Blogs & Opinion

Stuart Barnes:

Most Popular Posts:

'Lions strong at breakdown and gain line against Barbarians'

Stuart Barnes Posted 3rd June 2013 view comments

Weekend one of the Lions tour and it was definitely one for the Lions over the Wallabies as we move rapidly into Australia and towards the Test series.

Those regular Rugby Club viewers will have seen and heard me take the unwelcome (but not irregular) position of pantomime villain, predicting a 2-1 series win for the home side.

Now much as I like (and have some capacity after years of experience) changing horses in midstream, I have to remind viewers that, whilst tipping my head over my heart, there has always been the stated proviso that a lot can happen between pre-tour tipping and Test matches.

Cool customer: Lions wing Cuthbert will threaten the Aussies, says Stuart

Cool customer: Lions wing Cuthbert will threaten the Aussies, says Stuart

The 2-1 verdict was predicated on a series being played as and when the prediction was made. A few weeks on and things have changed.

Some key players appear to be coming to the boil; others are unfortunately heading in the wrong direction from the perspective of their respective coaches.

The Lions negotiated the substantial challenge of the elements and the sadly less-imposing one of the Barbarians with plenty in hand.

When the physical shape of the Welsh lads and the football skills of the Irish come together, something special could brew.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week


Lions v Western Force
10.30am, Wed, Sky Sports 1 HD

As a scene-setter for putting a few training ground patterns into place and finding a solid shape from which they can launch a substantial bid for glory, it could not have been much better.

This may sound surprising. "Has Barnes gone native after spending nearly a week in the same hotel as the squad?" I hear you say.


Well, the manner in which management and players have conducted themselves so far on and off the field has been a credit to them, although the management has had to put long hours into the Lions drinking tradition to cover for a new generation of professional rugby athletes.

So, maybe I am getting a little soft but it was the power of the second-half performance that impressed me most.

Brilliant at the breakdown when they needed to be, experimental and eventually successful at the line out and potent on the gain line; all this and a high level of intensity, Andy Farrell's favourite word of the moment, combined to make the Hong Kong trip a beneficial beginning to the tour.

The players appear to be in great shape. After watching a light session here in Perth, my niggling worry is that line-out throwing could become a problem in need of solving.

Richard Hibbard struggled in admittedly awful throwing conditions, while Rory Best's accuracy disappeared through the Six Nations and Tom Youngs is finding it hard to find his rhythm.

Best and Youngs did a session between themselves and the Leicester man appears to have difficulty putting the throwing body and arm back together. But there is a long way to go and plenty of time for these guys to find their range as long as they find their mental edge.

Other than that the sight of Jamie Roberts, George North and Alex Cuthbert in full stride must have caused Robbie Deans the odd furrow.

Yes, Australia have a great record against Wales and the style of the team is visibly Welsh but when the physical shape of the Welsh lads and the football skills of the Irish come together, something special could brew.


Rob Kearney's fitness is a worry but other than that all is in good shape.

It is a tremendous shame Michael Foley, the Western Force coach, has seen fit to prioritise on his team's final Super Rugby match of the season against the Waratahs than giving the locals a full-strength team to throw the kitchen sink at the Lions. Hopefully there will be stronger challenges ahead of the first Test.

A tour needs meaningful and exciting rugby en route to the Test matches. Australia are already clear that their Test squad will not face the Lions before the series, let us hope the other sides field their best available sides otherwise the tour could become a truncated test series which is not the essence of Lions tours.

Warren Gatland wants tougher matches. It helps harden up the team and make the right selections. The latter point was a substantial factor behind the Lions' first Test loss to South Africa four years ago as Sir Ian McGeechan readily admits the management selected a wrong front row. These are small clouds on what has been a fine looking horizon.

The clouds are darker for the Wallabies. The rugby nation is being drawn up along battle lines in the 'should Cooper play or not' debate.

It is the only question Australian journalists ask me when we meet. The Aussies fear a wrong call here could be their undoing but at least that is in the hands of Deans.


The loss of Scott Higginbotham is a terrible blow and one of those awful, unfortunate things that happen in sport, as 'The Rebel' was back to his blockbusting best and shaping up as a key Wallaby.

He is out of the series while Timani, the Waratahs lock is another weekend injury blow of some proportions. Throw in the doubt surrounding George Smith and Digby Ioane and suddenly the pendulum swings back the way of the Lions. Right now the visitors look the likelier winners but we are still nearly three weeks from the first Test, a lot can happen.

The highlight of the coming week will be the much hyped battle between Quade Cooper and the Lions with some thinking Deans would like the Lions to make it easier to leave the maverick playmaker out by wrecking his game.

