Opinion Links: Opinion Home Page | Latest Expert Columns | Latest Blog Entries
Pollock celebrates one of 421 Test wickets
Along with Glenn McGrath, Shaun Pollock must be the most difficult seam bowler to play of the last generation. He always hit the seam and, if there was anything in the pitch, he could always get the most out of it.
Bob Willis
Quotes of the week
The world of international cricket is about to see the final fling of a player from the absolute top drawer.
Shaun Pollock's Test career ended with victory in the third Test against the West Indies last week and after five one-day internationals against the same opposition, a 12-year and 410-game career will come to an end.
No praise can be too high for him. I can't think of a cricketer who has put so many miles on the clock in such a short international career. He has been the mainstay of the South African side for over a decade - he and Jacques Kallis have been the only major, consistent performers for South Africa for the past ten years.
Along with Glenn McGrath he must be the most difficult seam bowler to play of the last generation. He always hit the seam and if there was anything in the pitch, he could always get the most out of it, as was shown again recently in his final Test against the West Indies the other day.
He got a bit of a bum deal when sacked because of the World Cup debacle in South Africa 2003 when he was captain and miscalculated the number of runs his team needed to beat Sri Lanka and the miscalculation cost his team their place in the tournament.
That incident was probably the only time he anywhere near let his team down but the same can't be said of the other way round. I believe he would have taken more than 421 Test wickets had he played in a better team.
His uncle and, for that matter his father latterly, suffered in their careers because of apartheid isolation. The recent periods of the quota system has meant that South Africa hasn't had its strongest 11 on the field and that must have been pretty hard to take for Pollock as one of their leading cricketers.
But he always played the game in the right way, true to his own spirit and the spirit of the game. While his bowling was from the top drawer it should not be forgotten that he was a very capable batsman, in fact just the sort of cricketer that England has been looking for since Beefy retired.
While England unearthed Andrew Flintoff to step into Botham's boots unfortunately Freddie has not been able to stay fit to occupy them consistently. Pollock barely missed a match for South Africa and that was during a period when they really crammed the fixtures in.
With 108 Tests and 302 ODIs (by the time he has finished) plus some 600 first class and List A games - not to mention 20 Twenty20 matches - he has dedicated a lot of days to cricket in a 12-year period since his debut for South African against England at Centurion back in November 1995.
In his generation he would have to be in the top five among the likes of Courtney Walsh, Curtley Ambrose, Glenn McGrath, Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis - it's too hard to choose five from those six. From South Africa you would maybe include Allan Donald too but he was more value to his team than Donald, because Pollock averaged 32.31 with the bat as well. Mike Gatting only averaged three more runs per knock than that and he was a frontline batsman for England.
The South African board appear to think they are well equipped to move on without Pollock, having left him out for the first Tests of the summer against New Zealand and West Indies, preferring Andre Nel. You couldn't mention Andre Nel in the same breath as Shaun Pollock as far I am concerned.
Andre is an expressive, honest 'tryer' but he has a terrible action and can be like Steve Harmison at his worst on occasions, with the ball going everywhere.
Although Nel isn't anything like the handful that Pollock is on any surface, the South African bowling attack is not in ill-health. Dale Steyn has had an excellent start to his career and a very good summer while Makhaya Ntini is probably under-rated. He gets loads and loads of wickets and at 31 has a few years left in him still.
The tail might prove to be a problem though for South Africa because without Pollock the batting now stops dead at Mark Boucher at seven and you have four number 11s after that. We know from experience in England that is difficult to bear sometimes.
Pollock's future might well be in England next year with some counties rumoured to be interested in taking him on as a Kolpak player for the 2008 season. My hope is that he stops now because I think it is rather sad when players stop playing the international game but feel as though they still want to earn some money playing county cricket.
Top class cricketers should stop playing when they have stopped playing for their country. I am not a fan of Kolpak players - overseas players in any shape or form for that matter - but certainly not when they have given up on the international game.
Shaun Pollock is a great of the game and I hope he bows out as a winner of a Test match in Johannesburg for his country in front of appreciative packed house rather than in front of a handful of fans at a county ground in England for a couple of quid.
Whichever way he finishes, he will always be one of the greatest international players of his generation.
The England and Wales Cricket Board have named Andrew Strauss as their new skipper following a day of turmoil for the national team.
Hampshire batsman Kevin Pietersen has confirmed his resignation as England captain.
West Indies all-rounder Kieron Pollard has been reprimanded after damaging a glass door with his bat.
Australia have left troubled opener Matthew Hayden out of the one-day and Twenty20 squads to face South Africa.
Dominic Cork says that England cricket is in chaos after the ECB failed to clear up the situation.
Comments
Mark Carter says...
Bob is way off the truth about the quota system in the SA side. Every so called 'black' player deserves their place and has proved this by saving many games for SA. The selectors over the years have been inconsistant with their selections and players like Benkenstien and Rudolf never had a long enough run at the top. I do think though, that as good as Andre Nel is, he may find it difficult to get a place when we have ntini, Steyn, Morkel and Harris as the automatic selections. SA has lacked a speedster for long enough, and now we have two. As for Shaun Pollock, we will miss him. He has been an amzing player and still has lots to offer SA cricket if they don't let him slip away like Donald did. Having said this, I do think SA cricket is on the rise and the selectors need to stick to their best team and politics must remain away. An in form SA team could beat anybody.
