Skip to content

Harry Kane, Mohamed Salah or Sergio Aguero? Who will win the Premier League Golden Boot?

Who will win the race to become this seasons top Premier League goalscorer
Image: Who will win the race to become this season's top scorer?

Harry Kane, Mohamed Salah and Sergio Aguero are battling it out for Premier League's Golden Boot but who will win the accolade? We asked the Soccer Saturday pundits for their verdict.

Two-time holder Kane leads the way again on 23 goals and is naturally considered Sky Bet's favourite in the top goalscorer betting with 11 games remaining.

Premier League top scorers so far in 2017/18

Harry Kane Tottenham 23
Mo Salah Liverpool 22
Sergio Aguero Man City 21
Raheem Sterling Man City 15
Jamie Vardy Leicester 13

However, Salah, on 22 goals, and Aguero, with one less, are hot on the England star's heels and are given 3/1 and 7/2 chances of finishing top of the charts.

Here's who Soccer Saturday pundits Phil Thompson, Paul Merson, Charlie Nicholas and Matt Le Tissier are backing...

Thommo says: Harry Kane

I'm sticking with my pick from the start of the season. Manchester City look set to go far in the Champions League so when Gabriel Jesus is back he'll share the minutes with Aguero. Salah will give them a good run but he tends to score single goals whereas Kane gets a lot of hat-tricks.

Sadio Mane (L),  Mohamed Salah (C) and Roberto Firmino (R) have been in excellent form for Liverpool
Image: Mohamed Salah has led Liverpool's lethal three-pronged attack

It is just absolutely phenomenal what Salah is doing though. We haven't seen a winger score this amount of goals since Cristiano Ronaldo was in the Premier League. It looks extremely close and I actually wouldn't be surprised if Salah has missed more good chances than Kane, who is just clinical.

Top goalscorer odds
Top goalscorer odds

Who will top the goalscoring charts? Find Sky Bet's odds here.

Merse says: Sergio Aguero

I know Aguero won't be playing as many minutes as the others with the Champions League becoming the focus for Manchester City, but I don't know anyone else who can get four goals in a match on multiple occasions. Manchester City score bundles of goals so I've just got to go with him.

Also See:

Sergio Aguero scores Manchester City's third goal
Image: Sergio Aguero put four goals past Leicester

I think Salah is in contention but it's a big ask for a winger to do it. He's not an out-and-out centre-forward so it would be a phenomenal feat for him. Kane has proved he can score big goals in big games but Tottenham don't blow teams away like Manchester City.

Fantasy Six-a-Side
Fantasy Six-a-Side
Fantasy Six-a-Side

Think you can beat Merse's team? Pick yours for free to win the £50,000 jackpot here.

Charlie says: Harry Kane

It is very hard to look beyond Kane. He's so consistent in just picking up goals every week. Not only does he get lots of goals against the lesser teams but he also scores in the big games now.

Harry Kane scores the opening goal of the North London derby at Wembley Stadium
Image: Harry Kane scores the winner in the north London derby

I always think Aguero has that danger of a hamstring injury looming if he plays too many games, so Pep will want to protect him for other competitions as they go for the quadruple. Salah could be clear of the other two with the chances he's missed, but I think if you were going to have a bet on it then you couldn't look beyond Kane.

Le Tiss says: Harry Kane

When Jesus comes back then I think Aguero's match time will be significantly less than Kane's. Salah is on such a run that you cannot rule him out, but as a winger you wouldn't expect him to be in as many goalscoring positions.

Harry Kane poses with the 2016/17 Premier League Golden Boot
Image: Harry Kane with the 2016/17 Premier League Golden Boot

If Aguero was going to be the first choice for every game for the rest of the season I would nudge towards him. However, if I could sign one player to come in and save Southampton, then I would go for Kane as he is a better all-round striker with his ability to hold up the ball and win physical battles.

Super 6 £1m jackpot
Super 6 £1m jackpot

Simply predict six correct scores to win Jeff's £1 million. Enter your selections for free here.

Around Sky