Blogs & Opinion

England can secure historic series win in India even if Steven Finn is ruled out, says Mike Atherton

Features - Michael Atherton Posted 12th December 2012 view comments

Alastair Cook can lead England to a long-awaited series victory over India this week in Nagpur, the city where he scored his first Test ton on debut nearly seven years ago.

The ground may be different - the Vidarbha Cricket Association Stadium has hosted only three Tests since 2008 - but given the prolific form Cook is currently in, you wouldn't bet against England's captain to produce more of the same and steer the tourists to their first series win in India since 1985.

Steven Finn: bagged 3-45 in India's second innings in Kolkata but is now a doubt

Steven Finn: bagged 3-45 in India's second innings in Kolkata but is now a doubt

Back then David Gower's side went into the final Test in Kanpur 2-1 up having fought back from a heavy defeat in the opening Test. They arrived at the ground to find a belter of a pitch and, happily for Cook's men, Nagpur looks like it will be pretty flat too. Gower on 1984/85


After their crushing Kolkata victory, all augurs well for England although the news that Steven Finn will have to pass a fitness Test on his back if he is to play is an immediate concern and perhaps one for the future too.

The present set of circumstances begs the question whether Meaker should have stayed with the squad even once Finn was declared fit to play at Kolkata

Mike Atherton
Quotes of the week

The seamer looked like somewhere near his best form in Calcutta, where he bowled quickly and straight and got the ball to reverse nicely. Back in the side, he will have seen that game as a springboard to establish himself as one of England's frontline bowlers.

So it will be a blow if he misses out this week and another setback in what has already been a stop-start career. England would love to have his pace here on a pitch that is very, very hard and has cracks all over it - solid, abrasive cracks that will help the ball to reverse.

That said the outfield is as green and lush as I can remember an outfield being in India, so that will counteract any reverse swing.

Any time you hear of a young fast bowler with a back problem alarm bells start to ring in your mind and you ponder the question 'is something in his action putting strain on his back?'

The good news is that Finn's action looks pretty solid to me; rather than being all over the crease, he bowls in straight lines and he doesn't bowl with a 'mixed' action either. His is a well-grooved, repeatable action so let's just hope that this problem is a one-off strain rather than any long-term issue.


Surrey's Stuart Meaker - in India with the Performance Squad - was on stand-by for the third Test and I would be surprised if he's not called into the squad now because in terms of pace and reverse swing he's Finn's natural replacement, even if he is shorter and more skiddy.

The present set of circumstances begs the question whether Meaker should have stayed with the squad even once Finn was declared fit to play at Kolkata? By keeping him and sending either Tim Bresnan or Graham Onions away, England would then have had replacements for each type of bowler.

If Meaker is not called up then I suspect that England will probably go for Bresnan, who lost his place after the opening Test defeat in Ahmedabad - a match in which he looked pretty innocuous.

Bresnan will be itching to get back into the side but it has to be said that he's not looked as sharp recently as he did on England's 2010/11 Ashes tour when he came in for Finn. Ever since he had a slight elbow injury his pace looks a bit down; he's not been hitting the pitch or the bat as hard and I think that was the look of it in Ahmedabad, even allowing for the fact that it was a very flat pitch.

Bresnan has been around the team more than Onions, who I think is a very, very good bowler - he's lively and bowls from close to the stumps.

Apparently Onions bowled so-so in the warm-up games but otherwise hasn't got overs under his belt and the fact that he hasn't played in such a long time might just tilt the selectors towards Bresnan, whose batting also lengthens the lower middle-order.

We'll have to see if Stuart Broad, dropped for the third Test and now ruled out of the fourth with a bruised heel, recovers in time for next week's Twenty20 internationals.

It's been a difficult tour for him so far with injury and illness, plus one or two spats with the media along the way, hampering his progress. He has yet to take a wicket, too, so a skipper he'd love the chance to get back onto the pitch and turn things around.


The more pressing question, in terms of this week's Test, is can India turn things around?

The selectors have made changes to the squad but these are neither sweeping nor seismic and have the distinct whiff of 'muddling along'.

That cannot be right for a side that has lost 10 of its last 16 Tests and, it has to be said, looked distinctly ragged in Kolkata.

Not only was some of the running between the wickets pathetic, but the standard of fielding was bordering on the bizarre with players gesturing for each other to chase the ball.

Amid the action it's easy not to dwell on such small incidents but those in charge of Indian cricket must dwell on them and more importantly address them, otherwise the astonishing decline of a side that not so long ago topped the world Test rankings will surely continue.

Catch day one of the fourth Test between India and England from 3.30am on Thursday on Sky Sports 1 HD.

back to top

Other Experts:

Latest Posts in :

Alex Ferguson

Clowney's no joke

US sports expert Alex Ferguson profiles Jadeveon Clowney, the biggest defensive pick of the draft....

