Blogs & Opinion

Stuart Barnes: Irish provinces are in pole position to challenge Clermont Auvergne

Stuart Barnes Posted 19th January 2014 view comments

Round six of the Heineken Cup started with a 36-3 win for Leinster on Friday night. It ended with a 28-3 triumph for Clermont Auvergne on Sunday evening.

The Irish team left their home ground with what they required to qualify and Clermont departed with the bonus point win to push them up to second seeds and with it, all-important home advantage.

The top and tail games were similar affairs. In both instances the scoreboard failed to register the commitment of the well-beaten opposition. In both games cards played a deciding role in eliminating any prospects of a shock away win. Ian Evans was red carded early at the RDS and Racing Metro saw a trio of players yellow carded in the Auvergne.

Ruan Pienaar: magnificent for Ulster

Ruan Pienaar: magnificent for Ulster

Even with such handicaps some credit should go to the teams that had nothing but pride for which to play for. There have been times in this tournament when the weaker team hasn't managed that. Despite the scorelines, Ospreys and Racing Metro defended with heart and left this season's competition with heads held high.

In between these comfortable wins, Leicester and Ulster fought out the best and most significant game of the weekend. Ulster overcame the Welford Road factor and left as deserving winners. Their defence, spirit and rugby nous is impressive. The reward for them is huge. It is not that Saracens will be easy, far from it, but it means they avoid Clermont Auvergne away. Clermont have gone 71 games without their flag being lowered at home. It is not mission impossible for the Tigers who need the match-winning assets of Manu Tuilagi in a hurry, but it is the toughest of the Heineken Cup draws.

Revenge for Ulster

Avoiding Clermont is some reward for Ulster and their magnificent scrum-half, Ruan Pienaar. From being the outsiders they will be favourites to inflict revenge for the defeat at the hands of Saracens in last season's quarter-finals.

Munster proved the biggest winners of the weekend. The odds were on Toulon, Clermont and Toulouse all doing what they needed to do to qualify for the three other home ties alongside Ulster or Leicester

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

Saracens themselves dismissed any chances of a shock home defeat at the hands of Connacht with a veritable rout. It was a slick performance but it did nothing to answer the questions that surround Saracens against the powerful French sides. Beating mediocre opposition and being physically smashed by strong teams are two different worlds.

Ulster, it is noted, are not French and Saracens have beaten them at this stage within the last twelve months but that was in England. This time they are in Belfast and Ravenhill will finally be completed. It makes a din when the place is a building site, when complete it will be some psychological advantage for them. Saracens are not afraid on the road but with the statistics of the Heineken showing the home teams win three of the four quarter-finals, they have to start as underdogs, albeit ones with a better shot at an away win than Leicester who have the odds stacked against them.

Munster proved the biggest winners of the weekend. The odds were on Toulon, Clermont and Toulouse all doing what they needed to do to qualify for the three other home ties alongside Ulster or Leicester. Toulon eked out a satisfactory win in difficult conditions to head home for the quarter-final but it was in Italy where the shock scoreline - not result - sent Munster into seventh heaven.Scoring just the one try against Zebre, Toulouse wasted much of the good work from the previous week when they devastated Saracens. So often so good at home, so often so awful on the road, they gave Munster a chance to pinch that fourth home tie which Munster were always going to do. They don't do a complacent attitude, they do what they have to and against Edinburgh they played with conviction and a determination to score the four tries. They did it with something in hand and will now play Toulouse in Limerick. I would not have written them off in France but suddenly, instead of a puncher's chance, the semi-final is in their hands. Toulouse won the game but they may have blown their chance.

At the end of our coverage on Sunday afternoon, Alex jovially apologised for sending them on the road in the semi-final. I wouldn't be so sure about that. They face the winners of Toulon versus Leinster. Whilst home advantage favours the French, Leinster has the game and the self-belief to beat the reigning champions. Leinster are the likeliest team to be the one in four away winners. If that happens the semi-final will be at new Lansdowne Road - where it would have been had Munster been drawn at home!

With the winners of Ulster or Saracens facing Clermont or Leicester in either Ireland or England, I would make a tentative guess that we could be in store for an all-Ireland set of semi-finals, with Clermont the only non Irish semi-finalist.

