Blogs & Opinion

Dundee will struggle to win Sunday's derby with United, says Andy Walker

Dundee United - Andy Walker Posted 3rd December 2012 view comments

Unfortunately, the SPL can't offer any Celtic v Rangers games this season so the Highland derby involving Inverness Caley Thistle v Ross County, the Edinburgh derby between Hibs v Hearts and the Dundee derby take on added significance.

Our live SPL clash this week takes us to Tayside where Dundee have the perfect opportunity to show they're not out of their depth in Scotland's top-flight when they host city rivals United in the second derby of the season on Sunday.

Barry Smith: needs more from McBride and Conroy, says Andy

Barry Smith: needs more from McBride and Conroy, says Andy

At Tannadice in August, Peter Houston's men were comfortable 3-0 winners in the first Dundee derby for seven years - it threw up a fabulous atmosphere - and it's fair to say that it's taken Barry Smith and his men some time to cope with the demands of life in the top-flight.


Winning just 11 points from 15 games has left Dundee adrift at the foot of the table but nothing would give the home side a bigger boost in their quest for survival than a victory over their greatest rivals.

Having seen United play recently, Dundee will be well aware that their bitter rivals have a questionable attitude in how they've started recent games.

Andy Walker
Quotes of the week

Granted, Dundee had a very short time to prepare for life in the SPL after Rangers were placed in the third Division and the harsh reality is they've had to learn quickly that it can be an unforgiving league.

They'll remember they started at Tannadice really well but couldn't maintain that form and were soundly beaten in the end. It's always a sore one for the fans to take when the margin of victory is so great and revenge will be on the players' minds.

Rab Douglas, Matt Lockwood and Colin Nish provide the type of experience that Barry Smith relies on for big performances but he needs to see more from Kevin McBride and Ryan Conroy.


Having seen United play recently, Dundee will be well aware that their bitter rivals have a questionable attitude in how they've started recent games.

Speaking to Peter Houston last week after seeing his men lose two goals in the opening 10 minutes of a 2-1 home defeat to Motherwell, he couldn't understand why his side kept giving the opposition a goal of a start.

In four of their previous five games they had gone behind and had made life so difficult for themselves.

In his words, it had gone "beyond a joke" and they certainly had a better attitude when they beat Stranraer 5-0 away from home in the Scottish Cup last weekend.

Dundee are also through after their away success at Livingston but more importantly, Barry Smith's men kept a clean sheet.

With Jon Daly and Johnny Russell in attack, United have a potent threat and even allowing for their bizarre habit of conceding the first goal, they do have a greater number of options from middle to front.

Gary Mackay-Steven will be missing through injury but John Rankin & Stuart Armstrong have the energy to constantly get up in support of their strikers.

My guess is that United's greater experience of big games will see them come out on top once again.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Redknapp

Redknapp - United's Galacticos

Jamie Redknapp says Manchester United may emerge as the new “Galacticos” after their heavy spending....

Guillem Balague

Balague - Falcao wanted Real deal

Guillem Balague says Radamel Falcao spent the summer desperately trying to join Real Madrid....

Alan Smith

Smith - Welbeck exit sad for United

Alan Smith says many Man Utd fans would be upset to see Danny Welbeck move to Arsenal....

Latest News RSS feeds

Transfer Deadline Day

Radamel Falcao in Man Utd loan deal, Arsenal land Danny Welbeck, QPR sign Sandro and Hull bring in Hatem Ben Arfa

United finalise Falcao loan

Manchester United have signed Monaco striker Radamel Falcao on a season-long loan with an option to buy.

Arsenal wrap up Welbeck deal

Arsenal have signed Danny Welbeck from Manchester United for a fee believed to be in the region of £15-16million.

Deadline Day done deals

Keep up to date with all the completed deals with our list of all the movers on Transfer Deadline Day.

QPR complete Sandro deal

QPR have completed the signing of Tottenham midfielder Sandro for an undisclosed fee.


Transfer deadline day: Hit or miss?

Transfer deadline day: Hit or miss?

Every fan hopes their club can produce the best signing of any transfer window. Sometimes a new arrival can indeed prove to be a masterstroke but sometimes that latest signing can also develop into an expensive mistake.