Alex Ferguson

King James reigns

Alex Ferguson celebrates a wacky, smile-inducing year in US sport - and salutes Miami's LeBron James....


Alex Ferguson

Start your engines!

Alex Ferguson predicts who will triumph in NASCAR's showpiece race, the Daytona 500....


Alex Ferguson

A perfect union?

Alex Ferguson looks at the possible unionisation of college football and how he would handle the issue....

Alex Ferguson

Call of the century

Spacemen Portland pick Bowie over Jordan - Alex Ferguson ranks the biggest decisions in US Sport....


Alex Ferguson

Independence aces

Alex Ferguson kicks off his Independence Day fun by picking his 20 best bits of American sport....


Jamie Redknapp

Everton come unstuck

Man Utd's men with a point to prove can take advantage of Everton's midweek blow, says Jamie Redknapp....

Paul Merson

Merson's predictions

Paul Merson says Liverpool WON'T beat Norwich - and Chelsea and Man City will close the gap....

Ed Chamberlin

Van the man?

Ed Chamberlin explains why Tejay van Garderen is capable of plucking the Tour de France's Yellow Jersey....


Jamie Carragher

Bruce almighty

Steve Bruce deserves a mention when this year's managerial awards are handed out, says Carra....

Dewi Morris

Heart and soul

Dewi Morris looks at a crucial weekend in the Championship as we head towards the play-offs....

Stuart Barnes

Ups and downs

Stuart Barnes says the drama of relegation must be kept in rugby, but the play-offs need changing....

Phil Clarke

To Hull and back

Phil Clarke looks at the mental damage done to Hull FC and Huddersfield in the Challenge Cup....

Bob Willis

Away for a while

Bob Willis thinks Jonathan Trott will be absent from England duty for some time following his latest setback....

Rob Lee

Pinky and perky

Rob Lee blogs on his vivid Masters Breakfast attire and the men that made waves at Augusta National....

Mark Petchey

Fillip for Ferrer

Mark Petchey marvels at David Ferrer's win over Rafael Nadal but downplays it's long-term significance....

Barry Cowan

Heavy burden

Great Britain's best Davis Cup since 1986 fails to mask their reliance on Andy Murray, says Barry Cowan....

Alex Hammond

Just Cause

Alex Hammond reveals her tips for the Irish Grand National and the other decent racing in Ireland this weeend....

Alex Hammond

Going the distance

Marathon entrant Alex Hammond previews the Newbury action and Scottish National meeting at Ayr....

Alex Hammond

Rocky's road

Alex Hammond explains why she is backing Rocky Creek and Lion Na Bearnai at the Grand National....

Johnny Nelson

The best of friends

It will be tough but Johnny Nelson expects mates Anthony Crolla and John Murray to serve up a classic....

Glenn McCrory

Manny happy returns

Manny Pacquiao is back to his best and could yet get it on with Floyd Mayweather, says Glenn McCrory....

Johnny Nelson

Delighted for DeGale

James DeGale's Matchroom switch is the perfect move to get him back in the mix, says Johnny Nelson....

View from America

Desperate deals?

Simon Veness reviews a crazy week in the NFL's free agent frenzy, as sides splash out over $1bn....


Neal Foulds

Trump tip

Ronnie O'Sullivan is favourite for the Worlds - but Judd Trump could spring a shock, says Neal Foulds....

Neal Foulds

Night at the Circus

Neal Foulds is looking forward to another fun, raucous Snooker Shoot-Out - but can't pick a winner....


Neal Foulds

Simply the best?

Five-time Masters champion Ronnie O'Sullivan may be the best snooker player ever, says Neal Foulds....


Kelvin Tatum

The contenders

Kelvin Tatum runs through the teams and riders ahead of the 2014 Elite League Speedway season....

Kelvin Tatum

Kelvin's 2013 Review

Kelvin Tatum salutes Poole's hierarchy and Tai Woffinden in his round-up of the speedway season....


Kelvin Tatum

Rich re-Ward

Poole, and the dynamic Darcy Ward, will wrap up the Elite League title at Perry Barr, says Kelvin Tatum....


Richard Moore

The final curtain

Richard Moore reflects on Sunday's Closing Ceremony to an unforgettable Olympic Games......


Richard Moore

A lasting golden glow

Richard Moore suggests all the British Olympians should visit schools and talk about their experiences....


Richard Moore

Favourite Froome

Richard Moore reveals his predictions for the 100th Tour de France, which starts on Saturday....


Wayne McCullough

Wonderful Davis

Wayne McCullough watched Antonio Rogerio Nogueria take on Phil Davis at UFC Fight Night 24. ...


Wayne McCullough

Jones shines bright

Wayne McCullough was highly impressed as the talented Jon Jones made short work of Mauricio Rua....


Wayne McCullough

A bloody marvel

Wayne McCullough salutes Diego Sanchez as he edges out Martin Kampmann in a UFC humdinger....