| Cards | Rating | |
|---|---|---|
| Paul Robinson | 8 | |
| Anthony Gardner | 6 | |
| Pascal Chimbonda | 7 | |
| Paul Stalteri * | 4 | |
| Younes Kaboul ** | 4 | |
| Steed Malbranque |
|
5 |
| Didier Zokora | 6 | |
| Jermaine Jenas |
|
5 |
| Robbie Keane | 6 | |
| Dimitar Berbatov | 6 | |
| Darren Bent *** | 6 | |
| Substitutes | ||
| Radek Cerny | ||
| Ricardo Rocha (17) ** | 6 | |
| Tom Huddlestone | ||
| Jermain Defoe (60) *** | 6 | |
| Wayne Routledge (66) * | 5 | |
| Cards | Rating | |
|---|---|---|
| Tim Howard | 8 | |
| Alan Stubbs | 8 | |
| Joleon Lescott | 8 | |
| Tony Hibbert | 7 | |
| Joseph Yobo | 8 | |
| Lee Carsley | 7 | |
| Leon Osman | 8 | |
| Mikel Arteta | 9 | |
| Phil Neville | 7 | |
| Andrew Johnson | 8 | |
| Victor Anichebe * | 7 | |
| Substitutes | ||
| John Ruddy | ||
| Phil Jagielka (79) * | 5 | |
| Nuno Valente | ||
| Steven Pienaar | ||
| James McFadden | ||
| Player | Rating | Club |
|---|---|---|
| Mikel Arteta | 9.3 | Everton |
| Joleon Lescott | 8.6 | Everton |
| Leon Osman | 8.5 | Everton |
| Tim Howard | 8.4 | Everton |
| Joseph Yobo | 8.4 | Everton |