Blogs & Opinion

Stuart Barnes:

Most Popular Posts:

A team of substance

Stuart Barnes Posted 11th February 2013 view comments

Not quite the excitement and ambition of the first weekend but the Six Nations was again packed with stories.

England's maturity and general good sense, France's slide from one of the best teams in the world in autumn to one of the worst in February and spring - finally - arriving in Scotland.

The assessment has to begin in Dublin where England recorded a first Six Nations win in five games. The dominant element of the game was the elements themselves. It destroyed any thought of an international being played at the tempo England and Ireland has so enjoyed in their previous two matches in which both teams had run up a collective total of 76 points.

Ben Youngs celebrates a well deserved victory

Ben Youngs celebrates a well deserved victory

The icy rain may have been the enemy of attacking ambition but on the flip side it did the work of the defence itself. Everything was done deeper and slower. The match metamorphosed into a grinding game of chess and England - to their credit - outwitted an Ireland team of more experience.

Two years ago England went to Dublin looking for a Grand Slam and got a hammering. In the aftermath of the defeat the squad was highly criticised for the photographs of celebrations on a day when they had been hammered.

Everything was done deeper and slower. The match metamorphosed into a grinding game of chess and England - to their credit - outwitted an Ireland team of more experience.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

The celebrations were more muted on Sunday even though England had won. Of course, no championship is in the bag but this side has a level headedness to it that the Martin Johnson side never possessed. Johnson's team had, like this fledgling crew, some brilliant moments but the awful ones were only a few minutes away.

In the wake of this sodden Sunday the sense is that England is now a team clear in its knowledge of how it should play and the sort of integrity required to make it something special. As I write the side is NOT a special one. Little England elements have to wait a while before those acclamations have substance. A Grand Slam is a step in the right direction but still only a step.

Not such a quantum one after seeing Ireland off in with intelligent efforts from Ben Youngs (ghosts of Dublin well and truly laid after his public slating two years ago) and Chris Robshaw whose Lions credentials remain standing after yet another rounded performance against high grade opposition.

The possibility of England heading to Cardiff in search of a Grand Slam grows. The next two matches are at Twickenham and France are somehow reduced to tatters. Wales deserved their win but were nothing special. Do not be fooled by those who acclaim the incredible quality of the defence; there was barely an attack worth the name.

Wales stop the rot

Wales just had to win; no marks for style count when you are on an eight-match losing streak.

Ryan Jones was superb as captain which leaves the thorny question of what to do with Sam Warburton. The injured captain is out of form while Justin Tipuric is bang in it. Jones's leadership from the blind side was good as was the balance of the back row. It would be weak of Rob Howley to restore his captain on current form. It is THE selection to keep an eye on.

France - one assumes - will make changes. Philippe Saint-Andre is enduring a shocking Six Nations campaign. It cannot be just the fact I tipped them!

Frederic Michalak is a failed gamble, Morgan Parra is the missing general and Wesley Fofana is being utterly wasted on the wing when he is as good a centre as there is in Europe.

The country has so much talent at its disposal but so little invention. The French manager could twist his squad like a kaleidoscope and something very different may come at England in the next round. Or they could simply not turn up.

Spring flowers for Scotland

Scotland produced the most exciting game of the weekend and the individual headline maker to boot. Stuart Hogg's ninety metre solo breakaway try capped two outstanding weeks of Test match rugby. Full back is a massive area of strength for the Lions but the young Scot is making a determined bid to upset the established order.

That aforementioned try summed up the narrow margins of sport. Hogg intercepted a pass from Luciano Orquera; had the Italian fly half dummied he would probably have scored and the game would have been on at 20-10. Instead one dazzling score and a few seconds later it was 27-3 and stone dead. This might not be the end of Scotland's winning this term.

Italy were not as bad as the score reflects but whereas the pack were superbly marshalled against France the Italian half backs reverted to their usual useless selves and then it doesn't matter how many Parisse's you have to the pound, the wins are not going to come.

Relegation battles

Away from the international stage the big news was both Sale and London Irish winning; London Welsh and even Worcester are back in the relegation fight now. Sale's game at Welsh is a huge collision.

At the other end of the table Leicester took advantage of London slip ups to go top while Wasps and Gloucester enhanced their own play off credentials.

Bang mid-table and not talked about beyond their own borders, Bath have discovered the joy of rugby and are scoring tries instead of trying to grind out wins. Peter Stringer and his rapid service is the element that has ignited them. Keep one eye on them for the rest of the season.

Keep both eyes on England; after a first year where any win was overhyped they are starting to win in a manner that suggests they are finally heading in the right direction.

I might just have a look at the 2015 World Cup odds.

Stuart answers your emails...

