Blogs & Opinion

Luke Dorn:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

Royce rolled out

It's a tough job being a coach these days, but Luke is still keen...

Luke Dorn - Luke Dorn Posted 23rd March 2012 view comments

The departure of Royce Simmons from St Helens seems a little bit bizarre to say the least. Cause and effect always has a place in rugby league, but here is a man that missed out on winning a Grand Final last year by 17 points.

He was obviously considered the right coach at the start of 2012 to take the club into a new era with their move to Langtree Park, yet here we are, just seven games into the season, and he's out the door.

Royce Simmons: steered Saints to a Grand Final appearance last season

Royce Simmons: steered Saints to a Grand Final appearance last season

Now, I don't know if there was more pressure on his shoulders because of the stadium move to get off to a good start, but it's unusual in the sport of rugby league for a man not to be given time to turn things around.

If they had someone lined up to take over who was free and what they wanted long term, then you could see why this decision had been taken so early in the season. Perhaps they do have someone in mind, but coaches don't often become available midway through a campaign.

It's hard for a supporter to stomach three seasons of failure just because the club is being rebuilt.

Luke Dorn
Quotes of the week

But what makes this even more strange is that it hasn't been like Saints have been playing that badly. They were pipped by the Dragons on the final play, then last week scored two tries just like Bradford but still came up short.

Obviously the absence of a player like James Roby makes a difference, though you also have to look at what Royce did last year during their injury problems. They spent the second half of their season with two young English half-backs (Lee Gaskell and Jonny Lomax) in their line-up, unearthing a combination that might go on to serve country as well as club.

Royce is perhaps wondering now just what else he could do to keep his job. Without knowing anything more than the facts, and not jumping to conclusions, it seems there may have been a little more to it than just the last few results.

Lofty goals

As for the future? Saints now have time, and a head-start over any possible competitors, in their quest to find the right man for them.

I'm not sure what coaches (apart from Nathan Brown) are out of contract at the end of the season, either here in Super League or Down Under, but at least they don't have to be in a rush.

Whoever is next in charge at Saints, the target seems a lofty one. The last man in the post took the team to a Grand Final (as well as the last four of the Challenge Cup) and that still wasn't enough to keep him in his job. Do they HAVE to win something every year?

That is something we've become more used to in football, particularly at somewhere like Chelsea. And just how is that working out for them right now (except for those sacked managers who keep getting huge pay-offs)?

Interestingly, you don't see too many coaches on the opposite end of the spectrum. Where are there four or five-year contract extensions when their team has hit a good run of form?

Perhaps it's because the coach is seen as someone who can be replaced fairly easily. At the highest level their job is more about man-management than being a tactical genius. It's about getting the best out of each individual player on a match-day, making sure they are prepared in the best possible way for what they will face. Recruitment is also a big thing these days.

What clubs need to show is patience. Midway through last season some Leeds fans thought Brian McDermott might not be the right man for Leeds. We all know how their season finished up...

Sports fans, and I include myself as one of them, are very, very impatient. It's about short-term success, not long-term benefits. It's hard for a supporter to stomach three seasons of failure just because the club is being rebuilt.

Yet despite the perils of a career in coaching being highlighted again this week, it's still a move I'd be keen to make after my playing days. I've worked with the London Broncos' Under 18's for the past three years and I've loved seeing the players come through the club and develop into first-teamers.

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

Rules of the gain?

Phil Clarke is worried some of the basic laws are being ignored just to make rugby league faster....

Barrie vs Terry

Barrie v Terry

Barrie McDermott and Terry O'Connor go head-to-head with their Super League predictions......

Latest News RSS feeds

McDermott wants win for players

Leeds head coach Brian McDermott is eager to help the Rhinos' ageing stars win their first-ever Challenge Cup final.

Rovers let Lovegrove leave

Hull KR have agreed to release forward Rhys Lovegrove from the final year of his contract on compassionate grounds.

Abdull signs new Hull FC deal

Teenage half-back Jordan Abdull is one of five academy players to be handed new two-year contracts by Hull FC.

Burrow relishing Wembley return

Rob Burrow insists Leeds' hat-trick of Wembley Cup final defeats will have no bearing against Castleford Tigers.

Castleford hopeful over Huby

Injured Castleford prop Craig Huby will have a fitness test on the morning of the Tetley's Challenge Cup final.


Preparing for points

Preparing for points

Sky Bet's RL expert Jordan Fiddes expects some key battles in this weekend's Challenge Cup Final.

Tetley's Challenge Cup final: Castleford Tigers v Leeds Rhinos key battles

Tetley's Challenge Cup final: Castleford Tigers v Leeds Rhinos key battles

Ahead of Saturday's mouth-watering Tetley's Challenge Cup final from Wembley we break down where the game could be won.