Opinion Links: Opinion Home Page | Latest Expert Columns | Latest Blog Entries
Karlsson: birdies first play-off hole to beat Fisher and Kaymer
It was not to be and as the resulting play-off was lost, I felt for them as they ambled back to the clubhouse, but their togetherness gave us one of the images of the year.
Ewen Murray
Quotes of the week
When the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship began its life just after the turn of the Century, many said it would fail and the system of professionals playing with amateurs was flawed. Well in the last seven years, it has turned out to be an outstanding success and last week's event was probably the best.
It resulted in a three way play-off involving the form player and two we will hear much about in the years ahead.
Robert Karlsson has always been a model professional and I have no doubts the best of him is yet to come. He starred for our Ryder Cup team in Valhalla and his play this season has been as brilliant as it has been consistent.
He has that gift of calmness under pressure and has the ability to forget things that go against him, instead focussing on what lies ahead. He also has a fine bagman in one handicap golfer, Gareth Lord.
Since they joined forces, Karlsson has enjoyed a golden period in his career and I would expect Robert to challenge for majors and win at least one during the next five years.
In Martin Kaymer, we have part of the future of the Tour. Already two wins under his belt before the Dunhill, Kaymer has the same temperament as Karlsson and with a better putting technique, which I'm sure he will develop in the months ahead, this 23-year-old from Dusseldorf will achieve much in his chosen career.
One should never have favourites when sitting in the commentary booth, but I was hoping Martin would have closed the deal at St. Andrews on Sunday.
Standing on the 18th green, he had a ten footer to win. The cameras cut to his playing partner brother Phil and their dad who was caddying for him. Only months ago, they had lost their mum and wife at too young an age.
It was not to be and as the resulting play-off was lost, I felt for them as they ambled back to the clubhouse, but their togetherness gave us one of the images of the year.
The third member of that play-off has impressed me greatly during the past couple of seasons.
Ross Fisher has turned out to be a superb golfer and his alliance with short game expert, Golf Night's Mark Roe has made him a more complete player.
He is one of the best drivers of a golf ball on tour and his studious mind is one of his strengths. Over the past two years, he has had the odd hiccup combined with two wins and I see him as one of our future stars.
When the dust settled on the Dunhill, Ross and his caddie will be disappointed with their decision to take the driver at the 73rd hole. I could not believe my eyes when they made that choice. He is one of the games longest hitters, so it came as no surprise when the ball hurtled into the famed Swilken Burn.
Before you become the finished article, you have to make mistakes like that, but I know he will learn from it. Its been a great year for him getting married and this week he takes delivery of a gleaming new Lambourgini sports car. He deserves to enjoy the fruits of his labours and I look forward to following his career with interest.
Midgeley Taylor wrote in last week re the Alfred Dunhill Links and suggested one of our commentary team could walk round with an amateur and help him with course management.
Midgeley, if any pro walked round with an amateur, I can assure you he would knock a few shots off their score. It's not just the amateurs, if we had been beside Ross Fisher last Sunday, we would have hidden his driver at the first play-off hole!! Good idea, maybe we can organise that for next year.
Malcolm Speight and Steven Standage, thank you for your kind words and to all of you who enjoyed our coverage of the Ryder Cup and in general our European Tour coverage.
Steven wanted to know about the new Castle Course at St Andrews. Steven, I had a look at that last week and my reports are more than favourable. Designed by David Kidd, it is in many ways like Kingsbarns with considerable changes in elevation on the putting surfaces and stunning sea views. It compliments the collection of courses around St Andrews and will prove to be extremely popular.
Nice to get email from abroad and to Lee Calderwood, we look forward to seeing you at the South African events in December and January. The selection process has worked well for our Ryder Cup side in past years and my thoughts are that we should continue with that process. Good to see South Africa will feature prominently in the new European Tour schedule announced at the beginning of the week.
53 events in next years calendar and the possibility of having the likes of Kim, Mickelson, Villegas and John Daly as members of the European Tour. These are exciting times for Executive Director, George O'Grady, who along with Ken Schofield had the vision to take our tour to the rest of the world. The "Race to Dubai" has caught the imagination of many and the European Tour is about to step into a new era.
Madrid is the venue this week and for many at the wrong end of the order of merit, a chance to confirm their playing privileges for 2009 without a visit to the qualifying school. It's a horrible pressure but one they must embrace and conquer.
I had another birthday this week and having firmly entered the back nine of life, I am going to put the feet up after a hectic few months. Next week is the Portugal Masters from Villamoura and there will be many agendas there.
Top 15 of the order of merit to get into next years majors, some trying to win enough to stay on tour and some trying to get into the final Volvo Masters at Valderamma etc. The battle to become European number one enters its closing stages and the likely winner looks like it will come from Karlsson, Harrington or Westwood.
All good stuff, enjoy Madrid.
Vijay Singh will reportedly undergo knee surgery after the Mercedes-Benz Championship that will sideline him for around five weeks.
Anthony Kim and Camilo Villegas have both backed Tiger Woods to return the dominant player he was before his injury.
Adam Scott admits he learnt a lot from a difficult 2008 and is now looking to make 2009 his most successful year yet.
The 2009 PGA Tour season gets underway on Thursday with last year's winners competing at the Mercedes-Benz Championship.
Asia captain Naomichi 'Joe' Ozaki wants revenge against Europe at the 2009 Royal Trophy.
Comments
Sam Baldwin says...
