Blogs & Opinion

Feeling Blue

Beags responds to your Football League posers...

Rochdale - Peter Beagrie Posted 24th January 2013 view comments

Peter Beagrie is here every week on answering YOUR Football League questions.

The former winger, who played over 770 games, representing clubs in all four tiers of the English footballing pyramid, including Manchester City, Everton, Bradford, Sheffield United, Scunthorpe, and Grimsby, forms part of the Sky Sports punditry team for all the big matches in the Championship, League One and League Two.

Butland: the Birmingham custodian could be sold during the transfer window

Butland: the Birmingham custodian could be sold during the transfer window

So if you have a poser for Peter, whether it's about your team, a player, match or incident that has caught your eye, or a wider point on the Football League, make sure you send it in.

Read below for this week's column where Beags gives his take on Birmingham's travails, Fraizer Campbell's Cardiff switch and John Coleman's sacking from Rochdale...

Send your question to Beags

1. Mail them to

2. Use the feedback form at the bottom of this page

Hi Peter, What do you make of the situation at St Andrew's? Cheers, Steven Cale (Birmingham City fan)

BEAGS SAYS: Stability and Birmingham have not often gone hand in hand. Blues used to be run by the Kumar brothers, when big investment never materialised due to their businesses going into receivership, and while there was relative normality for the club when under the stewardship of Davids Sullivan and Gold and Karren Brady, that trio were replaced by Carson Yeung, Hong Kong's version of Walter Mitty, who was arrested for money laundering, meaning the Blues are now haemorrhaging money, and have revealed that they will sell any of their first-team squad at the right price. Star strikers Bob Latchford and Trevor Francis have been sold in the past to balance the books and if a proposed takeover by former QPR chairman Gianni Paladini does not bear fruit, I think that will happen again this time. An asset like Marlon King (pictured) could go, as could the underperforming and exorbitantly-paid Nikola Zigic, though as both are 32, they would not command a big fee - but Jack Butland and Nathan Redmond would. Birmingham have been the biggest underachievers in the Championship so far this season, in my opinion - a big statement when you consider the form of Wolves, Blackburn and Bolton - and the fact that Blues have won just one game from a losing position this season and recorded four back-to-back loss sequences, shows a lack of character, spirit and application and for that reason, I think a squad that is good enough to be in the play-off shake-up will finish closer to the bottom three than the top six.

Hi Peter, Could you tell me why Colchester are on such a bad run? Also, who do you think we should sign? Thanks, Jordan Allston (Colchester United fan)

BEAGS SAYS: An eight-game winless streak at the start of the season was quickly forgotten due to five wins from the next six, during which time the U's kept four clean sheets. However, one shut-out in the last 13 games has seen Essex troop register a paltry three points from 39 - and lose their last nine games on the spin. I think Colchester lack experience in vital areas as well as creativity and for that reason I see the United, who have netted just nine goals on the road this term and lost at home to relegation rivals Scunthorpe last time out, struggling to stay in the division. Clinton Morrison and Freddie Sears will score goals if given better service, while the permanent signature of Jabo Ibehre (pictured) from MK Dons may be the catalyst to push Colchester up the league and secure League One safety, though they will need an experienced centre-half and to hold on to the sough-after Anthony Wordsworth, too.

Hi Peter, Cardiff have just signed Fraizer Campbell for a very reasonable, in my opinion, £650k from Sunderland. Do you think he will be a good addition to Malky Mackay's squad? Thanks, Rhys Lewis (Cardiff City fan)

BEAGS SAYS: As Malky has signed Campbell, you can rest assured that he will be an asset, as the Cardiff boss' transfer dealings have, without doubt, been the reason City sit 10 points clear at the top of the Championship. Fraizer (pictured) has a proven track record in the second tier, having starred for Hull during the promotion season and laying on the winning goal in the play-off final against Bristol City for Dean Windass, and I think it is a snip acquiring a 25-year-old England international for the fee you mentioned, Rhys. I think Mackay is responding to narrow 1-0 wins over Leicester, Millwall and Birmingham and a goalless draw with Ipswich, and the ages of Heidar Helguson and Craig Bellamy by capturing Campbell, who has the ability to play central or out wide. The best bit of business Mackay has conducted, though, is trying Peter Whittingham down to a new contract, no doubt via the promise that the midfield maestro could captain the Welshmen in the Premier League should they get there, which is looking extremely likely at the minute.

Hi Peter, Do you think John Coleman was unlucky to lose his job as Rochdale manager? Barry Hastings (Accrington Stanley fan)

BEAGS SAYS: I do think John was unlucky, but I also think he was a victim of circumstance, that circumstance being the sudden availability of Keith Hill, the man who ended Dale's record-breaking run in the fourth tier of English football, which stretched 41 years, by getting them promoted to League One in 2010, a feat which prompted his move up the footballing ladder to Barnsley. Rochdale have plenty of attacking thrust with Dele Adebola, Ashley Grimes, Terry Gornell and Bobby Grant regularly testing opposition 'keepers, but there were also defensive negatives under Coleman's tutelage with on seven occasions this season the club scoring twice and not winning. The Spotland side's hierarchy must think Keith can tighten up at the back without compromising the attacking style and garner some upward momentum after four straight defeats. Dale are only six points off the play-offs, though, so we will have to wait until the end of the season to see if sacking Coleman was justified, and it certainly will be if Keith gets the team promoted again.

