Blogs & Opinion

Stuart Barnes:

Most Popular Posts:

Golden opportunity

Don't write off Lions after rusty Rustenburg display, says Stuart

Stuart Barnes Posted 2nd June 2009 view comments

Sorry Lions fans but the biggest game in town last Saturday was a fair few miles from Rustenburg.

While the Lions were so rough edged as to be almost serrated in their efforts against the minnows (but manful in the extreme) of the Royal XV, the Blue Bulls were putting together the outstanding team performance of the last twelve months and that includes any test match effort.

Best foot forward: Rob Kearney and Brian O'Driscoll in training

Best foot forward: Rob Kearney and Brian O'Driscoll in training

The previous week their first forty minutes against the Crusaders was as good as anything I have seen in aeons but in the final they stopped their New Zealand opponents from sharing in the fun.

It was - and I hate this overly used Americanisation a great deal - awesome. You can argue a case that five of the world XV would play for this one South African region. The fanatics of Loftus have much to be grateful for.


What a shame the Lions are not playing them on their home ground. For all the talk of the Lions going back to their roots, the absence of a fixture against this great traditional region is a sign that this is not quite the old fashioned adventure many would have you believe.

It does not look good for the Lions but looks can be deceptive.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

Golden Lions v Lions
5.30pm, Wed, Sky Sports 2 & HD2

In fact, it is equally sharply focussed on its rugby and its financial imperatives and there is nothing wrong with that but maybe a little less of the romantic stuff all the time, please.

Me, I will be delighted with a series that is in the balance come the final test in Johannesburg. After the disparities between the Lions and Bulls at the weekend that appears a pipe dream but South Africa wear green not blue and are Springboks not Bulls.

In a fight the Bull takes the Springbok every time. Having seen an elephant thirty paces from me whilst I sipped a pleasing Pinotage after the game on Saturday and no, I was not sizzled, who is to say what is waiting around the corner.


It does not look good for the Lions but looks can be deceptive as I try to explain and argue in response to a slightly despairing question.

Write last Saturday off as a phony war; the locals were not interested, the Lions were not flowing and the nation was on Bull alert. You may think it a matter of bull to claim that a Lions match was probably only the fourth most interesting match of the weekend but with the Super Fourteen and the French semi finals it takes a rugby person with a peculiar disinterest in matters other than international rugby to disagree.

It begins for real at Ellis Park on Wednesday night. Fingers crossed it is packed with 60,000 fans expecting the worst from the Lions and getting something better and unexpected.


I cannot comment on the England loss to the Barbarians because I have not had a chance to see the game but I guess it has to be seen as a setback as England places such a priority to winning each and every game.

Let every Englishman hope they grind out a victory against Argentina but that's not really the priority is it? The Golden Lions Wednesday and the Cheetahs, hopefully with Juan Smith and his Springbok colleagues on the field; it is time for the Lions to claim the spotlight (although I would love to be in Paris as well for the French final; well, who wouldn't?

Have a great week, if you, like me don't have the capacity to be in two places at once and are stuck in the UK and Ireland, enjoy the rugby.

Stuart answers your emails...

Got a question for Stuart? Email him at or use the feedback form below...

Stuart, I am not one for 'kicking' players when they are down and while Keith Earls is a very talented player I cannot help but feel that he is not quite ready for this Lions tour. The selectors have made such a fuss about picking players on form, but what about proven criteria? Having seen Gordon D'Arcy in superb form for the Baa-baas I wonder how many people now think that it was a good idea to pick Earls ahead of D'Arcy or even Max Evans?

Peter Reece

STUART REPLIES: Peter, No doubt Keith Earls had an anxious start to his Lions career and - on top of a poor Heineken Cup semi final performance - one could argue that Ian McGeechan was carried away by the Munster demolition job on the Ospreys. I think he was but I am not going to blame him as I certainly felt the same way as he probably did. This is something of a hindsight judgement and, remember, Earls was selected as an outside centre/stroke utility player which the now in form D'Arcy most certainly is not. In retrospect it looks a bad call but that's the nature of selections, no one gets them all right and who is to say that now the nerves are out the way he may not bounce back and show his undoubted ability. Let's not dismiss Earls too early.

Hi Stuart, hope you are enjoying our hospitality - we are loving having the Lions here. My question to you is whether the narrow win will actually play into the Lions hands. On Sunday around the braai (bbq) all the men were talking about how poor the Lions were and how they the Boks were going to win 3-0 easily. I remember 1997 very well - although that time it was my Dad and his friend standing around the braai saying how poor the Lions were and we were going to smash them 3-0. I am a Golden lions fan but part of me want them to lose as it may just wake up our fans and some of our players to realise that this tour is far from done and dusted just because the Lions were slow of the mark. Beth Viljoen, Killarney

STUART REPLIES: Beth, The Lions will be a different beast come the first test. Different combinations, different moves, different systems. It would be foolish to write them off on the balance of a rusty Rustenburg performance. If the Braai folk want to write them off because they think the Springboks can emulate the quality of the Bulls performance on Saturday, that is a more reasoned reason to dismiss them. However, South Africa are not the Bulls. They might be better (if they are the Lions cannot possibly improve enough - or find players good enough to live at that level ) but they might make selection errors, tactical errors, the sort of errors that left them series losers having scored nine tries to three against the Lions in the 1997 series. Logic suggests the Lions cannot win but logic, thank God, does not determine everything on this wonderful random planet of ours. PS I think your Lions might struggle against the British and Irish version Wednesday but good luck and hope we all enjoy the occasion.