Lining up against him will be Sam Warburton. A captain who has missed the first two games will be as keen to make his mark as a certain Queensland ten. It is going to be a riveting week.

So long from Perth and it's gently fading late afternoon sun. Next week I will report back from Newcastle. By then we will be another two matches nearer the Test.

How far will the pendulum swing in the space of the next seven days?

Stuart answers your emails...

Got a question for Stuart? Email him at or use the feedback form below...

Morning Stuart, I've just seen the team to play on Wednesday. How big a blow would it be for the Lions if Rob Kearney doesn't recover from his hamstring problem? Worried John, Westmeath

STUART REPLIES: John, Rob is undoubtedly a great player at his best, but the Lions have another full-back whose form has been outstanding all season in Leigh Halfpenny. His goal kicking makes him the favourite for the 15 shirt and with Stuart Hogg bursting with potential one has to say it would be an injury the Lions could certainly survive, although I am desperately hoping the Leinster man has a chance to show his brilliance. I am a big fan but the position makes a sad early departure a more painful blow for the individual rather than the collective.

Hi Stuart, Hope you're enjoying Hong Kong. I wondered how much you know about Western Force back row forward Ben McCalman. Can't say I'm that familiar with him, but with Australia's injury problems mounting it sounds like he could have more of a role to play as the tour progresses. Many people seem to be saying that this could be one of the most physical Lions tours ever. Do you agree and, if so, where does the balance of power lie between the two teams? Cheers, Tim, Billericay

STUART REPLIES: Perth now and it's a little more cool and sedate than HK but I love the energy of the place. McCalman, a tough, grafting forward who will probably be bench at best. The issue is not who is in but who is out. Scott Higginbotham has been immense this season and linking his absence to the question of power, the balance swung the Lions way this weekend but the scales are far from settled yet, Tim.

Hi Stuart, How big a role do you see Mako Vunipola playing on the Lions tour? Will this trip be more of a learning experience for him or can he oust some of his more experienced peers from the starting 15? Thanks, Jackson Thorpe

STUART REPLIES: Jackson, I think Vunipola is going to learn a lot this tour but I do not see him ousting Cian Healy from the Test starting XV but as for the Test bench, that is a distinct possibility if he keeps us his second-half display as witnessed in Hong Kong.

Watch every Lions game live only on Sky Sports. To sign up or upgrade click here.

Comments (4)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Dennis Morgan says...

Stuart, should the Lions have had a penalty try when the ball was knocked from Owen Farrells hands in the act of scoring a try. The player who dislodged the ball was the tackler, who was still in contact and had not released and got to his feet. So penalty try and bin? Without the foul play there was no doubt that a try would have been scored.

Posted 09:29 9th June 2013

James Baillie says...

Stuart, quick question about your new hair guru, Adam Jones. No doubt about it, a quality scrummager. I do feel your praise during the BaBa's game was a little overstated. By any chance, did you watch the Glasgow v Ospreys game at the end of the season? Adam Jones got a decent seeing over by Ryan Grant, who was bizarrely overlooked for the Lions. I can only imagine Warren Gatland did not see the game. Must be the unluckiest player not to be on the plane. Anyway, my question is what hairstyle did Adam suggest you get?

Posted 15:12 5th June 2013

Mat Davies says...

Stuart Mike Philips has started 5 of Wales´ last six games against Australia. They lost all of them and he failed to score in any match. Given the Aussies have a history of nulifying his running game, is he the right man to start at 9 for the tests?

Posted 01:13 5th June 2013

Ruaidhri Duddy says...

Hi Stuart, what are your thoughts on extending the premiership to 14 teams and having two teams relegated and promoted? Similar to the system in France. Ruaidhri

Posted 17:11 3rd June 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Add Comment*

Send us your views

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Latest News RSS feeds

Barnes: Plenty to play for

Stuart Barnes says England's clash with Ireland could be a Six Nations decider, but the other games must not be forgotten.

Vunipola calls for intensity

Billy Vunipola says England will need to match the intensity they showed in Cardiff when they face Ireland in Dublin.

Williams facing nine months out

Leicester Tigers fly-half Owen Williams has been ruled out for nine months after having surgery on his knee.

Prop Welsh out of Six Nations

Scotland will be without prop Jon Welsh for the rest of the RBS Six Nations Championship.

Goode to join London Irish

Former England fly-half Andy Goode will leave Wasps to join fellow Aviva Premiership side London Irish next season.


PRO12 Highlights

PRO12 Highlights

Watch all the highlights of this weekend's Guinness PRO12 action.

Six Nations in pictures

Six Nations in pictures

We bring you the best action shots from the second weekend of the 2015 Six Nations.

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Worcester coach Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre against Italy.