Got a question for Stuart? Email him at or use the feedback form below...

Feeding the scrum

Stuart, when I was a wee schoolboy scrum half many years ago the referees insisted on putting the ball in straight. As a consequence both front rows tried to win the ball, as they had a chance to win the ball, and scums "worked". Now with no obligation to put the ball in straight (in practice if not in the laws of the game) the side without the put-in has no incentivisation to try to hook the ball so goes for disruption and penalty seeking or similar. And the scrums do not work, and this creates a major problem with today's game. If the ball were to be put in straight and both scrums were intent on winning the scrum would that not ensure more positive scrums? With less time wasted on resets etc, and hookers could relearn their role. Do you think referees should be instructed to impose this law? I ask this question because I heard you accuse a scrum half of an error in a recent game when he put the ball in a bit straight and I did not understand the reasoning behind accepting a culture of not straight. Why does it benefit the game to allow scrum halves to feed the ball into the middle row?
Graham Noble

STUART REPLIES: Hear, hear Graham. Straight put ins are still in the law book. Who on earth told referees to ignore the book (yet referees will tell you they have no option but to obey the laws when it is something fashionable like the tip tackle)? I have spoken and written on this subject. A crooked feed takes the technique of the hooker out of the game and turns the scrum into a 'hit' whilst the law book has a set of laws for something different entirely... no wonder the scrum is such a mess.

Punishment for Healey?

Stuart, very disappointed with Ireland on Sunday but I thought England really got into their faces and played with a lot of thought. Do you think that Healey's rush of blood to the head will ruin his chances for Lions selection? On another not, what is happening to the pitches these days? Are they just not up to the wear and tear of professional rugby?
Mark Lupton-Smith

STUART REPLIES: Mark, I do not think Healey will or should be punished as regards his stamp and Lions prospects. I thought the English foot was in the air and not on the ground and the intent was to cause pain for someone Healey perceived to be on the wrong side, no more. As for the pitches, they are simply not up to the constant reset of a thousand scrums...what or who is?

Saints in freefall

Hi Stuart, I wrote to you in the autumn bemoaning the lack of basic skills at both club and England level, well a few months on and everything in the England garden is starting to smell of roses. The performance in Dublin was top draw considering the venue and the conditions, could this be the start of something very exciting... let's hope so. I wish the same could be said of Franklins Gardens!!! As you witnessed on Saturday there were precious few basic skills in evidence from The Saints. I know Sky like to come to The Gardens because there is always a good atmosphere which helps to make good TV. Not anymore and if you want to have any viewers left you need to give it a wide berth from now on. It really was desperate stuff and I wonder what you think the answer is? I have been going down there for 40 years now and I don't know when the club has been in such disharmony, the natives are NOT happy and we are a pretty loyal bunch. The relegation years were not as desperate as the stuff we are having to sit through now, I am sure our aspirations have been raised since those days and the time when you and your Bath mates used to give us a good stuffing but it's all got rather sad. What do you think?
Jim Bryant

STUART REPLIES: Jim, All due respect but I think the relegation year was considerably worse. Like Gloucester you were missing key players which could have changed the shape of the game - could have, not would have; too often Northampton's best fifteen has struggled to find a rhythm. A lack of variety in the way the team plays is clearly fundamental. They have long reminded me of a club version of traditional England teams; big and strong and good at bullying opponents but when someone stands up to the bully....oh well, at least England cheered you up.

Too many kicks?

Hi Stuart, big fan of the column (shocking from a Welshman I know). After watching Ireland/England this afternoon, I felt the only players to emerge with any credit were Goode and Best although admittedly the weather ruined any hope of seeing the finer aspects of both teams. My query comes regarding the scrum halves. Do you find it slightly worrying that the first instinct these days is to put up a box kick? Youngs and Murray managed about a pair of decent ones between them all game. Also, surely George North has put himself in pole position for a test spot, barely got a touch all game and had a magical finish. Apparently some fella called Halfpenny didn't do too badly either.

STUART REPLIES: Dan, Had I been a fly half in Dublin I would have screamed for my nines to keep boxing the ball. What else could a team do in such conditions? So, given the weather, no not too concerned. I wouldn't be too quick to knock either team on a technical level. As for George North, it is about time he got into the game (something he did through the second half) and yes, Leigh Halfpenny can play but if he wants to be the test fifteen he has some serious opposition doesn't he?

