Blogs & Opinion


Beauty and the beast

Wembley disappoints but London Welsh delight, says Dewi

London Irish Posted 19th September 2012 view comments

After two weeks of great rugby we were let down by a pretty boring game at Wembley when Saracens and Leicester drew 9-9.

It is still early days and there is a heck of a lot of rugby still to be played but this was disappointing from both sides. They played within themselves again - playing no-rush rugby because they can control it.

First win for London Welsh

First win for London Welsh

We have seen some of the beauty of the Premiership but we have also seen some of the beast of it. I know you have to have balance but from a spectators' point of view it is not what they want to see.

They were like two heavyweight boxers who knew each other so well that the defences were up before a punch was thrown. There was no one out there creating anything and you have got to say that England have a bit of a problem at 10.

They were like two heavyweight boxers who knew each other so well that the defences were up before a punch was thrown. There was no one out there creating anything and you have got to say that England have a bit of a problem at 10.

Dewi Morris
Quotes of the week

It may have been just one of those days for Owen Farrell - and he is a young lad - but to miss 12 points is a disappointment. Leicester fly-half Toby Flood is great with front-foot ball but he does not frighten anyone because he lacks the pace.

I do think Saracens did not help their cause by using their rotation policy - Leicester at Wembley was the wrong game to bring Farrell in. Charlie Hodgson did eventually come on and should have won them the game but I think if he had started that game then Sarries would have won.

London Welsh got a well-deserved win against Exeter and it was just fantastic. Skipper Jon Mills lost two teeth but came back on the field just three minutes later to lead his team to victory. That is commitment; I wonder how many footballers would do that?

London Welsh showed a tremendous amount of heart and commitment. Alfie To'oala came on for Mike Denbee after about 20 minutes and really played his part. Their tackling was just superb and it was a team effort.

There was a lot of skill there too - they came back from 14 points down, but they regrouped, tightened everything up and pulled it off. They kept on harrying and asking questions of Rob Baxter's team and it is what they deserved.

We like the story of them coming up into the Premiership but we tend to think that the new boys will be on the end of another drubbing - which it looked like on after 11 minutes but that does not do anyone any good, so it was fantastic to see them get their first win in the Prem.

They have a massive game against Sale next up and the Salford-based side will certainly feel the pressure from the Premiership new boys. Sale did not play too badly against Harlequins but Quins are just a level above.

I think it will come for Sale, I think this year is all about rebuilding. If they are playing this badly next season then I will have some serious reservations about not only players but also the coaches.

Dewi Morris team of the week: Round three

1. Logovi'i Mulipola (Leicester): I thought he was the only really bright spark on show at Wembley. They love to use him to carry the ball and he carries very well too.

2. Neil Briggs (London Welsh): He was brilliant for London Welsh. He can play in the backrow too and did his fair share of tackling against Exeter.

3. James Johnston (Harlequins): He does what he needs to do and has a good pair of hands.

4. Jon Mills (London Welsh): For obvious reasons, he was captain fantastic!

5. Dean Schofield (Worcester): I struggled to find another lock who performed but I thought he has played well under the pressure of losing two tight games. They should never have lost this game but I thought his carrying and leadership was great.

6. Alfie To'oala (London Welsh): He came on and performed very well - he may have been blowing a bit at the end but was superb.

7. James Scaysbrook (Exeter): Even in defeat I still think he is the in-form seven in the Premiership. He is an old fashioned seven who is just brilliant.

8. Ashley Johnson (London Wasps): Whoever decided to get this guy over from South Africa should get a huge pat on the back. At the first viewing he was fantastic. I think he tops the carries and even Jonathon Poff looked quiet next to him which is saying something. It was a phenomenal performance

9. Joe Simpson (London Wasps): Tyson Keats from London Welsh came a very close second but Simpson showed his unbelievable pace against London Irish and just shred them to bits.

10. Nick Evans (Harlequins): Even though Stephen Jones kicked nine out of nine for Wasps, Evans controlled the game so well and once again underlined his pure class.

11. Ugo Monye (Harlequins): I think he will pose questions for the England selectors - I don't think it will be enough but in a very good side he is performing very well and his work rate is exceptional.

12. Hudson Tonga'uiha (London Welsh): Epitomises what they had to do which was carry and tackle and he did that all game.

13. George Lowe (Harlequins): I thought he did particularly well after the horrendous time he had in the win against Christian Wade in the opening game.

11. Tom Varndell (London Wasps): Like Monye he also plays 14 but he is that talented that they can play together.

15. Mike Brown (Harlequins): With Ben Foden being injured I think Brown is not going to weaken any side.

Comments (3)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Andy Langdown says...

Yeh definately "unbelievable" As usual all Gloucester players don't get a look in. Bit like the England selections (down to Rob Andrew's dislike of Gloucester i believe) James Simpson Daniel!!! Unluckiest player in England in the last 15 years, how he has been overlooked in favour of some of the awful wingers that have been picked??????

Posted 17:04 24th September 2012

Harry Henstock says...

Unbelievable, Dewi, that you struggled to find a second row worthy of mention after Samu Manoa's performance on Friday night!! The guy was everywhere!

Posted 11:57 20th September 2012

Malcolm Cupis says...

Take it you missed Bath vs Northampton then Dewi? There were some excellent performances from players on both sides. Especially Abendanon, Hipkiss and Claassens from Bath and Hartley, Wood, Dowson and Dickson from Northampton.

Posted 15:26 19th September 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Latest News RSS feeds

Jones still waiting on Ospreys

Wales prop Adam Jones hopes his club future with the Ospreys will be sorted out sooner rather than later.

Waratahs keep faith for final

Waratahs coach Michael Cheika has named an unchanged squad ahead of Saturday’s Super Rugby final against the Crusaders.

Charles commits to Force

Australia hooker Nathan Charles has signed a new deal to stay with the Western Force until the end of 2016.

Alphonsi: Lessons learned

Maggie Alphonsi revealed morale is soaring as they prepare to get their Women’s Rugby World Cup campaign underway.

Cheetahs lose four to Bulls

Adriaan Strauss, Trevor Nyakane, Pieter Labuschagne and Jamba Ulengo have all left the Cheetahs to join the Bulls.

Features

Women’s Rugby World Cup: England flanker Heather Fisher feeling confident

Women’s Rugby World Cup: England flanker Heather Fisher feeling confident

Can England stop New Zealand’s dominance in the Women’s Rugby World Cup?

Good Week/Bad Week: We take a look at the winners and losers from the last seven days

Good Week/Bad Week: We take a look at the winners and losers from the last seven days

So much can change in a week of sporting action and, sure enough, there have been plenty of highs and lows over the past seven days.

Super Rugby final: New South Wales Waratahs host Christchurch Crusaders in Sydney

Super Rugby final: New South Wales Waratahs host Christchurch Crusaders in Sydney

The Crusaders will take on the Waratahs in the Super Rugby final after both sides registered eye-catching semi-final victories on Saturday.