Blogs & Opinion


Cherry and fight

Is the flag flying high over fortress Kingsholm again?

Exeter Posted 29th October 2012 view comments

I went to the cinema a while ago and came out thinking about Gloucester; didn't tell Mrs Barnes who thinks I need to get a life but after Saturday evening's 13-man heroics against Leicester it's time to recount those thoughts.

The film was 'Lawless'. The screenplay is by Nick Cave; I am a fan of Cave's lyrics; that was the main reason for going. The script - 'based on a true story'- centres upon the deeds of a set of bootlegging brothers (talking whiskey not Bob Dylan concerts here) and the eldest brother is one tough bootlegger.

Simpson-Daniel: bringing the belief back

Simpson-Daniel: bringing the belief back

In one particularly violent scene a rival slits his throat with a totality which leads to death; I know because I have seen it so many times in the movies. Only our hero makes a miraculous recovery (and if you don't believe in miracles that is the filmic equivalent of hanging on against the Tigers with two men down; or Chelsea coming back to beat Manchester United, nine against eleven. In real life these things do not happen).

Take them on and they'll collapse. So it has been too often for the Shed and the rest of this support base but on Saturday they rediscovered that bootlegging spirit of Lawless and refused to accept their rational, seemingly inevitable, fate.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

Anyway, I digress, back to Lawless. He recovers from the throat-cutting incident only to be riddled in the guts with bullets by the film's bad guy. That's the end of him, I thought, but oh no, Cave had him grumbling into his plate as the family sat down for a meal sometime in the future. And the thing is, he survives because he believes (yes, yes, it is only a film). Big Brother tells his brothers they are invincible. That they are, like Achilles, invulnerable in battle and with the belief comes the survival. (I won't ruin the end for you and tell any more).

The point is some people can take a vast amount of punishment and come out the other side partly through willpower and self-belief. Others suffer the slightest, most superficial cut and swoon, disintegrating in a manner to confound and disgust these bootlegging brothers; which brings me to Gloucester.

Never an easy win

There was a time when a trip to Kingsholm was a guaranteed battle. In my Bath years we were, man for man, superior and likely to win with ease at home.

But in Gloucester we would point out our innate superiority as we looked down the team sheets but that never translated to an easy win; not in Gloucester. They had a pack and not much else bar a vast determination in front of their superb supporters. In the end a 6-3 win was a cause for celebration, never mind the fact we were 20 points better on paper.

Gloucester changed with the advent of professionalism. They became easy on the eye for the first time in their history (if they ever used the backs before my days, the old guard at Gloucester has not admitted as much to me).

They were dazzling with James Simpson Daniel replacing Mike Teague as the local hero. Now there is nothing wrong with that because somebody has to love England's most wasted talent of the 21st century. Yet it is almost as if Gloucester forgot those roots forged by the forwards and that indomitable fight until the last second mentality.

Heavy defeats in finals and a growing vulnerability at home only heightened the sense of Gloucester's not totally welcome evolution. They were the ones who fainted at the sign of their own blood. Take them on and they'll collapse. So it has been too often for the Shed and the rest of this support base but on Saturday they rediscovered that bootlegging spirit of Lawless and refused to accept their rational, seemingly inevitable, fate.

A turning point?

The last time I remember a team surviving a two-man disadvantage in a big game was England in Wellington 2003. England won in New Zealand. They went on, of course, to win the World Cup on Southern soil.

I am not suggesting Gloucester are suddenly the world's best team but if Nigel Davies's men have found the secret of self-belief and merge it with the talents of JSD, Freddie Burns, Jimmy Cowan et al, then they have taken a substantial leap forward in the space of ten minutes, from the 59th to 69th minute of the game against Leicester to be precise.

There has been plenty of criticism of Mike Tindall's technical ability in this column over the years but on Saturday his leadership was spectacular. This team didn't look like it was playing for money, but Gloucester. That is a cause for celebration amongst traditional rugby fans.