Not really a comment but a suggestion. I recently played Hoylake and enjoyed every view, shot and hole. I am based in the centre of England and don't get th chance to play sea-side courses. My real moan is that all Open Championship courses are so expensive. Hoylake was only £50 and it was packed! I would love to play the fantastic Open courses but all ask well over £120 a round, and travelling to these places will easily cost £50-£60 so nearly £200 to play their. It's not open to everyday people. I live very close to the Belfry and I can play the Brabazon next week for £40! It's hosted the Ryder Cup!! Deals at these places would be great and give 'normal' golfers the chance to tread the same grass as the greats. To Ewan; I really like your open and honest style when talking about golfing issues. The "humble-pie" comment to America, which I expected to be cut by Sky, took guts and I feel that you have them. i read your article every week and do mirror most of your views. But some fo us are not lucky enough to play the great courses and I feel that I will improve, from 7 hcp, if I can see what the pros play. Cheers and keep up the great work!
Posted 12:39 22nd October 2008
Andrew Norrby says...
Ewen, many happy returns, hope you had a restful week. The Dunhill has evolved into compulsive viewing. Interesting concept sky used this year, concentrating most of their cameras on one course per day. The plus side of this was that Karlson and Kaymer were on full view each day. On the negative side of things we had limited coverage of the likes of Rory McIlroy who had previous form in this tournament and on these courses. I disagree that St Andrews is too 'easy' for these pros. For whatever reason, they seem to touch lucky with the weather every year and play it in benign conditions. When the wind blows the old lady is still a fearsome test! I'm sure you will have something to say about the terrible sounding news coming out of Spain this week regarding Seve. I look forward to some detailed comments about the great man over the next few weeks and like everyone else, hope that his condition is not as bad as is feared. I have enjoyed the Madrid Open this week and think its great to see Olazabal playing tournament golf once again.
Posted 14:05 12th October 2008
Scott Beaumont says...
Happy Birthday Ewen, hope you had a good day. I really do hope the likes of Mickelson come and play the Euro Tour next year as it gives people a chance to watch these superstars up close, but what bothers me more is the fact the the only reason they might come is the lure of the big bucks. What a shame that money is the only reason to play and not the prestige of winning titles. I remember Greg Norman trying to get a 'world tour' going in 90's and wished he had, many people though were not pleased with him for suggesting it but here were are today with in my mind a real chance it might happen. Why not just have both Euro and PGA tour merge and let the guys 'chase the sun' all over the world ?
Posted 10:24 8th October 2008
Brian Tyson says...
Ewen. I'm almost frightened to say this as I know I'll be shot down by every player / commentator / tour official etc. St Andrews may be the home of golf but I don't think its up to major championships. It has the easiest opening tee shot in golf (yes, I know Fisher still blew it), and the easiest finishing tee shot in golf. Where's the pressure standing n the first or last tee. The last two Open Championships held there were the worst ever, whereas the last two at Carnoustie were two of the best ever. The viewing at St Andrews for the fans is also terrible with no-one allowed in to line the fairways and sit around the greens. Why oh why does it get picked every 5 years when the far better courses are only picked every 10. History or not it defies belief for me.
Posted 09:51 8th October 2008
Derek Field says...
The future of the Ryder Cup and The European Tour is in safe hands - what a pleasure it was to witness three young professional gentlemen plying their trade in the playoff of the Dunhill, shame Ross made a mistake - he will not do that again, Martin and Robert both made excellent chips to the 73rd and I guess the rub of the green favoured Robert. What a wealth of talent we have coming through, I can see a time when the US may have to join forces with SA and Aus to compete just as GB & Ir had to welcome in talent from Europe a few years back, it just gets better and better including that amazing technology which enables us mere mortals to see the Pros swing at 7000 frames per second, I also enjoy the skills of the commentators pointing out minor swing imperfections causing the ball to fly a little off the straight and narrow, well done. Derek Field
Posted 08:41 8th October 2008
Steven Standage says...
Ewen, Hope you enjoyed your birthday.! I did say at the time that harrington would be the first european to win a major and I am convinced what I have seen so far that Ross Fisher will be the first englishman to repeat that feat. Ok driver in play off no no no!!!!.. The reason is long of the tee great touch and do you know what he enjoy's the battle. You heard it here first!! Regards Steven
Posted 19:27 7th October 2008
Simon Rourke says...
Firstly, Happy Birthday Ewen! Hope you had a good one! I am always fascinated watching the top pro' s play tough Links courses like Carnoustie and St Andrews, whenver the wind and rain gets up at the weekend I always moan about it and never seem to maintain my swing or composure (although did go round 10 over on Sunday with a howling wind and constant rain!). However, the pros just seem to take it all in their stride and adapt to conditions, always really impressed. Totally agree with your thoughts on Robert Karlsson. What a great player, and he seems a genuinely nice guy with it too so I hope he does win a major or two over the next few years and no doubt he will star for Europe at Celtic Manor in two years time. As for the future of the European Tour, all sounds very exciting and if it attracts bigger names to the tour then that is great news and look forward to Skys coverage - I am a big Phil Mickelson fan (fellow lefty!) and really hope he comes and plays a few more events in Europe, maybe that will put him in good stead to win the Open at some point!
Posted 17:05 7th October 2008
Malachy Wylie says...
Ewen, Being an Irishman i'm biased in the fact that Padraig would be my favourite golfer.. but my question is with every interview he seems to do he mentions how tired he is. I try and understand the mental focus that went with winning the back to back majors, but he did have a few weeks off and surely with his wealth he does get to enjoy the more relaxing pleasures of life. Is there other parts to a touring pro's life that we don't get to see?
Posted 16:23 7th October 2008
Add Comment*
All fields are required