Posted 10:18 13th February 2008
Riaan Willemse says...
Shaun Pollock will remain one of the best all-rounders that this world has ever seen. Being able to stay at number one as a bowler in ODI's and Test cricket and then of course being renowned for his big hits. Beating Jacques Kallis a couple of years ago in a all-rounder competition, with sixes that Hershelle Gibbs would be proud of, his ability with bat and ball should never be questioned. Just like my father told me about Peter and Graeme Pollock, my kids will know about Shaun, his dad and his uncle. Thank You Shaun!
Posted 14:10 28th January 2008
Roger Cole says...
Morne Morkel is Sean Pollock's natural successor, not Andre Nel. Morne is also a more than capable batsman who will ease into Polly's number 8 test position and will probably end his career averaging more than 30 with the bat too. In fact, now that he has returned from injury, Andre Nel might battle to make the test team. I envisage a bowling attack comprising: Dale Steyn Makhaya Ntini Morne Morkel Paul Harris Jacque Kallis If SA decide to opt for an all seam attack, Nel will get a look in.
Posted 10:14 21st January 2008
David Harrington says...
agree with Bob on all three points: 1, Pollock was a fantastic cricketer and much underrated when compared to a contempory such as Flintoff 2, SA has continually discriminated against white players over the past 10 years. Jacques Rudolph and Martin V-J are two players playing county cricket that should definitely be in the side if they hadn't been forced to retire 3, I too would like to see all kolpaks and all foreigners kicked out of the English game Finally i would like to disagree with Dylan and a few of the other SA comments. Bob Willis is one of the best cricfket writers in the game. He does buckle to popular opinion and is a man of integrity!
Posted 02:57 21st January 2008
Dylan Baxendale says...
Shaun Pollock is going to be greatly missed by SA cricket as well as World cricket, it is a shame to see him go and I wish him all the luck with whatever he does in the future. I would just like to say that I think Boob Ellis has got a bit of a big head and couldn't talk more rubbish if he tried, verything he said about Pollock being brilliant is right, but mocking the SA team about quota's without mentionung any names, idiot. Andre Nel is a much better bowler that what Bob says, he has passion like no other cricketer and is the perfect replacment for Polly, even if he does not bat as well! If Bob knew what he was saying as well as Nel bowls, we would not have to listen to his driffle over and over again, I'm sure there is Somebody better than Bob out there SKY, Bob could never be rated highly thus how can you listen to such rubbish coming out of his mouth, I'm surprised he praised Pollock so much!
Posted 14:15 16th January 2008
Darren Clarke says...
I agree that Pollock has been a top-class cricketer for South Africa for over a decade. It is however, laughable to suggest that he would have taken more wickets playing for a "better" side. South Africa consistently produces pitches that suite the seamers, have a wicket keeper that has taken more dismissals then any other in history and has always had a world-class side in the field. I also completely disagree that our tema selection is influenced by racial quota's. Would someone please name a better 'quota-less' South African test team. Every player of colour in that side deserve their place.
Posted 12:28 16th January 2008
Mark Hancox says...
Willis is quite right SA cricket is going to miss Pollock and I doubt there will another like him for some time to come. The quota system is an unfortunate part of cricket here and Cassiem is partly right except he forgets that it was due to the quota system that Kevin Peterson now plays for England!
Posted 10:10 16th January 2008
Graham Fish says...
South Africa are losing a wonderful cricketer and an exceptional gentleman. He is going to be sorely missed and i hope South African Cricket take good care of him and keep him involved in the game. He started as a roaring speedster and ended as a cunning operator - Shaun Pollock, legend, gentleman and role model to all.
Posted 09:10 16th January 2008
Ierfaan Cassiem says...
Bob Willis is misinformed. How can he say that due to the quota system SA is not fielding its strongest team. Herschelle Gibbs, Hashim Amla, Ashwell Prince and Makhaya Ntini are the black players in the SA test squad. Please name me the "better" players who would replace them. Of the 4 possibly only Gibbs currently does not merit a place in the team. Along with Kallis, both Amla and Prince have been tyhe mainstays of the batting this summer. Ntini is a proven test bowler with over 300 tests wickets. Bob Willis is too far away to make such irresponsible statements.
Posted 07:36 16th January 2008
Denzil Bricknell says...
Refreshing article and a great tribute to a great player. Nice to see Bob addresses real issues like quota systems and Pollock not always playing with the "BEST" SA side. We tend to avoid these "sensitive" issues a lot of the time but they are a reality and the more people speak about them hopefully they will be addressed and I cant wait for the day the "BEST" SA side walk onto the pitch again!!!
Posted 06:52 16th January 2008
Harry Harrison says...
World cricket has lost one of it's greatest players. Shaun is a well respected and well liked player who's skills and competiveness made him one of the greats. I'm not sure what his plans are for the future but who would argue that he would make an excellent bowling coach.
Posted 22:09 15th January 2008
Add Comment*
All fields are required