Away from that thrilling game there have been plenty of problems for the international coaches. Injuries are an abundant inevitability (even the Big Bootlegging Brother has to recover from his scrapes.) We'll consider them in greater depth next week when we know more about the medical prognosis.

As far as this week goes the column celebrates the day Gloucester defied rugby reality and hopefully (for them but no other club) rediscovered their grim, defiant past.

The film wasn't bad but it would have been better with Gregory Peck.

Stuart answers your emails...

Got a question for Stuart? Email him at skysportsclub@bskyb.com or use the feedback form below...

Hello Stuart, Having watched Toby Flood closely since his move to Leicester I still find his poor drop-kicking to be a major shortcoming in his repertoire. Not only is he scared to go for a potential match winning drop (witness Saracens away last year when he left it to Geordan Murphy), but he cannot get hang time on his re-starts. If you watch his re-starts for Leicester, the opposition invariably take the ball unchallenged whereas that is not the case with most other number tens. Surely, England need to have a kicker that gives its forwards the opportunity to re-gather a re-start? Do England not have a kicking coach that will teach him to gain that extra split second with the ball in the air. Re-starts are a vital part of the game. Without Flood gaining more hang time I can't see England beating the southern hemisphere giants.
Peter Arnold

STUART REPLIES: Peter, It is true that kicking is one of those areas where basic skills have been neglected. Compare Dan Carter's restarts with Flood's. You make a decent point. In Dave Alred England possesses one of the world's best kicking coaches but for some reason or other he and England has drifted apart. Wilkinson has always sworn by him, others find him hard to work with. A zillion years ago I was one of his first projects and I am in the Wilkinson camp on this one. He'll be demanding but it ain't easy getting to the top....

Stuart, the injuries to Lawes and Hartley are big blows for England's chances in the autumn. I know Hartley is seen as a potential England captain but Lancaster (I don't get that at all!) but think that Lawes would be the much better loss - would you agree?
Cameron Fletcher

STUART REPLIES: Cameron, Lawes would be a huge loss; he's coming back to form but Hartley would be even more worrying an absence as Tom Youngs is in the development stage still (we saw that at Kingsholm). David Paice has been called up and might leapfrog the Leicester man into the starting line up; no, Hartley is more of a blow.

Stuart, what do you think Stuart Lancaster would have made of the Glos v Leicester game? I know you go on about not judging players on just one game but surely the performances of some of his England squad member compared to those he has ignored would have had him scratching his head? Freddie Burns was exceptional - as he has been all season, while James Simpson-Daniel may not be in the right age bracket but surely should be in at least the Saxons squad?
Richard Hale

STUART REPLIES: Richard, Freddie was not exceptional. In fact he had a poor game in terms of controlling and shaping a match. He did reveal much brilliance however but I think this England team works along different lines. What might have earned FB most brownie points with the selectors was his defence as this appears the primary function of midfield England men. Freddie is not ready yet but given the form and potential of those around him his omission looks disturbing. As for JSD, the Lions maybe but not the Saxons. To see England give up on him so long ago is the saddest selectorial cock up in an age of major bloopers! He's England's most gifted three-quarter and utterly ignored.

Stuart, if Hartley's knee injury and Robshaw's eye injury do rule them out of the autumn tests who would you like to see given the captaincy - would a man who not only has plenty of experience but also is in superb form be called up - Nick Easter perhaps?
Gary Rigby

STUART REPLIES: Gary, No; you are trouble making and you know it.....it'll probably go to Tom Wood who is not playing well enough to be in the squad.

Comments (5)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Grahame Gadd says...

