Blogs & Opinion


Cardiff promotion is fitting reward for Malky Mackay, says Jeff Stelling

Plymouth Argyle - Jeff Stelling Posted 18th April 2013 view comments

As a player Malky Mackay was never daunted and embraced a never-say-die attitude.

Those same qualities have stood him in good stead as Cardiff manager and I'm delighted he has won promotion to the Premier League.

Malky has succeeded where many managers have failed in the 51 long years since Cardiff were last in the top tier, and as a big club it's good to see them back there because a capital city needs to have representation in the Premier League.

Malky Mackay: centre of attention after guiding Cardiff back to the top flight

Malky Mackay: centre of attention after guiding Cardiff back to the top flight

With League Cup winners Swansea doing themselves proud in the top flight, these are great times for football in south Wales - and what an atmosphere there will be when those two rivals go head-to-head next season!

You can always rely on a Welsh crowd to give their side fantastic support, whatever the sport, and Cardiff is going to be a difficult place for any side to go to - just ask any of the Championship sides who have made the trip there (with the exception of Peterborough!).

Cardiff have been the best team in the Championship by some distance. Mind you - and this is not to tarnish their success at all - it has been a pretty ordinary league this season.

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

Generally speaking they've earned promotion without spending loads of money. They did bring Frazier Campbell in during January but on the whole Malky has stuck with players he trusts to deliver.

It will be interesting to see if that remains his mantra this summer.

Famously, Malky won promotion as a player with three different sides but was jettisoned twice without playing a game in the top flight before he finally got there with Watford.

I wonder how that will affect his transfer policy? Will he look back and think that he doesn't want his players to go through the same experience and give them the chance? It certainly seems to be more 'en vogue' as the way to go now.

Ambition

Under Malky's management Cardiff have become well-organised and they stuck to their style of play even when they had a couple of wobbles during the season.

In my view, they've been the best team in the Championship by some distance. Mind you - and this is not to tarnish their success at all - it has been a pretty ordinary league this season.

Peter Whittingham - a midfielder I've always liked - was a key player for them early on in the season and he scored some very important goals, although they did rather dry up.

Likewise Heidar Helguson hasn't scored many in the second half of the season but has always been a decent target man to have up front.

When he's in the side, Craig Bellamy is still explosive and is capable of making a difference. I know it has always been his ambition to play for Cardiff in the Premier League and I hope he does.

Difficult

Cardiff will almost certainly take the place of Reading, QPR or one other in the Premier League.

There has been plenty of talk this week about which players QPR will have to get rid of to reduce their wage bill if that scenario transpires.

While I have some sympathy for Harry Redknapp, who came into the job at an impossible time, I do think Rangers should thank their lucky stars that the dice are loaded between the Premier League and the Championship in such a way that the teams that go down can have a great chance of coming straight back up.

I say that because the further down the leagues you go, the dice are loaded against that happening. It applies to any club but just indulge me for a moment and look at Hartlepool as a classic case in point!

For most of the season we've struggled to balance the amount that we are allowed to spend on players' wages and transfer fees as a viable percentage of our turnover - an amount we can't exceed.

When you drop down a division, as we're about to do from League One to League Two, the percentage of your turnover that you are allowed to spend on players decreases so clubs that are relegated have to reduce their wage bill immediately - and are not even on a level playing field with the sides in the division that they are going down into.

The long and the short of it is that Hartlepool will have to reduce player wages by a certain percentage before we're allowed to start signing players again.

The players that we most want to hang on to are the ones we are most likely to lose because their hand is being forced by the Financial Fair Play at that level, which means that they have to sell their few prized assets.

A lot of Hartlepool fans have asked me this week if we'll come straight back, which we did the last time we were relegated. But it's darn difficult if you know that you might have to do it without key players like Luke James, Jack Baldwin and Scott Flinders - players who clubs at a higher level will certainly be looking at.

It will be very difficult to hang onto them.

Jeff's Gem of the Week

Plymouth are not quite safe yet but they've given themselves a fantastic chance after winning five games in seven, including the midweek 2-1 victory away at Chesterfield. I thought John Sheridan was pretty harshly treated when he lost his job at Chesterfield but he's proving once again that he is a high-quality manager who perhaps deserves a chance higher up. Hopefully he'll get that chance one day because somehow he's transformed Plymouth's fortunes without funds or goal-scorers! Jason Banton's loan spell produced six goals but he has now returned to Crystal Palace and none of Plymouth's permanent staff have got more than five - yet somehow Plymouth have conjured up these victories. Home Park is a proper football ground and it would be nice to see the good times back.

back to top

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Sociedad draw on Moyes debut

Real Sociedad earned a 0-0 draw against Deportivo La Coruna in David Moyes’ first match in charge of the team.

Premier League round-up

Manchester United climbed into the top four in the Premier League with a 2-1 victory at Arsenal.

United punish wasteful Arsenal

Manchester United hit Arsenal on the break at the Emirates to earn a 2-1 win - their first away victory of the season.

Souness: Arsenal so vulnerable

Man Utd exploited Arsenal’s vulnerability to counter-attacks to score a crucial win, says Graeme Souness.

Messi sets goalscoring record

Lionel Messi has set a new La Liga goalscoring record after netting a hat-trick in Barcelona’s 5-1 win over Sevilla.

Features

Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard's form at 34 sees him making fewer goals, tackles, interceptions and runs

Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard's form at 34 sees him making fewer goals, tackles, interceptions and runs

Last November, Steven Gerrard spent this international week captaining England to a Wembley defeat against Germany. A year earlier there was the 4-2 reverse in Sweden as Zlatan Ibrahimovic had his wicked way with Ryan Shawcross and the rest. Maybe Gerrard wasn’t missing it too much.

Premier League: Liverpool still struggling to learn the lessons from their 3-3 draw with Crystal Palace in May

Premier League: Liverpool still struggling to learn the lessons from their 3-3 draw with Crystal Palace in May

If Liverpool’s limp attempts to claw their way back onto level terms against Chelsea saw them sleepwalking to second spot, the implosion at Selhurst Park was the moment they woke from the dream.

Hull v Tottenham: Three Tigers players fired up to face former side Spurs on Super Sunday

Hull v Tottenham: Three Tigers players fired up to face former side Spurs on Super Sunday

Tottenham will come up against three familiar faces – and three men with a point to prove – when they head to Hull on Super Sunday.