Blogs & Opinion


Bending the rules: Andy Walker says proposals of a three-match ban for diving is absurd

Features - Andy Walker Posted 16th October 2012 view comments

"Diving is the cancer of football and we must stamp it out".

Those were the words of FIFA Vice President Jim Boyce, Britain's representative on the world's governing body.

Stoke manager Tony Pulis has also been fairly consistent in his comments after recent high-profile clashes with Chelsea and Liverpool. Their answer?

Bale: has been criticised for going down too easily this season

Bale: has been criticised for going down too easily this season

Players should be found guilty retrospectively of diving and handed a three-game ban.

My view is that a drastic measure such as that advocated by Boyce and Pulis is completely unworkable.

No one has ever come up with a clear definition of what a dive is. Is it going to ground too easily? Is it going to ground when there's been no contact whatsoever? Or is it going to ground when there's been minimal contact and the player can stay on his feet but chooses not to?

As a former player who readily admits to putting pressure on a referee when I thought I was fouled but could have stayed on my feet, I see it as part of the game.

Andy Walker
Quotes of the week

Granted, it's a tough call for referees but in the rulebook it's simulation and if they spot such an act during play, it's a yellow card offence. The idea that someone else can look at an incident after the game and impose a three-game ban for a yellow card is absurd.

As a former player who readily admits to putting pressure on a referee when I thought I was fouled but could have stayed on my feet, I see it as part of the game. I don't ask anyone to accept that I'm right but I completely understand why professionals look for dubious fouls.

To simply refer to it as cheating and say you just shouldn't do it is naïve in the extreme. Professionals play for points, contracts, money and prestige and will always look to gain an advantage somewhere. In my experience, most players and referees accept this.

Pushing boundaries

For players, it's a matter of where you draw the line as far as pushing the boundaries of the rulebook are concerned and the referees I speak to accept that players will always look to gain an advantage and that it's their job to apply the laws of the game as they see fit.

Most opponents I played against would wrap both arms around me at free-kicks and corners. I accept that as cheating and regard it as my job to break free and look to get the run on them. If they get away with that, it's their good fortune and if I get a penalty then the referee has spotted a foul.

Gareth Bale was outstanding for Wales in Friday's Word Cup qualifier against Scotland and demonstrated what an extraordinary talent he is. And yet some now refer to him as simply a "cheat" after going to ground without being touched in Spurs' recent clash with Aston Villa.

As a young player who is often on the receiving end of some aggressive and over the top challenges, who's to say he simply anticipated a collision and took evasive action to avoid serious injury? But according to Boyce and Pulis, Bale's actions would merit a three-game ban. That can't be right.

I didn't hear any outrage when Michael Owen won a couple of dubious penalties against Argentina in the 1998 and 2002 World Cups. The truth is that all fans are only outraged when it goes against their team. If dubious decisions go in their favour, all well and good.

The hypocrisy from football managers and supporters in this debate is laughable. If managers are so incensed by players' simulation or diving, let's see them take action against one of their own. My guess is no manager will ban one of their own players for cheating or winning a dubious foul.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Alan Smith

Smith: Wenger needs a striker

Arsenal are playing with one arm tied behind their back until they invest in a striker, says Alan Smith....

Jamie Redknapp

Jamie questions Remy move

Jamie Redknapp says Loic Remy will get nowhere near the Chelsea first team with Diego Costa around....

Gary Neville

Neville: Arsenal must sign a striker

Arsenal must sign a replacement for injured Olivier Giroud if they want to win the title, says Gary Neville....

Latest News RSS feeds

Transfer Deadline Day live

Radamel Falcao in Premier League link, Real Madrid target Javier Hernandez, Valencia want Alvaro Negredo and Chelsea sign Loic Remy.

Wenger coy on striker move

Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger has refused to rule out a move for a new striker before the close of the transfer window.

Falcao linked to Premier League

Monaco striker Radamel Falcao has been the subject of frenzied speculation as the transfer window enters its final day.

Gerrard: Luis engineered exit

Steven Gerrard knew Luis Suarez would ‘engineer’ a way out of Liverpool after biting Giorgio Chiellini at the World Cup.

Alderweireld in Saints talks

Ronald Koeman has confirmed that Atletico Madrid defender Toby Alderweireld is on his way to Southampton.

Features

Transfer deadline day: Hit or Miss?

Transfer deadline day: Hit or Miss?

Every fan hopes their club can produce the best signing of any transfer window. Sometimes a new arrival can indeed prove to be a masterstroke but sometimes that latest signing can also develop into an expensive mistake.

Balotelli verdict: Hit or miss?

Balotelli verdict: Hit or miss?

When it comes to the art of signing players, few did it better than Brian Clough and Peter Taylor. In the latter’s book With Clough by Taylor he explained some of the science behind it in detailing how Nottingham Forest actively sought to buy players they perceived to have personal problems.