Blogs & Opinion

Stuart Barnes:

Most Popular Posts:

Freddie Burns: England fly half does not merit start against New Zealand

Stuart Barnes - Stuart Barnes Posted 3rd June 2014 view comments

A passionate, powerful if not perfect game of rugby rounded the English season off at Twickenham with Northampton winning in the final seconds of extra time.

A first Premiership title in their history and well deserved. Congrats to the Saints team, management and fans. A marvellous occasion, a stirring atmosphere with the Saints fans, in particular, in superb voice and, for Stuart Lancaster watching in Auckland's early hours, no injuries.

Burns has not been in as good a form as fly-half rival Cipriani, says Stuart

Burns has not been in as good a form as fly-half rival Cipriani, says Stuart

Andy Farrell may have been expected to root for his old club but I suspect all the England management cared about was their contingent of tourists coming through without injury.

From that perspective it was a green light with only Owen Farrell and Billy Vunipola limping from the fray. Neither suffered anything worse than the immediate agony of severe cramping - although the regularity of the England fly-half's cramp issues is perhaps a cause for minor concern.

On all playing form Burns does not merit inclusion on the tour, let alone a team start.

Quotes of the week


New Zealand v England
First Test
8am, Sat, Sky Sports 1

The greater concern for England is who will fill Farrell's competitive boots this Saturday. The leaks suggest the answer is Freddie Burns with Danny Cipriani warming the bench. It makes a mockery of Stuart Lancaster's claim that players are picked on form.

Whilst Cipriani has not been quite the superstar some newspapers would have you believe, his form has been consistently solid, while Freddie Burns' career has nosedived since his sparkling cameo against the All Blacks in 2012.

Confidence in his club shirt crumbled long before Gloucester's pack did and well before the disconcerting fuss over his move to Leicester. His representative game for England A (Saxons if you have a disregard for the poor old Angles, Celts, Picts etc) against Ireland's second string at Gloucester was a horror show.

On all playing form he does not merit inclusion on the tour, let alone a team start.


So what is going on here? Well, Lancaster places great store by players' performances in training, both the quality of their work on the field and the character shown in camp.

This is the stuff we in the media cannot see. Whether the manager is right to place such trust in knowledge of systems and ability shown under no pressure will be put to the test on Saturday.

So far in his managerial career the England coach has had the knack of getting more from his players than the clubs tend to get. It is a happy knack and one that reflects exceedingly well on the organisation and coaching of the team.

Whether it is Burns as expected or DC playing his way into the team with a series of superb training sessions, the pressure is very much on Danny Care to take the major share of responsibility as the half-back decision maker.

He has been one of England's most improved players in the past six months. His running game is, as ever, a threat and his kicking game has acquired more accuracy than previously but maturity and decision making will be imperative with a fresh face at fly half.


The other Harlequins also have a huge role to play if England is to be competitive against a New Zealand side whose players are finding some form and fitness at the right time.

Chris Robshaw has to make more of an impression at the breakdown than he did in the Six Nations against Richie McCaw and this clever All Black breakdown outfit. Mike Brown has to inspire England as he did throughout the autumn and the Six Nations.

Yet for once all three of these Harlequins may play second fiddle to Joe Marler.

The absence of the injured Mako Vunipola means England lacks the thrust of eighty minutes the combination of the two have been providing. Given the All Blacks' potential weakness at hooker it would be a shame if England could not at least try to target the New Zealand front row.

On the other side of the scrum, with Dan Cole out injured, this is a magnificent opportunity for David Wilson to steal a march on the tight head. But with less experienced cover the question is how hard, fast and long can the pair go? If England takes the game to New Zealand up front these guys are going to be at the heart of the effort.

Other interesting selections centre around inside centre where Kyle Eastmond, dropped by Bath, could be a shock inclusion if Billy Twelvetrees is not fit enough to train flat out as I write (3.30 NZ time Tuesday) and tomorrow.


