Blogs & Opinion

Running out of time

Athers gives his take on the Pietersen drama

Features - Michael Atherton Posted 15th August 2012 view comments

So Kevin Pietersen has apologised, as the ECB said he had to.

I think the apology was fairly straight forward - he talked about provocative texts when the ECB have talked about derogatory texts - but basically he said sorry for sending them.

The ECB now say they need time to digest that and that there are still issues to be resolved.

Can Strauss (L) and Pietersen get back on the same page?

Can Strauss (L) and Pietersen get back on the same page?

Andrew Strauss, in his press conference just now, has said that it's not only about the text messages but a little bit about what Pietersen said in his Monday night press conference at Headingley about the lack of trust - or the trust that has broken down - between him and his team-mates.

The problem now is the timeline: England have to pick their one-day squad and their World ICC Twenty20 squad by Saturday and it's difficult to see how they can talk if Pietersen has gone away and Strauss is concentrating on the Test match here at Lord's.

England have to pick their World Twenty20 squad by Saturday and it's difficult to see how they can talk if Pietersen has gone away and Strauss is concentrating on the Test match at Lord's.

Michael Atherton
Quotes of the week

England v South Africa

Third Test, day one
10.30am, Thu, Sky Sports 1 HD
Watch on the move with Sky Go

Do they have time to get Pietersen in that squad on Saturday? We'll have to see.


Today's ECB statement hasn't knocked the issue dead as it could have done by accepting Pietersen's apology, so this issue will now rumble on over the next two or three days.

It will certainly overshadow the game a little bit - it has already overshadowed the preparations here and the fact that Strauss is playing his hundredth game and Graeme Smith is becoming the most capped Test captain of all time. Instead, the Pietersen issue has dominated the agenda.

Those players who have said anything publicly have been pretty critical of Pietersen.

James Anderson wrote a piece in his Sunday newspaper column where you didn't have to read too closely between the lines to understand what he was saying.

Tim Bresnan said they were behind the ECB's decision to drop Pietersen 100 per cent and that England may be a better team without Pietersen. They won't be, I'll tell you that, but that's what Bresnan said.

So clearly there has been a breakdown between Pietersen and a lot of his team-mates. I don't know whether that's a universal feeling in the England dressing room but it appears to be a majority feeling.


For their part Andy Flower and Andrew Strauss have been pretty strong - Flower in particular.

The problem was the press conference last Monday when it moved on from being a dispute between Pietersen and the administrators, if you like, and moved to being a dispute between Pietersen and the rest of the team.

At that point Strauss, as England captain, has to get involved. That was the critical moment at which this became more than just an argument between Pietersen and his bosses.

It's been difficult for Strauss and Flower. They felt they had to make a stand.

Difficult characters exist in every dressing room; there has never been a dressing room yet where you get 11 best mates and captains of every team have to cope with - and manage as best they can - difficult characters.

Everybody tries to do that but every captain has a breaking point at some level and Strauss and Flower obviously felt that enough was enough and they had to make a stand.

Clearly they are the men that count and who make the decisions and things must have got pretty bad because there is not a captain or a coach out there who wouldn't want Pietersen in their team as a batsman.


Strauss said that he sensed when the team met up that they were very happy that the situation had been sorted out i.e. that Pietersen had been left out.

That's what Strauss said - he sensed a better atmosphere around Lord's when they met up. He may just be saying that - who knows.

Once the game starts I think the Pietersen issue will be a talking point for everyone in the ground and it may be a talking point in the media, but for the players themselves the batsmen will be concentrating on the ball coming down, the bowlers will be concentrating on whacking it on a good length.

There is very little that gets between you and that imperative once the game comes.


For now the team goes on and that's how it should be.

There will be 11 players out there who will be picked by the selectors and if you lose someone like Pietersen you may not be as good as you were - and there's no doubt that Pietersen is one of the great players of the modern game - but the side goes on.

The team will go out and represent England and that will be the case no matter who retires or is dropped.

The question really is 'how much does Kevin Pietersen need England?' My view is that in terms of his commercial appeal, in terms of people looking back on his career in terms of history, that he'd be better off trying to play well in the two Ashes series that are coming up, trying to help England win in India and help England try to retain their No 1 status.

My point of view is irrelevant to what he feels because there are other issues. How much does he want to earn from the IPL, being one?

I hope he comes around to the former point of view but only time will tell.

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

Latest News RSS feeds

Yorkshire dominate PCA awards

Yorkshire dominated the PCA Awards with openers Adam Lyth and Alex Lees scooping two of the top honours.

Players behind captain Cook

Jimmy Anderson says England's players never had any doubt Alistair Cook would remain captain for the 2015 World Cup.

New Zealand recall Bracewell

Doug Bracewell has been recalled to the New Zealand Test squad for next month’s three-match series against Pakistan.

Essex spinner Phillips quits

Essex spinner Tim Phillips has decided to retire from cricket with immediate effect after 16 seasons with the county.

Awards for Yorkshire duo

Yorkshire's opening batsmen Adam Lyth and Alex Lees have claimed the top honours at the Cricket Writers' Club Awards.


Division One review

Division One review

The summer sun slowly begins to make way for frost and fog as another domestic season is ticked off with mixed results for the 18 first-class counties.

Division Two review

Division Two review

Hampshire and Worcestershire clinched promotion but things are going from bad to worse at Leicestershire. We review the Division Two season club-by-club...

Lacashire relegated: Paul Allott says Glenn Chapple won't coach and captain next term

Lacashire relegated: Paul Allott says Glenn Chapple won't coach and captain next term

Paul Allott reckons Glen Chapple is unlikely to be both player and coach for Lancashire next season.