Sky Sports.com

Special features

Blogs & Opinion

Mike Atherton:

Recent Comments:

Darren Kok on Mind the gap

"As much as I would love to see England smash the Aussies, I still think the Aussies have the edge over the English. People talk about them losing Hayden, Martin, Langer etc.. yet they ... " View all comments

Ritesh Lamsal on Time's right for Ravi

"There are five problems with England currently : 1) Hyper passive captain in Strauss, 2) Inexperienced head coach in Flower, 3) The brute attack of injuries (Harmison, Sidebottom, ... " View all comments

Captain Sensible

KP will find it difficult to integrate back into side

Mike Atherton Posted 7th January 2009 view comments

Michael Atherton believes the appointment of Andrew Strauss as England skipper on an interim basis after Kevin Pietersen's resignation is a rational choice.

Strauss missed out on the captaincy last August following Michael Vaughan's decided to quit, with Pietersen getting the nod instead, but has been handed the reins for the upcoming tour of the West Indies after Pietersen chose to stand down.

Strauss: interim role

Strauss: interim role

Atherton, who led England from 1993-2001, told Sky Sports News that the appointment of Strauss could be the long-term solution to England's captaincy conundrum.

"Andrew Strauss is very different from Kevin Pietersen. He's less instinctive, less of a maverick, less brilliant in many ways but perhaps a safer pair of hands," he said.

"The problem he has is his one-day form. He has not been in the one-day side and Geoff Miller recently said that he wanted one captain for all forms of the game, so that would be problematic for Strauss.

Pietersen's got a big ego and that ego will have been punctured by the knowledge that the rest of the team are not necessarily on him on this issue.

Michael Atherton
Quotes of the week

"I don't see a problem myself with splitting the job and having a Test match captain and a one-day captain."

Unloved

Atherton suggested that 28-year-old Pietersen, who described his working relationship with former coach Peter Moores as "unhealthy" at the weekend, could find it difficult to slot back into the England ranks despite his determination to travel to the West Indies and help to try and to recapture the Ashes later in the summer.

"This decision is going to leave some bruises, some big bruises," said Atherton. "Pietersen's got a big ego and that ego will have been punctured by the knowledge that the rest of the team are not necessarily on him on this issue.

"When [managing director of England cricket] Hugh Morris talked to the players they did not necessarily back Kevin Pietersen up, so he will feel a little unloved and let down because he deliberately went out of his way to back players when he was in charge.

"So how he reintegrates into the team, or whether he can, is the key issue for England moving forward because he is the world-class player in the team. He would be a hard player to lose and England certainly want him at his best for the very important year that is coming up.

"So how Andrew Strauss and the new coach go about integrating him into the new team, making him feel loved, wanted, a part of things when he won't feel like that right now is the key thing moving forward."

Cult

Pietersen and Moores are believed to have disagreed on a number of issues, including the use of coaching methods and the decision not to recall Michael Vaughan for the tour of West Indies, and the on-going saga has re-opened the debate about how the coach-captain relationship should work.

"I think it is an issue that cricket has not really resolved since the rise of the 'cult of the coach'," said Atherton. "When I started playing for England we had a coach who was no more than a man who used to organise practice and the players had responsibility for their performances.

"But now you have batting, fielding, bowling coaches and analysts. The rise of the 'cult of the coach' has meant that the coach is more important than he was and cricket has to resolve who is the man in charge? The key issue, though, is that the two men must get on.

"If you look at the strongest relationships in recent years - Michael Vaughan and Duncan Fletcher, Nasser Hussain and Duncan Fletcher, Graham Gooch and Mickey Stewart.

"They might have had differences on policy and players but always those differences were behind closed doors and they presented a united front to the team and the public."

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

David Lloyd

Monkey business

Why was golf with Nasser Hussain ruined by a monkey? And will the rain ever stop? Bumble blogs......

2 comments

Mike Atherton

The heat's on Rash

Spinner Adil Rashid will be fully tested by South Africa in the upcoming one-dayers, says Mike Atherton....

1 comments

Nasser Hussain

Trotting along nicely

Jonathan Trott is quickly becoming a vital cog in England's middle-order, says Nasser Hussain....

0 comments

Latest News RSS feeds

Proteas recall Gibbs

South Africa have recalled Herschelle Gibbs for the remaining three one-day international matches against England.

Colly ton crushes Proteas

Paul Collingwood's 105 not out guided England to a seven-wicket win in the second one-dayer against South Africa.

All-rounder hails 'special' England

Paul Collingwood was delighted after his century led England to a seven-wicket win over South Africa.

Cook to remain in Pretoria

England opener Alastair Cook will remain in Pretoria while the rest of the ODI squad head to Cape Town.

NZ tour incident revealed

Neil Broom and Aaron Redmond have confessed to being charged with serious misconduct on New Zealand A's tour of India this year.

Features

Maximum potential

Maximum potential

Expect fireworks in the International Sixes League as Graeme Smith's South Africa tackle England.

Cricket highlights

Cricket highlights

Watch the highlights from South Africa's win in the second Twenty20 International on skysports.com.

Bumble on Twitter

Bumble on Twitter

Catch up on all the latest from the Sky Sports commentary box with David Lloyd's tweetings.