Hi Peter, Sheffield United have slipped eight points behind the automatic promotion places in League One after failing to win any of their last four games. What do you put the slump down to? Thanks, Mike Galloway (Sheffield United fan)

BEAGS SAYS: These are times of concern for Danny Wilson and his boys as United had reached the halfway stage playing well and in a great position to kick on and cement an automatic promotion place, but Doncaster, Brentford and Swindon have now bypassed the Blades, who now sit fifth and have Bournemouth on their tails, too; it is going to need a massive effort from the Yorkshiremen to avoid the potential heartache of the play-offs once more. It has been evident of late, during losses to lowly Hartlepool and resurgent Yeovil that they are playing with pressure and need a tonic, which may or may not be in the shape of a win or good performance against Reading in the FA Cup. I was worried when United registered more than one goal just once in their opening nine fixtures, but am more concerned now as their four defeats have come in their previous 12 matches and this current four-game winless streak has seen them ship eight goals. There are plenty of games to go but anything short of six points from the next two, at home to Coventry and Crawley, will heap more pressure on my former club.

Hi Beags, Neil Warnock is an amazing manager but I think his contract should be terminated and we should get a new, young, manager in who can take us to the Premier League. What do you think and who could that young man be? Also, could Luciano Becchio cut it a team like Norwich or Wigan? Cheers, Morgan Spencer and Em Kem (Leeds United fans)

BEAGS SAYS: I will comment on the first part of your question, even though I don't think it needs answering, as I expect Warnock to be at Elland Road until the end of the season at least. However, Nigel Adkins (pictured) will be in the minds of many Championship chairman; the recently-axed Southampton boss has many recent promotions, both with the Saints and Scunthorpe, plays attacking football and is a media man's dream. Plus, if Leeds want to look outside of the box, Brentford boss Uwe Rosler could be a candidate; the German is tactically astute, has tremendous attention to detail as far as preparation is concerned and is incredibly driven. Like I said, though, the Whites should maintain Warnock's services - and loosen the purse strings so that he can sign a game-changing wideman, something Leeds have lacked since Robert Snodgrass and Max Gradel departed. Becchio, who has handed in a transfer request, is having a very good goal-scoring season - 19 in all competitions at the time of writing - and is big and strong, too, but I don't think he is a Premier League player; his link-up play is not good enough and he is a couple of yards short of pace for the top division.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Ryan Deeney (Birmingham City fan) says...

Hi, Peter. While I agree with your sentiments about Blues currently, when you look at the injury list we've had this season culmilating in a lack of consistency in team selection forced upon Lee Clark, it goes some way into showing why we are where we are. During the season we've very rarely had a settled midfield with Burke losing form, Mullins, Diop, Fahey, Ambrose, Spector and Gomis all getting injured at some point. Morrison isn't disciplined enough to play a midfield role properly meaning that the likes of Callum Reilly have been thrown into the mix. Then in defence, Caldwell has lacked form, Ibanez has been injured, Carr and Murphy are out for the season meaning Will Packwood and Mitch Hancox have been thrown into the XI. Then recently over Christmas we had no strikers! While I don't like using the excuse of injuries, it's clear that we are a club currently that isn't just lacking in funds or the ability to sign players, but we're also lacking consistency in team selection, player form and a winning mentality. The young lads have done an excellent job with the club but they need the right guidance. Have to say that the next week will be vital for our season. Jack Butland, Curtis Davies, Marlon King, Nikola Zigic, Nathan Redmond... will they stay or will they go?

Posted 11:24 25th January 2013

Russell Hill (Birmingham City fan) says...

Re: your comments on Birmingham - finally somone who is saying it like it is - we are vastly under performing even with the injuries we've had. Given those injuries, we shouldnt expect to be challenging at the top, but a team with Butland, Davies, Burke, King, Zigic, Lovenkrands in it should NOT be battling relegation. One man to blame for that, the clueless Lee Clark.

Posted 10:13 25th January 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Pellegrini: One team wanted win

Manuel Pellegrini believes Chelsea did not set out to win from the beginning against Manchester City at Stamford Bridge.

Sturridge: Great to be back

Daniel Sturridge spoke of his delight at being back in the Liverpool team after he scored on his first outing since August.

Live transfer updates

Follow the latest transfer news and gossip, as Darren Fletcher's proposed move to West Ham breaks down.

Paper Talk

Dortmund's Marco Reus is heading to Arsenal, Man Utd still pursuing Marquinhos, plus more gossip from the papers.

Sky Live: Arsenal v Aston Villa

Arsenal are looking to win their third game in a row against a struggling Aston Villa side.


Manchester City left to rue a wasted opportunity after dominating Chelsea clash...

Manchester City left to rue a wasted opportunity after dominating Chelsea clash...

Manchester City dominated Saturday's title clash at Stamford Bridge but were left to rue a wasted opportunity to close the gap, writes Matthew Stanger...

Arsenal v Aston Villa: Alexis Sanchez's absence would give Mesut Ozil and Theo Walcott vital game time

Arsenal v Aston Villa: Alexis Sanchez's absence would give Mesut Ozil and Theo Walcott vital game time

Alexis Sanchez's hamstring injury gives Arsene Wenger the opportunity to give invaluable minutes to Mesut Ozil and Theo Walcott against Aston Villa...

Five conclusions from Chelsea's 1-1 draw with Manchester City at Stamford Bridge

Five conclusions from Chelsea's 1-1 draw with Manchester City at Stamford Bridge

Matthew Stanger draws five conclusions from Chelsea's draw with Manchester City, which leaves the Blues with a five-point lead at the top...