Free flowing game

Stuart, From a great admirer of your since Bath's glory days. No matter how much discussion on individual matches rugby will never rival soccer as an international sport whilst the game itself is so flawed. The fact that the ball is in play for less than a quarter of match time speaks for itself. There are far too many petty regulations which constantly impede flow of play for reasons which the crowd invariably cannot see or understand, and which so often mean the game is won on negative scoring (penalties) rather than through tries (e.g Eng v Ireland). The outcome often therefore depends simply on whichever team has the best goal kicker. Let's find a way to stop scrum collapses, and get rid of all the ineffective regulations (especially the accidental knock-on, which time and again stops a promising flow of play because of an inconsequential fumble which usually disadvantages the attacker anyway). It's time for influential commentators and journalists to look at the wider picture and start campaigning against entrenched views.
R. Hawdon.

STUART REPLIES: Mr Hawdon, fascinating set of questions; it is the quality of the time in play, not the amount that most matters and penalties are not 'negative' scores when they prevent negative teams stopping positive ones. Tries are the litmus test of exciting rugby but not always the only proof. We cannot use the Ireland v England game as an example as conditions were exceptional... the accidental knock on, hmm, to allow that means diminished skills are encouraged, ie catching and passing. However, whilst not agreeing with the small detail of your argument I concur that the game cannot stand still and pat itself on the back; too many games are poor. Reducing conversions to one point and raising a try to six is one of my suggestions along with dropping the drop to one point.

The scrums are another issue altogether with coaches teaching their teams to fool referees. It is a tough contest to call when nobody is hamming when a referee has two front rows with their mind on conning it becomes almost impossible to administer. No lesser a personage than Andy Farrell made this point whilst saying that the scrum should remain a key attacking weapon in the sport.

Comments (15)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Shane Mcevoy says...

England played well against Ireland but you are sugar coating how they did it. First of all besides the players who went off injured, Zebo and Sexton, a further 4 or 5 players were carrying knocks for the majority of the match, O'Driscol, Darcy, O'Brian, McCarthy etc. Also Ireland had the poorest game in terms of simple handling for a long time. England won through playing simple rugby, bad Irish hands and the Irish team being hugely depleted. Well done England but don't build up the victory to the heights that its definitely not at.

Posted 13:58 21st February 2013

Roger Hunt says...

Stuart, in light of another disappointing performance and in the context of the last three, trophyless, seasons, do you think it is time Leicester "parted company" with Richard Cockerill? Leicester just seem to be consistently declining, I appreciate Leicester are in the Quarters of the HC and third in the Premiership but I do feel that Tigers are being increasingly left behind by Quins and are being caught up Gloucester and Wasps, While in Europe Leicester are so far off the best it's painful, the salary cap etc. excuses some of that gulf but not all of it. Things can always be worse and Cockers is doing an "ok" job but I look at Saints and can't help but feel that could be Leicester next year. Leicester certainly have little chance of winning any silverware this year.

Posted 08:19 17th February 2013

Dave Brew says...

Michael, what England proved was that they vary their game. Conditions dictated that style of rugby, but the two previous games (Scotland and nz) proved that they can play rugby. This side isn't ready to win a World Cup now but who know in a couple of years. Who knows what conditions our teams will face then? And give credit to england for forcing mistakes rather than just being lucky, although all teams need sometime.

Posted 21:05 15th February 2013

Jeff Hazell says...

The comments of R Hawdon make me laugh. Rugby doesn't want or need to be compared to poofball! Its a gladitorial sport, far more exciting, interesting and technical than a bunch of wendies running around, falling over at the slightest touch, crying to the referree etc etc etc! R Hawdon, get outta hear!

Posted 11:54 14th February 2013

Michael Dwyer says...

Re Dave B, I agree absolutely with your comment, despite Irelands large amount of possession they didn't look like scoring a try and Englands defence was incredably disciplined giving virtually no penalties away. While England played defencably magnificantly considering the situation, normally the team with the most possession wins and not having the ball is nothing to triumph. While there are many ways to win, I will never agree that giving away possession is one of them. Not wanting the ball is anti rugby and I do not believe that that was Englands intension. Sunday was a very disciplined and brave performance from a young England team under tough conditions but I would argue they had some luck with Irish fumbling and indiscipline. They will not win a world cup conceding that much possesion.

Posted 12:59 13th February 2013

Dave B says...

Re. Michael Dwyer. Sunday's match was a match when it was better not to have the ball, play territory and force the opposition to make mistake with pressure; and that is exactly what England did far better than Ireland. At what stage did Ireland look like crossing the try line, how many penalties did they force in England's half. For a side with about half the caps of the opposition, England did extremely well and fully deserved their victory. A point about the pitches: the problem is they are always getting relaid so when its wet there are problems - the pitches weren't just churning up, it was sliding.

Posted 09:29 13th February 2013

Steven Lake says...

