Blogs & Opinion


The state of play

Scots shaping up nicely - and what chance the French in the final?

Stuart Barnes - Stuart Barnes Posted 22nd August 2011 view comments

England may have had the weekend off from playing but the team's analysts would have been busy with so many of their pool rivals in action.

I did the dutiful over the weekend and watched both Scotland and Argentina's effort but the highlight has to be the three minute YouTube coverage of Romania's match with Ukraine.

Never has a three-minute clip revealed so little about a game other than the fact that the weather was good in Lviv and Romania ran out 41-16 winners away from home. As they say, a win's a win. Scotland managed a second win in Edinburgh against an Italian team that played with a little more ambition than we are used to seeing.

Quicker game: Mike Blair impressed as Scotland upped the pace

Quicker game: Mike Blair impressed as Scotland upped the pace

In fact the first half was a decent game before substitutions took their toll on the game and it limped to a weary conclusion. Quite why teams lose all shape when substitutions are made is a minor mystery that critics and supporters accept without a second's thought.

These squads have been together all summer and you would think that replacements would be able to slot into a side without the disruption that has been occurring in these last few weeks.

Rory Lawson is a favourite of the coach but it is under Mike Blair that Scotland's attack is at its sharpest. Nick De Luca and Max Evans were also penetrative with Graeme Morrison playing the anchor role in midfield. Throw in the Lamont brothers at full tilt and Scotland have the makings of a decent side. South of Hadrian's Wall rugby watchers knowingly discuss their lack of gain-line penetration but they are not the only team in Britain struggling in this department.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

The first half would have made interesting viewing for Martin Johnson and his mates. Scotland's glaring weakness was a scrum that struggled to keep its foundations solid. England will target this aspect. That was the greatest concern from a Scottish perspective. The rest of the news was more promising.

Andy Robinson is moulding a handy back row that - on paper - is at least a match for England's while it's line-out is another area of strength. Nathan Hines and Alastair Kellock were formidable. Richie Grey will start against England and Robinson will have a tantalising choice between the rugged graft of Kelly Brown, the regular blindside, or Nathan Hines; his off-loading skills could prove as useful as his line out expertise.

Scotland tried to play a quicker game with Mike Blair impressive. The choice of the starting scrum-half is equally fascinating. Rory Lawson is a favourite of the coach but it is under Blair that their attack is at its sharpest. Nick De Luca and Max Evans were also penetrative with Graeme Morrison playing the anchor role in midfield.

Throw in the Lamont brothers at full tilt and Scotland have the makings of a decent side. South of Hadrian's Wall rugby watchers knowingly discuss their lack of gain-line penetration but they are not the only team in Britain struggling in this department. The scrum is the real Achilles heel however.

Argentina's scrum wasn't as dominant as they might have hoped against Wales. Put that down to the return of Adam Jones, arguably Wales's most important individual. If he can hold the scrum together Wales has the capacity to produce a good tournament effort. He played the part well enough on Saturday.

Formidable

Elsewhere Argentina managed to control the ball for most of the first half without testing the front line of the Welsh defence. There were neat touches but nothing explosive. In addition their failure to take their points during the long periods of territorial control is a major worry.

England and Scotland have players equipped to take points whereas Felipe Contepomi is not a kicker on whom a team can rely. If they cannot score tries and kick all their points it is hard to see them escaping this tricky pool.

They will definitely improve but they must find some men to open up a defence and find a guaranteed goal kicker. Until these questions are answered they must be seen as third favourites. I wish I could offer something on Georgia but I can only suggest they will have a formidable scrum and some hard men.

From the viewpoint of Wales, their ability to strike with ball in hand was encouraging but they have to ditch this habit of playing without the ball for long periods. As South Africa are first up they must find a huge improvement in their overall forward play and their work at the breakdown has to be another class to anything yet seen.

I write that because Heinrich Brussow showed his influence for South Africa in victory over New Zealand. His work at contact is as good as anyone on this planet. There was no Richie McCaw opposing him but the fact that the Free State's Test record against the All Blacks is played four, won four, tells you all you need to know.

Versatility

Beat the All Blacks at the breakdown and they can be beaten on the scoreboard. Brussow's return to fitness is great news for the Springboks but not so wonderful for Wales. Sam Warburton should be preparing himself for the test of his career.

Behind the scrum it wouldn't have been a surprise if Lee Byrne's slump from the heights of his 2009 form is not confirmed with omission from the Welsh squad. Rhys Priestland's ability to perform at Test level and Leigh Halfpenny's versatility - not to mention James Hook's capacity to play 15 - gives Warren Gatland a range of options for full back. He might prefer another forward to aid his hand up front where options are not as good.