The All Blacks appear likely to take even an under-strength England threat seriously and are unlikely to try many fresh faces. Strong favourites for the first Test they may be but if England can make a game of it, with the Twickenham cavalry arriving, this could be quite a series.

At Auckland airport I had the pleasure and privilege of bumping into the great Sitiveni Sivivatu heading home for a month break before starting with his new club Castres. He believes England is, at the very least, going to be extremely competitive - and he is not the only one.

Elsewhere, watch out for a strong Australian performance against France as their rebuilding continues.

So much for what is to come; finally a word on what has been.

Both Jonny Wilkinson and Brian O'Driscoll ended their careers with domestic trophies. Wilkinson kicked his goals and dropped another off his 'wrong' foot in what was an ugly affair, while O'Driscoll only lasted nine minutes of Leinster's comprehensive beating of a brave Glasgow team.

Congratulations to those clubs and these men. We will see their like again - maybe not for a while, though.

Stuart answers your emails...

Got a question for Stuart? Email him at or use the feedback form below...

Hi Stuart, great work as always. After seeing them sign off, does the retirement of O'Driscoll and Wilkinson signal the end of a golden era of Northern Hemisphere rugby?


STUART REPLIES: No, how can it be a golden era when we only won one World Cup and one Lions series against a troubled Oz team? BOD and Wilkinson were magnificent players but the future will throw up players to match and surpass them. That's the nature of the game, David.

Hi Stuart, I agree with Edward Griffith that the TMO decision system is a shambles, what can be done to sort this out?

A disgruntled Saracens fan

STUART REPLIES: DSF, it is a shambles. It needs a conference to rethink all the problems that have cropped up all season not a quick paragraph from a man who has just landed in Auckland and is typing through jetlag in a hotel lobby awaiting a room!

Hello Stuart, I'm really looking forward to watching the New Zealand Tests but is it just a case of damage limitation? Or is there a realistic chance we can cause some damage?


STUART REPLIES: Peter, England has a serious chance of winning either the second or third Test. The NZ press is not treating them lightly and nor is Steve Hansen and the All Blacks.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Andy Dickinson says...

Stuart, would like to know your opinion on why Dave Ward isn't even on the bench for the 1st Test? Ward is the form player, 5 MOTM awards this season, highest turnovers in the premiership with 27, Quins players player of the year, Quins coaches player of the year and not even part of Lancaster's plans? unbelievable!!! This is probably a more outrageous team selection problem than Burns/Cipriani. We want to see fast flowing rugby that Ward and Cipriani can produce not going back to trying to grind out a result by any means. We just don't support our flair players. I've travelled to Auckland and now worried about this first test. Cheers Andy

Posted 21:02 5th June 2014

Mick Collyer says...

Stuart I agree with you about Burns, he has been poor at best all season. This is a great opportunity for Cipriani in the long term, if Burns proves not to be the answer as no 2 to Farell, Ford has already proved by his performance in the Amlin final that he is not ready for international rugby & Myler's game is limited.

Posted 09:52 4th June 2014

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Latest News RSS feeds

Barnes: Plenty to play for

Stuart Barnes says England's clash with Ireland could be a Six Nations decider, but the other games must not be forgotten.

Vunipola calls for intensity

Billy Vunipola says England will need to match the intensity they showed in Cardiff when they face Ireland in Dublin.

Williams facing nine months out

Leicester Tigers fly-half Owen Williams has been ruled out for nine months after having surgery on his knee.

Prop Welsh out of Six Nations

Scotland will be without prop Jon Welsh for the rest of the RBS Six Nations Championship.

Goode to join London Irish

Former England fly-half Andy Goode will leave Wasps to join fellow Aviva Premiership side London Irish next season.


PRO12 Highlights

PRO12 Highlights

Watch all the highlights of this weekend's Guinness PRO12 action.

Six Nations in pictures

Six Nations in pictures

We bring you the best action shots from the second weekend of the 2015 Six Nations.

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Six Nations: Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre

Worcester coach Dean Ryan is delighted that England have stuck with Jonathan Joseph in the centre against Italy.