Skip to content

England, India and Australia gain ICC backing for their vision of the future of cricket

India's N Srinivasan (right) chats to Giles Clarke during the ICC Board Meeting at The Royal Garden Hotel on October 18, 2013 in London, England.
Image: ECB chairman Giles Clarke (left) and BCCI president N Srinivasan

Key changes to the "future structure, governance and financial models" of the International Cricket Council have been unanimously supported by the ICC Board, though not all aspects of the controversial 'position paper' have been retained.

Latest Cricket Stories

The announcement of this follow-up meeting, as well as guarded wording such as "unanimous support", indicates that no formal vote was taken despite extensive debate behind closed doors. Cricket South Africa has been a fervent objector since the 'position paper' was leaked, describing the proposals as "fundamentally flawed", while officials from Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh had all been quoted as taking a dim view of certain aspects. South Africa may have been partially appeased by an offer to include them in a planned 'Test Cricket Fund' from which they had previously been excluded. The fund is supposed to support the longer format in territories where it struggles to sustain itself and all full members would now receive a share, barring the 'big three' behind the blueprint. The notion of promotion and relegation between a streamlined group of eight Test nations and the lesser Intercontinental Cup was a large part of the position paper but featured altogether less prominently in the new communique. Indeed, the assertion that "there will be an opportunity for all members to play all formats of cricket on merit, with participation based on meritocracy" is open to several interpretations. Less ambiguous is the addition of the phrase "no immunity to any country", which refers directly to a divisive recommendation that England, India and Australia be exempt from relegation due to their financial importance.
BCCI position
The BCCI, which is eager to use any reorganisation to increase its share of revenue as the game's primary cash-generator, had reportedly threatened to break away from the ICC if no changes are made. Therefore the ICC Board's "recognition of the need for strong leadership...which will involve BCCI taking a central leadership responsibility", could yet prove most important of all. How India chooses to administer its influence in a newly-formalised position of authority could underpin every other change. In his closing comments, Isaac attempted to convey a sense of benevolence on the work of the big three and expressed dismay at some of the criticisms that met the draft. "Several months ago I encouraged BCCI, CA and ECB to enter into a constructive dialogue together to help resolve some of the key commercial and governance issues facing the game," he said. "These leading cricket nations have worked tirelessly to produce a document which provided the basis for the past few weeks of extremely constructive discussions. "It is obviously very disappointing that a draft position paper from these members was leaked as this prompted a debate that ignored the ongoing negotiations between all members and led to unwarranted criticism of many of those involved in the process. "The principles agreed today provide clear evidence that through the course of further discussions over the coming weeks we can be increasingly confident in achieving consensus." CSA president Chris Nenzani made an additional statement following the ICC release, declaring that his own support for the agreed principles was contingent on the approval of his board. "We will be convening a joint session of our CSA Board and certain key stakeholders as soon as is practically possible to consider the principles," Nenzani said. "One of the hallmarks of our new administration has been an absolute adherence to the principles of good corporate governance and we do not intend to deviate from this. Our position will be subject to full consideration by our Board and other stakeholders."

Around Sky