Hi Stuart, I am excited for the up and coming Autumn internationals and have managed to grab myself a ticket for the NZ game. My only concern is that we don¿t have the ultimate England side on the pitch because of stupid red tape. I just don¿t get why the RFU allows our best players to go abroad period. There has to be a solution to keeping the best players possible in our system. People keep going on about the welsh clubs not being competitive, but there national side being amazing, as a rugby fan, I love watching the welsh play. There National Side at present is playing the best rugby of all home nations regardless of results, however I fear for them also with huge stars leaving our shores for lucrative deals in France. I can only think this is the case because they have been able up until now to keep their home grown and international talent in the Welsh leagues, they play together and against each other weekly and have a great team spirit. Then when they come together they are already on the same hymn sheet. England needs to rethink the salary cap and allow English clubs to keep their English stars in the UK, I don¿t think that home grown talent that play for their fathering club should be a part of the salary cap and English players should be allowed to get the money they deserve from their clubs and if the club can¿t afford them they should be allowed to play in the UK but they need to be in this country. Also, Cipriani, playing great now, and from what I am seeing a class above even Flood, but I wouldn¿t want to go out and have a beer with the guy. If he changed his attitude and had a more adult persona, maybe the England set up would welcome him into the fold, and I would have a beer with him, see beer does all the talking. With his attitude, I just think he will still rub people up the wrong way, which is a shame as we still need a world class 10.

Posted 10:18 4th November 2012

Happy Ryan says...

Stu, did you catch the Currie Cup final? 12 years of heartache gone!

Posted 11:39 31st October 2012

Cameron Corcoran says...

hi Stuart: "We don't lay down for no body". Anyway, I've been watching mr Flood this year and i think since his confidence is back he has absolutely transformed into a much better player, both off the tee and putting players through (his defence always sound). I think he is definitely our man at the moment, but i can't see why, having watched Owen Farrell, why Burns isn't second choice. Owen hasn't been playing ten all that much and quite frankly he's not good enough. DO you think Andy Farrell being coach may have an influence in selection?

Posted 17:09 30th October 2012

Peter Cook says...

Saturdays game at Knigsholm was indeed, fantastic. To see Glos hang on like that and out "Leicester" the Tigers brought a tear to this Shed dweller's one eye. Barnesy, we are looking to you to lead the "Sinbad for the Lions" campaign.

Posted 11:07 30th October 2012

James S says...

I watched Bath against Exeter on Saturday. Mieres scored a try and had Donalds knee in his kidneys for his trouble. The try had already been scored and there was plenty of time to take avoiding action so there was no need for the contact . It happens all the time in the Premiership but less often lower down the leagues. Is this another form of the sanctioned offending that set off Andy Hazell's red mist? One for the refs advisors perhaps?

Posted 18:29 29th October 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Stuart Barnes

Size doesn't matter

Stuart Barnes admires the All Blacks' emphatic win and salutes Argentina's fight with the Boks....

Latest News RSS feeds

Reds sign O'Connor

James O'Connor will return to Australia in January after signing for the Reds along with league star Karmichael Hunt.

Welsh rugby peace deal agreed

The Welsh Rugby Union and the four Regions have struck a deal which puts an end to their long-running dispute.

Burnell hails remarkable Weepu

London Welsh coach Justin Burnell believes Piri Weepu has tenacity to thrive in Aviva Premiership after stroke recovery.

IRB to become World Rugby

The International Rugby Board will be renamed 'World Rugby' from November 19.

England props to miss Tests

England coach Stuart Lancaster will be without Dan Cole and Mako Vunipola for this autumn's QBE Internationals.

Features

Rugby Roots: What makes your rugby club unique?

Rugby Roots: What makes your rugby club unique?

The Rugby Club is continuing its ‘Rugby Roots’ feature this season looking at amateur & junior clubs and the stories they hold.

The Off Load: The best and worst from the world of rugby

The Off Load: The best and worst from the world of rugby

There was loads of great rugby to enjoy over the weekend including a masterclass from New Zealand!

Guinness PRO12: Stuart Barnes backs Munster to end Leinster's run

Guinness PRO12: Stuart Barnes backs Munster to end Leinster's run

Munster were last crowned PRO12 champions in 2011 and since then have seen their fierce rivals Leinster leading the way as far as the Irish teams are concerned.