Stuart, how much can we read into the Bulls demolition of the Chiefs in the Super 14 final? I am not a fan of the Super 14 but that was a really impressive performance from the Bulls against a very good Chiefs side. I did not think the Chiefs played that badly, but the Bulls were in a totally different league. Very scary stuff ahead - thank goodness the Lions are not playing them. Michelle, London

STUART REPLIES: Michelle, that was the stuff of nightmares. The best scrum half on the planet, the best second row combination, the most dynamic Number Eight and a fly half/kicker in the form of his life. If the South African management gets selection right it is hard to see the Lions winning but....see above. As for being relieved at not playing the Bulls, I cannot agree. Surely the best regional team in the world should have the chance of taking on the the Lions. I always loved those 'unofficial fourth tests' and this would have been a game the Lions could almost treat as a test triumph had they won in Pretoria (which I am pretty sure they would not have achieved, nor for that matter would New Zealand if Du Preez and company played at that incredible pitch of power and pace.

Thanks for the mail,


Comments (6)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Bob Monl says...

A lot has been said over the quality of Ronan O'Gara and whether he deserves a starting berth for the lions. He can on his day, be a classy 10 but unfortunately his tackling and occasionaly his composure let him down. Stephen Jones however, has the alround game. He has great composure, strength in attack, a solid tackler and good ball distribution. Thats not mention his kicking crendentials. He is consistently overlooked as one of the worlds best fly halfs because of his lack of flair, but Jones will no doubt prove his quality over the coming weeks.

Posted 23:39 2nd June 2009

Paul Kehoe says...

Stuart, i watched the Super 14 final and whilst the Bulls were impressive i think you have gone a bit mad saying they would beat the All Blacks and even South Africa. While the gap has undoutedely closed club rugby is surely a step below top class international rugby as you have repeatly stated in the past. Elsom, O'Driscoll, Darcy. Kearney and so on may argue that the Bulls still have to prove themselves as the best club/province in the world. Speaking off Darcy his absense is shocking really as i believe if he was touring he would be the starting 12. Maybe thats just bias as a Wexford man but if so argue for a better player. Love the column by the way always starts interesting debates.

Posted 17:14 2nd June 2009

Bob Wise says...

Considering the intensity of the Guinness & Heineken finals it is a little disappointing to say the least that the Lions just didn't look all that interested in playing. Some of the various battles over the last three months in the UK have been superb and watching them a sheer delight but this lot look like a local rugby club Easter tour! With all that coaching talent with the Lions you would think that the intensity would be simply hot. Are they just there for the beer and the fees or are they relly intereted in winning? Based on this performance they will not win many local games let any Tests. A very poor reflection on the talent in the BI & Ireland.

Posted 16:46 2nd June 2009

Ed Oc says...

Stuart, I think Geech may have to look at his entire game plan because if the boks play half as well as the Bulls, and with the same pace I don't see how the Lions can live with them. He may have brought over the grafters and plodders to try bash the boks into submission - 1 thing to say another to do! But the boks fast paced, multiple faze recycling will leave the aging pack of the Lions (Vickery, Shaw, Williams, Worsley, Wallace, etc) chasing shadows of the springbok athletes. The question is, do you think Geech is going to have to re-think a game plan after seeing local players and conditions so far ¿ or do you think he¿s canny enough to have already come up with a counter? If he has, I¿m sure he¿s come up with a counter to the back 5 bok forwards and FdP if his side is to have any chance ¿ as we know that¿s who the bok game plan revolves around. Well, it¿s not going to be dull either way that¿s for sure!

Posted 14:25 2nd June 2009

John Taylor says...

I am not confident we can match the incredible back row of SA but it would be a great bonus to have Tom Croft at second row and then have the skills of a fourth back row available . Despite the ridiculous rants of the biased irish comments ( Magners league better than Super 14 indeed ) Croft should have been one the first names down given we are competing on the fast grounds of SA Heres hoping we are at least competitive and not disgraced

Posted 13:20 2nd June 2009

William Black says...

Having watched Super 14 all season, the way all players seem comfortable with the ball, the offloads in tackles, the kicking game being aimed at allowing chasing players to get at the catcher rather than the aimless kicks up there, the use of both space and pace, am I alone in wondering when will any Six Nation team be able to match the southern giants ?

Posted 11:11 2nd June 2009

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Latest News RSS feeds

Barnes: Plenty to play for

Stuart Barnes says England's clash with Ireland could be a Six Nations decider, but the other games must not be forgotten.

Vunipola calls for intensity

Billy Vunipola says England will need to match the intensity they showed in Cardiff when they face Ireland in Dublin.

Williams facing nine months out

Leicester Tigers fly-half Owen Williams has been ruled out for nine months after having surgery on his knee.

Prop Welsh out of Six Nations

Scotland will be without prop Jon Welsh for the rest of the RBS Six Nations Championship.

Goode to join London Irish

Former England fly-half Andy Goode will leave Wasps to join fellow Aviva Premiership side London Irish next season.


PRO12 Highlights

PRO12 Highlights

Watch all the highlights of this weekend's Guinness PRO12 action.

Six Nations in pictures

Six Nations in pictures

We bring you the best action shots from the second weekend of the 2015 Six Nations.

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Worcester coach Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre against Italy.