Across the Irish Sea, the French hoodoo over Ireland continued. The home side started and finished well but in between were way too lateral. They have some work to do behind the scrum. The consecutive losses to France mean victory against England becomes extremely important.

We can talk up the importance of momentum pre-tournament but Ireland's morale will not be in a good place before they encounter Australia unless they can beat a side they beat as regularly as France beats them.

These psychological hang ups are deeply bizarre. If Ireland plays as they did to prevent England winning the Grand Slam they will travel with plenty of confidence, especially with France in the other side of the draw!

Psychologists

As for France, there are signs. They have power up front, penetration behind, a range of goal kickers and in Francois Trinh Duc an aggressive fly-half who can challenge defences and make space for genuine talents like Maxime Mermoz.

At their best France appear the most complete of the European challengers but if events go according to theory they will England in the quarter final and France do not like facing England, whereas England will fancy themselves against France no matter how unimpressive they have been to date. Maybe we should be analysing the strengths and weaknesses of the World Cup psychologists; they could be the Bletchley Park of 2011.

The World Cup squads are being announced today; I'll be back to focus on the English squad announcement in particular and seeing if anyone will be as desperately unlucky to miss out as that outstanding Clermont Auvergne loose head, Thomas Domingo. Fabien Barcella is obviouly fit and raring to go.

What price a repeat of the only other final played in New Zealand in 1987 and New Zealand facing France for the second time in a month? Just a thought...

Comments (3)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Shaun Drinan says...

as an irish fan i worry deeply about our chances @ rwc 2011! ! in fairness we might pull off 1 big performance in the tournement, but 2 or 3 is a big ask ...we r limited to the xtreme & even the lesser teams will sniff out r demise!! i think france showed us the way but im not sure if kidney is truly up 2 the task of taking this team forward 2 any great heights other than wat he,s achieved already! iv been following the super rugby very closley this season & it speaks volumes of we're we need 2 be...80 minutues of pure intensity..with guile & a cutting edge!! could be a bleak fairwell 2 our talisman...prove me wrong guys!!

Posted 00:36 25th August 2011

John Carlisle says...

I think this time that France will stuff England comprehensively - especially if Ireland beat them on Saturday. However, if you and Dewi, in particular, are prepared to accept some criticism, may I say that i am disappointed in your analysis of England's flaws. You discuss many things, including lack of imagination etc., but none of these are as fundamental as the backs' inability to take the tackle, pass out of it and RUN ON TO THE GODDAM BALL - fast! I have waited about two years for you tell me why they don't do this. Can you please tell me now.

Posted 18:24 22nd August 2011

Phil Samson says...

What a shocker! Whereas the other home nations are happy to inform the general public of their respective RWC squad selections without overstated pomp & ceremony, the RFU decide to make us wait until the corporate members are comfortably seated and sufficiently fed and watered before allowing us the privilege to witness the announcement 'Live on RFU.com'. Having enjoyed sharing the guesswork and anticipation of this announcement with like-minded supporters of the game I feel extremely let-down by the selfishness of the RFU who's reaction I anticipate to be "well we said the 22nd August but we didn't say what time". Same old - same old, the supporters will watch anyway! Makes you proud to be English!!

Posted 16:32 22nd August 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Stuart Barnes

Streak slips away

New Zealand fell short of an historic record but England Women had plenty to smile about, says Stuart Barnes....

Latest News RSS feeds

Toulouse crush Castres

Toulouse made it two wins from two at the start of the Top 14 season with a bonus-point 35-6 victory over Castres.

Mafi bids Tigers farewell

Tonga international forward Steve Mafi has thanked Leicester Tigers after being released from his contract.

New Zealand v Australia: Teams

New Zealand host Australia at fortress Eden Park on Saturday in the second match of the Rugby Championship series.

Argentina v S Africa: Teams

South Africa travel to Salta to take on Argentina looking to maintain their perfect start to the Rugby Championship.

Carnegie appoint Mercer

Yorkshire Carnegie have appointed former New Zealand rugby league international Gary Mercer as their new head coach.

Features

Tommy Bowe on Ulster's pre-season and rivalry with Leinster

Tommy Bowe on Ulster's pre-season and rivalry with Leinster

Ulster ace Tommy Bowe says the club's rivalry with Leinster drives the players on.

Rugby Championship: Springboks top the table after round 1

Rugby Championship: Springboks top the table after round 1

The Rugby Championship, featuring the three best sides in world rugby, kicked off over the weekend with South Africa the only team to record a victory.

Try of the week: Vote for your favourite

Try of the week: Vote for your favourite

England Women were crowned World Champions while the ITM Cup, Top 14 and Currie Cup kicked off with some electric tries.