediction; the next five years will see a sea change in the world order with Australia suffering most. You can't lose two great bowlers as Warne/ Mcgrath without it hurting.
Posted 16:37 28th March 2008
Johnny Bravo says...
My main fear is that while England overall played 5/10 against an average Kiwi side, South Africe who toured New Zealand a couple of months ago blew them away. As usual I think England are getting carried away after beating what most people think a good county side. I will be putting my money on, sorry even better my mortgage on South Africa winng the series in England in a few months time.
Posted 16:07 27th March 2008
Add Comment*
All fields are required