Amlin Cup

In the Amlin, Harlequins and the Scarlets produced a fine game in difficult conditions. Harlequins' reward is no sort of reward at all, a trip to second placed Top 14 team, Stade Francais. Still, Quins have history beating Stade and they have realistic hopes although the French, with a good Amlin record has to be the favourites. Bath, playing some sweet rugby on Thursday against an outclassed Bordeaux Begles team, should beat Brive while Wasps against a slowly resurging Gloucester and Sale against Northampton are compelling English clashes.

With the dust settled it seems that England's clubs still look short of the highest level. With five of their six strong contingent filling the best runners up spots and the three Amlin qualifiers there is nothing wrong with strength in depth in the top to middle ranks of the English game, but three French and three Irish teams standing tall as the top six seeds tells its own tale of the current state of affairs on the field.

Comments (3)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Paul Hickey says...

Munster have yet to peak this season. They haven't fired on all cylinders yet. I'm biased, but I think they'll find their game in the Rabo and beat Ulster in the final. They owe Ulster like they owed Edinburgh and they say "you don't beat Munster twice".

Posted 04:42 23rd January 2014

Matt Graham says...

Dear Stuart i find it infuriating when referees and commentators do not pick up on Adam jones binding on the arm, i can honestly say i cannot remember a single scrum when he has bound on the shirt and remained bound on the shirt. before the new srum laws Adam jones used to grab the opposing props tricep and roll his elbow inward to destablise and collapse the scrum, now because you have to bind first (if the refs on his side of the scrum ) he binds on the shirt then changes to the tricep grap once engaged. if the oppostion prop is getting the better of him, he simply belly flops, drops the scrum giving the ref the impression of "just a slip" i cannot believe he is so revered by you whilst every scrum he is kidding the ref.

Posted 10:06 21st January 2014

Adrian Callanan says...

Stuart, this QF line-up all but highlights how Irish clubs seem to be getting things right while hanging onto key player(SOB). Why are we seeing the Welsh clubs still feeling the pinch in Europe when they have as much quality as the Irish clubs. It leads me to think, money while being what the Welsh/English want, its the priceless thing of heart & guts that money cant buy and what the Irish sides have an abundance of...Agreed? They should focus on getting some soul (Leicester sure do) in they clubs than money!

Posted 08:31 20th January 2014

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Jonathan Davies

Davies: The need to succeed

Jonathan Davies talks about the Wales squad and his team's winner-takes-all clash with Saracens this weekend....

Stuart Barnes

Barnes: Inspirational Bath

Stuart Barnes looks at the latest round of Champions Cup matches and what it means for the final round this weekend....

Latest News RSS feeds

Fitzgerald: Leinster a threat

Leinster centre Luke Fitzgerald has issued a warning to the Europe's big guns ahead of the Champions Cup quarter-finals.

Sky Live: Munster v Sale

Team news for Sunday's European Rugby Champions Cup Pool 1 meeting of Munster and Sale Sharks at Thomond Park.

Clermont v Saracens: Teams

Team news for Sunday's crucial European Rugby Champions Cup clash between Clermont Auvergne and Saracens.

Cockerill: Best side won

Richard Cockerill was frustrated with Leicester after a 26-7 defeat at Ulster ended their Champions Cup campaign.

Jones calls it a day with Wales

Adam Jones has announced his retirement from international rugby union with Wales.


Six Nations: Paul Wallace believes Joe Schmidt delighted with Ireland's strength in depth

Six Nations: Paul Wallace believes Joe Schmidt delighted with Ireland's strength in depth

The concentrated strength of talent in the Irish squad is a credit to the work Joe Schmidt has done for Ireland, says Paul Wallace.

Live European rugby on Sky this weekend

Live European rugby on Sky this weekend

Sky Sports will bring you the best of European rugby action from a crucial final round of pool fixtures as we broadcast six live games.

The Off Load: Rupert Cox's best and worst from the last week in the world of rugby

The Off Load: Rupert Cox's best and worst from the last week in the world of rugby

Rupert Cox shares his highlights from the week's rugby action in his round-up blog...