Skip to content

Ashes 2015: Pat Cummins should play if Mitchell Starc ruled out, says Michael Holding

'Cummins' pace makes him better option than Siddle'

Pat Cummins, Australia v New Zealand
Image: Pat Cummins should play for Australia at Lord's if Mitchell Starc is ruled out

Michael Holding says Australia should pick Pat Cummins if injury rules Mitchell Starc out of the second Investec Ashes Test at Lord's.

Starc's participation at the Home of Cricket is in doubt after he picked up ankle knock during the Baggy Greens' 169-run first Test loss to England in Cardiff.

The left-armer came through a training session unscathed on Tuesday morning but Sky Sports commentator Holding says if Starc does miss out, he would opt for the extra zip of Cummins as opposed to the more experienced Peter Siddle.

The Ashes - Live

"If I was involved in the Australian hierarchy or dressing-room, I would go for Cummins," Holding said of a player with just six first-class matches and one Test to his name.

"I wouldn't go for Siddle as I think he would do a similar job to what Hazlewood, who doesn't have great pace but was very consistent in Cardiff on a slow pitch, is already doing.

"I am looking for someone with some pace, especially if the pitch at Lord's is like the one against New Zealand earlier this summer - hard and bouncy."

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Australia coach Darren Lehmann says he expects his side to adapt more quickly in the second Ashes Test

Holding reckons Australia have been severely dented by the retirement of Ryan Harris and the fact Mitchell Johnson finds conditions in England much tougher than in Australia, the 33-year-old averaging 41.92 in this country compared to 24.49 in his homeland.

More from The Ashes 2015

And the former West Indies seamer feels the tourists will be hoping for a Lord's pitch with extra fizz, not just to aid their seamers but also off-spinner Nathan Lyon, who took six wickets in Wales.

Johnson doesn’t do very well in England. His effectiveness is not what he’d like.
Michael Holding

"Australia are missing Ryan Harris, who I think would have been a dynamic bowler in this country," added Holding.

"But we have also seen in the statistics that Johnson doesn't do very well in England - he only has one five-wicket haul here compared to seven in Australia and his effectiveness is not what he'd like.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Australia fast bowler Peter Siddle says he is ready to play in the second Ashes Test at Lord's if team-mate Mitchell Starc isn't fit to play

"Lyon did what he could do [in Cardiff] but spinners need pitches with pace, too, because when the ball turns, you want it to turn at a good pace, not get slow turn."

Watch The Ashes live on Sky Sports, with continued coverage of the series on Sky Sports Ashes HD from Thursday or watch the second Test at Lord's with a NOW TV Sports Day Pass. Our Ashes Events Centre - the best of Sky Cricket's analysis at your fingertips - is available on our iPad app.

Around Sky