Blogs & Opinion

NZ v ENG: Visitors kicked poorly, crumbled defensively, and were too gung-ho

Features - Stuart Barnes (Rugby Union Expert & Columnist) Posted 15th June 2014 view comments

It's Sunday night in Christchurch as I sit here in my hotel room and England's Under 20 team has just thrashed Ireland and made it to the Under 20 final to defend the title they won last season.

It is some consolation after England's hopes of a second Test victory in Dunedin were dented by a combination of All Black brilliance in a thirty-minute burst in the second half and - alas - tactical ineptitude of the worst kind.

Marland Yarde has ample quality but kicked aimlessly against New Zealand, says Stuart

Marland Yarde has ample quality but kicked aimlessly against New Zealand, says Stuart

Excellent for the first ten minutes, England drove New Zealand, squeezed them, kicked a penalty and scored a try as Marland Yarde burst through the tackle of none other than Richie McCaw. The All Blacks, captain and all, were struggling against the direct power of the English game.

By half time England's lead had been cut to 10-6 but the writing might as well have been written in graffiti on the Dunedin roof that covered this superb pitch. The All Blacks looked more and more dangerous as the game got quicker and quicker.

The running lines were lacerating as England's much-vaunted defence crumbled against the quality of their opposition.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week


Third Test
8am, Sat, Sky Sports 1

England kept long instead of into touch. Yarde, in particular, kicked thoughtlessly to Ben Smith and the deadly All Blacks back three. The winger is inexperienced and will improve for the evening but England has to think, not just execute, a better kicking game.

What England's aimless and inaccurate long kicking was trying to achieve remains impossible to work out. England needed to be tighter as they got looser, they needed to slow New Zealand down as they offered them attacking opportunity, one after the other.

The floodgates burst as Julian Savea, Ben Smith, Ma'a Nonu and Conrad Smith provided some magnificent touches and performance. In particular, Ben Smith and Savea were superb with the full back doing for New Zealand what he does at his home ground for the Highlanders.


England played as if they didn't know what was coming; the home crowd and those of you regular Super Rugby followers certainly did. The running lines were lacerating as England's much-vaunted defence crumbled against the quality of their opposition. For thirty minutes New Zealand were as good in Dunedin as they had been in Ellis Park against South Africa last year and that is very good.

There is no shame losing away from home to such a team but England should take scant consolation from the character and commitment that helped them finish with their heads held high. New Zealand walloped England for half an hour and England needed them to ease off to cut the differential on the scoreboard.

Credit the visitors with bravery and courage and commitment but don't think for a minute that is enough. For those who believe these very English virtues can turn the tide it is worth pointing out that New Zealanders as a race are not exactly short of similar qualities. And therein is the problem. To beat New Zealand on a regular basis England has to find a way to close the gap in class.

That something' is not the blind madness of taking the All Blacks on at their own game; it is a tightened game and utilisation of the size and power.

The All Blacks and the press talked about England wanting to slow the game down in Auckland. At times it appeared England almost wanted to prove their critics wrong.

England will need tempo to beat New Zealand but it must be controlled and on their own terms. Saturday was a lapse into sporting insanity.


This England team cannot match the New Zealanders for talent and basic skills. They must control the terms in Hamilton, which brings me back to semi-final win against Ireland.

A scrappy second half but a masterly first forty in which England drove hard and tight. Overpowered their opposition and played almost exclusively to their strengths. The senior team should watch the youngsters first forty minutes to see how a game should be managed and physical superiority translated into points.

Elsewhere it was a bad weekend for Wales as South Africa, inspired by Willie Le Roux, thrashed them. The match sent two clear messages - one, that South Africa is definitely the second best team in the world at present and two, that Wales, without a few key players, are a struggling side. Warren Gatland's team are going to need a clean bill of health come the World Cup.

Australia, the other giants in the so called 'Pool of Death' were not as impressive as the previous week in beating France 6-0. Australia will see the performance as a retrograde one despite the result.

France is a fading force under the erratic lead of Philippe Saint-Andre, so it was left to Ireland to restore European pride in Argentina in what was another grim Southern Hemisphere weekend for the Northern challenge.

back to top

Other Experts:

Latest Posts in :

Alex Ferguson

Start your engines!

Alex Ferguson predicts who will triumph in NASCAR's showpiece race, the Daytona 500....


Women's cricket

Kate Cross blog

The England Women star reflects on the ODI series with New Zealand and some stunning panoramic views....

Barry Cowan

Murray back to his best

Andy Murray's semi-final win over Tomas Berdych was almost a 'complete performance' says Barry Cowan....

Barry Cowan

Too tough to call

Andy Murray is in impressive form but Tomas Berdych is showing real class, says Barry Cowan....

Jamie Moore

Blackpool shock?

Jamie Moore goes through the eight-strong Prizefighter line-up and of course, picks his winner....

Neal Foulds

Selby steel

New world champion Mark Selby's the master of match play, says Neal Foulds - but what's next for Ronnie?...


Neal Foulds

Trump tip

Ronnie O'Sullivan is favourite for the Worlds - but Judd Trump could spring a shock, says Neal Foulds....


Neal Foulds

Night at the Circus

Neal Foulds is looking forward to another fun, raucous Snooker Shoot-Out - but can't pick a winner....


Kelvin Tatum

'Poole inspirational'

Kelvin Tatum reflects on the 'most exciting' season he can remember - and Poole Pirates' heroics......


Kelvin Tatum

Back on track

Lakeside can make it two wins over Belle Vue Aces in four days, says Kelvin Tatum, but it'll be close!...


Kelvin Tatum

Hit the road

Swindon are struggling this season but will fancy their chances at Birmingham, says Kelvin Tatum....