Blogs & Opinion

Phil Clarke:

Most Popular Posts:

Recent Comments:

Trevor Fuller on Running on empty

"Hi Phil, Another interesting & thought-provoking article here! One thing I'd like to know is, if you compare this situation currently with clubs in the NRL in Australia or New ... " View all comments

Quality over quantity

If we fix the play-off system will fans come, wonders Phil?

Phil Clarke Posted 19th September 2012 view comments

After waiting for seven months the play-offs are finally here and I'd give week one about a 50 per cent score.

We had two good games and two one-sided events which has led to several questions from readers like the one from Peter Handley, who asks: 'Is it right to have a top eight play-off in a 14-team competition?'

Wigan on their way to victory over Catalans

Wigan on their way to victory over Catalans

Well, 50 per cent is a relevant figure as you only need to win half of your games to make the play-offs.

The Super League clubs have decided that eight teams should qualify and the fact that Leeds won the competition last year after finishing fifth seemed to justify to some that the play-offs format worked.

It is interesting that when we first introduced a play-off format to find the Champions we actually used the top five teams to find the winner. This was later expanded to six and then to eight.

We need to reward success and excellence and seem to have moved away from this in an attempt to attract more supporters from more clubs. It does not seem to be working.

Phil Clarke
Quotes of the week

I have written on this website before that in my opinion that sets the pass mark of entry too low. We need to reward success and excellence and seem to have moved away from this in an attempt to attract more supporters from more clubs. It does not seem to be working.

Attracting the crowds

A friend of mine, currently working in the States, was back in the UK last weekend and decided to travel up from London to watch Wigan take on the Dragons last Friday. He had seen the game the St Helens v Wigan the week before and couldn't understand why there'd been three times as many supporters at a league game compared to the play-off contest with Catalans.

I felt slightly embarrassed by the crowd and the game. The match lacked atmosphere and the Dragons seemed to lack effort. How do we solve this?

The suggestion made by Peter is one of several that should be debated. I know that several people feel that we need to reconsider this but the clubs have already decided that the top eight is the way that they want to operate for at least the next few years. If that is the case, and we do seem to chop and change so often in rugby league, then we need to find a way of packing the stadiums.

Got a question for Phil? Email him at or use the feedback form at the bottom of the page...

Hi Phil, I wondered what your view is on Super League referees having such a different view on games? Leeds and Wakefield players throw punches and the ref laughs and says calm down, no cards. Wigan and Saints players throw punches and the referee at the time sent three players off which completely ruined the game for both sets of fans. Surely referees are given the same training on how to handle fighting in a game without ruining the match?
Simon Madden

PHIL REPLIES: Simon, I don't have any referees on my Christmas card list but I do respect the effort that the put in to being the best that they can be. Nobody is perfect and neither are the 10 men who have controlled the 193 Super League games that have taken place this year. There have been times when one referee has interpreted and penalised one decision differently to one of his colleagues, but the number of these gets less and less each year.

If you don't believe me then take a look at some old tries on YouTube. I recently watched a try at Wembley in the 1970's when the try scorer was offside from the kick and nobody even thought of it. Their awareness and preparation is 10 times better now.

Without going into every incident of foul play and fighting this year I think that the refs are now correct in sending players from the field if they deliberately punch or strike an opponent in the head. The game needs to set the right example.

Not only do referees receive the training, but they also get as much, if not more, feedback on their performance than every player in Super League. Their number one goal is to be consistent, even if they don't achieve this. I am not sure which team that you support Simon, but the game when Wigan and St Helens had three players sent off at the Etihad Stadium was over as a contest well before the punch up at the scrum.

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Kev Webster says...

In response to Phi'ls comments and the comments of Tony Smith(warrington coach) made to the press earlier this week, I would like to piont out that warringtons was, in my opinion, the worst display of any of the play off teams last week end and goes to show that league position is not a guarantee of play off success. The current format was also voted for by 13 of the 14 teams in super league at the time of introduction. I also think it gives a chance for 1 or 2 of the less fashoinable teams in super league to gain extra revenue and more exposure on the "big stage". I am very happy with the current format and hope it stays like this for the forseable future and hopefully the experience that my team Wakefield have gained this year in the playoffs helps them to move forward as a club both on and off the pitch.

Posted 15:53 21st September 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

A Super finish

Phil Clarke picks his most improved player of the Super League XIX season, but do you agree?...

Barrie vs Terry

Barrie v Terry

Barrie McDermott and Terry O'Connor go head-to-head with their Super League predictions......

Latest News RSS feeds

A Super finish

Phil Clarke picks his most improved player of the Super League XIX season, but do you agree?

Escare extends Catalan stay

Full-back Morgan Escare has signed a new four-year contract with Super League club Catalan Dragons.

O'Loughlin wary of threat

Wigan captain Sean O'Loughlin is mindful of the danger Huddersfield pose ahead of the Super League playoff.

Whitehaven appoint Deakin

Whitehaven appoint former Catalan Dragons boss Steve Deakin as their new head coach.

Dragons sign Carney

Catalan Dragons have announced the signing of controversial Australian half-back Todd Carney on a three-year contract.


Super League Play-offs set for scintillating start

Super League Play-offs set for scintillating start

After one of the tightest Super League seasons ever, the top eight enter the final stretch this Thursday as the play-offs get underway.

Sky Sports reviews the week in sport with the best and worst performances

Sky Sports reviews the week in sport with the best and worst performances

Some big prizes were handed out this week but, as always, for every gloating winner there are a number of losers counting their losses.