Hi Stuart i am currently a referee in the ospreys region in wales and its got to the point where the tackle area is an absolute mess.,as is other parts of the game.Do you think the IRB should step in and simplify the game and its laws.You have most probably seen a law book and its like an encyclopedia.Most amateur players i speak too dont know what they can and cant do.Another thing is that i find if there is any law changes its usually directed from the southern hemisphere, and its too suit them.Do you think this is right.???

Posted 22:35 12th February 2013

J Cliff says...

It was an illegal action, Cole wasn't obstructing the ball but you believe he (Healey) shouldn't be punished because "the intent was to cause pain" (as opposed to breaking the ankle? You believe Healey factored in the airborne position of Cole's ankle into his stamp?). That may be the most ridiculous comment I've seen on the topic - while I don't believe in some of the extreme reaction in the English media, I sincerely hope you're wrong about this going unpunished...

Posted 21:58 12th February 2013

Reg Squires says...

Dear Stuart, while I agree with your comments with respect to putting the ball into the scrum and feeding the second row, in my opinion if the front rows would stop taking the scrum down and do what they are supposed to do,keep it up, then the referee would be able to concentrate on offences such as feeding! When I played the game I would have been strung up by the proverbials if I had deliberately collapsed the scrum!!

Posted 11:29 12th February 2013

Michael Dwyer says...

While I agree England played safe, clever rugby and defended magnifincently, I would argue that normally if you conceed so much possession and the opposition don't make so many basic handling errors at crucial moments you will loose. England were very brave but not much more than that I felt. Other than the grubber for Tuilagi, they didn't have a single line break and created nothing. If Ireland had not dropped everything England would have lost and I wonder what the comments would have been then.

Posted 08:11 12th February 2013

Jeff Badland says...

Stamping and rucking are entirely different things. What Healy did was not in the spirit of Rugby. You surprise me Stuart.

Posted 23:49 11th February 2013

Anthony Blake says...

Sorry but cannot agree with you regarding Cian Healy. Wayne Barnes showed real courage in removing the Racing Metro forward for reckless intent in the game against Munster. The referee should have likewise sent him off - You cannot justify his actions and what about his forearm around Owen Farrell's throat! At least he has been cited and I hope the 6 Nations disciplinary panel throw the book at him- needless to say good behaviour etc and the fact that there is a distinct Irish bias will mean a very low level ban.

Posted 17:38 11th February 2013

Peter Arnold says...

Hi Stuart I agree entirely with Graham Noble about straight scrums and with you about a xix point try, although i would leave the drop at three. Howabout trying to bring in the backs more. Don't allow a scrum option for a penalty or free kick offence unless the infringement was at a scrum. Give a free kick instead of a scrum for a knock on or forward pass without a scrum or kick to touch option. Finally, stop the clock at all reset scrums until the ball finally comes back into play legally.

Posted 16:14 11th February 2013

Ash Clarke says...

Stuart, good comments in general but cannot agree on Healey's stamp on Dan Cole. Whilst Cole was indeed on the wrong side (he had just pulled down a maul I believe), he was nowhere near the ball or preventing it from being released, which at the time of the stamp was already being moved on by the scrum half. Healey clearly took aim at a stray leg/ankle and stamped it to the ground, which could easily have resulted in a break. I'm all for old fashioned rucking, and indeed if Healy had rucked Cole on the body to clear him out then that would have been fair (on the wrong side, you deserve some pain). Taking aim at a stray limb and stamping it to the ground is not rucking however, whether under the old or modern interpretations of the ruck law.

Posted 14:22 11th February 2013

Spidey Jones says...

Halfpenny is a cert for the lions test side be it at full back or wing , Tupric has to be the lions 7 and young and farrell the half backs. Ryan Jones will be the mid week skipper, watch out the rest wales are back

Posted 13:51 11th February 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Latest News RSS feeds

Barnes: Plenty to play for

Stuart Barnes says England's clash with Ireland could be a Six Nations decider, but the other games must not be forgotten.

Vunipola calls for intensity

Billy Vunipola says England will need to match the intensity they showed in Cardiff when they face Ireland in Dublin.

Williams facing nine months out

Leicester Tigers fly-half Owen Williams has been ruled out for nine months after having surgery on his knee.

Prop Welsh out of Six Nations

Scotland will be without prop Jon Welsh for the rest of the RBS Six Nations Championship.

Goode to join London Irish

Former England fly-half Andy Goode will leave Wasps to join fellow Aviva Premiership side London Irish next season.


PRO12 Highlights

PRO12 Highlights

Watch all the highlights of this weekend's Guinness PRO12 action.

Six Nations in pictures

Six Nations in pictures

We bring you the best action shots from the second weekend of the 2015 Six Nations.

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Worcester coach Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre against Italy.