Blogs & Opinion


Recent Comments:

Joe Rose on It's handy Carroll!

"I'm a big fan Chris, great column as usual. I'm one of many happy baggies fan, who are hailing Roy Hodgson for the work he has done. Firstly under Di Matteo we played good football but ... " View all comments

Decision time

Manchester derby could have big say in title race, says Jamie

Features - Jamie Redknapp Posted 6th December 2012 view comments

With Rafa Benitez and Chelsea experiencing all sorts of problems, it seems the Premier League is now a two-horse race - and the leading contenders go head-to-head live on Sky this Sunday.

Last season only goal difference separated Manchester City and Manchester United at the top of the table, with Roberto Mancini's side just edging one of the most thrilling title races in years. And the pair seem set for another close battle in this campaign.

Aguero and Tevez: Pair would benefit from regular matches together, says Jamie

Aguero and Tevez: Pair would benefit from regular matches together, says Jamie

Much was made of goal difference deciding the title but it was their two league meetings which were really crucial. City won both of those encounters and went on to clinch the crown. You can be sure neither side will be willing to give their arch rivals an inch come Sunday.

Following City's European exit, retaining the league crown is now so important to Roberto Mancini and his side. There is an argument which says it will help them, that they can now focus solely on the league. But no European football at all could cause problems, too.

If Mancini wants to win something this season he may just have to say 'let's get some continuity in this team, this is my eleven' and stand by them. If it means upsetting one or two, well, unlucky.

Jamie Redknapp
Quotes of the week


Man City v Man Utd
1pm, Sunday, Sky Sports 1 HD

Mancini has such a big squad and without Champions League or Europa League football there will be a lot of talented players not getting much action now this season. I suspect he's going to have a lot of unhappy players on his hands. But they've got an embarrassment of riches and that is the challenge of managing a squad with so many big names.


However, in other ways, it may help Mancini. When I look at Man City I don't know what their best team is - and I'm not sure Mancini does either. If he wants to win something this season he may just have to say 'let's get some continuity in this team, this is my eleven' and stand by them. If it means upsetting one or two, well, unlucky.

Wherever you play on the pitch you work with someone else and it is much easier if you know where their knockdowns are going to go, where and when to cover them and you appreciate each other's movement. Manchester City aren't getting that at the moment; they're not building any relationships with each other and that's causing problems.

That issue has been most clearly reflected in their frontline, where Carlos Tevez, Sergio Aguero, Edin Dzeko and Mario Balotelli are all vying for a place. After 23 games last year they'd scored 65 goals, this year they've got 40. That's a lot of goals to be missing out on.

I bet Robin van Persie doesn't even need to look at the Manchester United team sheet before big games, there's no point, he knows he's starting. Tevez, Dzeko, Aguero and Balotelli - they haven't got a clue whether they'll be playing. And that's not easy for players.

United are experiencing a similar problem with their goalkeeping situation. Sir Alex Ferguson can't choose between Anders Lindergaard and David de Gea and it isn't helping United's backline.

They had a strange game last week against Reading where, after going behind for the 14th time in all competitions this season, they battled back and won a seven-goal thriller. All the goals came in the first 34 minutes but, apart from that, the match was indicative of their season to date.

Neither Lindergaard nor De Gea are particularly commanding goalkeepers, unlike previous Old Trafford stoppers, Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar, and with Ferguson rotating them that's affecting everyone around them.

If you were playing United at the moment you'd focus on set pieces, go into real detail for free-kicks and corners, because their defensive organisation is a weakness at the moment.

I'm sure that's what City have been doing this week as that's what worked so well for them last season when these sides met at the Etihad and City captain Vincent Kompany headed the winner from David Silva's corner.

In that match Ferguson picked a team to go there and consolidate, rather than take City on. I remember Ji-Sung Park played, along with Ryan Giggs and Paul Scholes, but Yaya Toure was too powerful for the South Korean and they had to change it just before the hour. City's personnel were simply too quick and dynamic.

Ferguson won't make the same mistake again, though. He knows he handed the initiative to City with that defeat last season and he'll be more positive this time.


However, a draw suits both managers - and I think this one could finish 1-1, which is a 6/1 punt at Sky Bet. Neither side are at their best at the moment, Mancini will be more than happy to maintain their unbeaten record and Ferguson will look at it as a point gained.

Of course, for City, a win over United would help the fans quickly forget their problems in Europe. It's the sort of game where you can silence your critics and all that's gone before can be forgotten.

Lose, though, and their failings in the Champions League and the amount of money they've spent will resurface again. The stakes are high.

Find out what else Jamie is tipping up in his Red Hot Tips here.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Gerrard hard to replace

Jamie Carragher says there’s no natural replacement for Steven Gerrard in the England team....

Martin Tyler

Tyler: We need Stevie's values

Steven Gerrard can inspire the next generation of England stars even in retirement, says Martin Tyler....

Dwight Yorke

Yorke: Van Gaal impressive

Dwight Yorke has tipped Louis van Gaal to take Man Utd back to the top of the Premier League....

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Michel Vorm agrees terms with Spurs as Gylfi Sigurdsson has a Swansea medical, while QPR are set to sign Steven Caulker.

Gerrard quits England duty

England captain Steven Gerrard has announced his retirement from international football.

Koeman: No new bids for Lovren

Southampton manager Ronald Koeman insists they have not received a new bid from Liverpool for defender Dejan Lovren.

Vorm, Sigurdsson set for moves

Swansea keeper Michel Vorm has agreed personal terms with Tottenham, with Gylfi Sigurdsson set to move the other way.

FT: Sydney FC 0 Newcastle 4

Live updates from the pre-season friendly in Sydney.


Steven Gerrard international retirement: England captain deserves our admiration and will be missed in midfield

Steven Gerrard international retirement: England captain deserves our admiration and will be missed in midfield

“He is an incredible man and a fantastic footballer who we have all been blessed to see in an England shirt so often.

The Premier League new boys arriving from Spain

The Premier League new boys arriving from Spain

Once again the bulging purses have seen the Premier League keeping La Liga afloat with their abundant transfer fees. There has been a fair amount of bustling, buying activity so far this summer, especially with Jose Mourinho raiding Atletico Madrid's squad for a Chelsea quick fix.

David Ospina & World Cup bargain buys from Brazil 2014

David Ospina & World Cup bargain buys from Brazil 2014

As Liverpool proved with a fee rising to £26million for Adam Lallana, buying English means paying big money. Meanwhile, despite the huge audience, the World Cup still represents the chance to uncover fantastic value in players across the planet. And Colombia's David Ospina is just one of many.