Blogs & Opinion

Guillem Balague:

Most Popular Posts:

Recent Comments:

Cem Takaci on Making his mark

"Hi Guillem, all of this hype sourounding jose mourinho and the saying that the wave is swinging for real madrid right now. But once Jose leaves and it does seem that he will if not this... " View all comments

Siyavuya Zamxaka on Awesome foursome

"wonderfull column as always...I think Madrid have a better chance of winning the Cup game in all of these 4 games. This is because Mourinho can play any system and not worry about how ... " View all comments

Barca's Real problem

El Clasico promises to be a thriller, says Guillem

Guillem Balague - Guillem Balague Posted 8th December 2011 view comments

It's the most watched club game in world football and this Saturday regular La Liga watchers on Sky Sports will be joined by millions tuning in for the first Real Madrid v FC Barcelona clash of the season.

So, what do we need to know to get the most out of the game? Here's Guillem Balague's indispensable five-point guide to the biggest game of the season so far...

Once you've digested this, make sure you check out Guillem's 'Legends Lunch', as he, John Toshack, Albert Ferrer and Michael Laudrup take an extended look at El Clasico!


Real have a three-point lead over Barca with a game in hand. At home, the hosts are the only side with a 100% home record in La Liga and after winning their fourteenth consecutive game at the weekend with a 3-0 victory over Sporting Gijon, go into the game on the verge of a record breaking run of victories.

At the Bernabeu, Mourinho's side have scored an astonishing 28 goals in six games and they possess the best offensive stats in La Liga this season; in contrast, the visitors have the best defensive record in La Liga (two clichés about Mourinho's negative approach and Barcelona's inability to defend dismantled in one fell swoop!).

At home, Barcelona appear invincible - nine games played, 39 goals scored and none conceded - but away from home, it's a very different story. Outside the Camp Nou, Barcelona were defeated by Getafe in their last away game and they've managed just two wins out of six (both 1-0s over strugglers Granada and Gijon). Without their home fans behind them, Guardiola's side have scored just eight and conceded seven - and Messi has scored only once on the road in contrast with the 16 he's scored at the Camp Nou. Barcelona dropped just 14 points last season before clinching the title; this time they've already dropped 11.

That lack of intensity has been a problem for Barca this season and they've lacked that edge that has made them arguably the best side this generation will ever see.

Guillem Balague
Quotes of the week

8.30pm, Sat, Sky Sports HD1


Barca bounced back from that defeat at Getafe with a 4-0 win over Rayo and a 5-0 win over Levante last weekend; both at home. Against Levante, the presence of Cesc Fabregas, Alexis Sanchez and the latest talent to emerge from La Masia, Isaac Cuenca, all provided depth and penetration to a Barcelona side that has lacked some of that spark, that intensity, pace and aggression that is key to making their possession based style and high pressure successful.

Keep an eye on Cuenca in particular; he's an old fashioned style winger who broke into the side in the absence of Pedro. The 20-year-old is excellent at taking on opponents in one-on-one situations, a great dribbler and crosser of the ball - but his inexperience may make him too much of a gamble for a Clasico at the Bernabeu.

That lack of intensity has been a problem for Barca this season and they've lacked that edge that has made them arguably the best side this generation will ever see; but a trip to the Bernabeu, against the old enemy, could be the spark that re-ignites the flame.

Madrid, in contrast, are at their highest level since Mourinho took charge and playing better than on any of the seven occasions they have faced Barcelona under the Portuguese.

Their 3-0 win over Sporting at the weekend was a hard fought, physical battle that saw Madrid individual qualities separates the two sides. But make no mistake, Madrid are not a team of individuals - they are a team in every sense of the word and much less reliant upon Cristiano to get them out of trouble. Di Maria, Khedira, Ozil and Carvalho are all blossoming and taking on greater responsibility in their second seasons at the club - while the rest of the squad now reflect what Mourinho wants in his second season in Madrid.


Madrid possess a variety that will make them a force in Europe this season: capable of dominating teams at home with also a high pressing game, or counter-attacking with devastating pace against stronger sides that enjoy possession (like Barcelona) or away from home.

In the victory over Sporting at the weekend we saw Sergio Ramos playing as a centre back and the team playing a higher defensive line. Importantly, making fewer mistakes: something that is crucial against Barcelona who are capable of punishing you dearly for every error.

Xabi Alonso is pivotal in the centre of midfield, and when Madrid win possession, his forward passes from deep lying midfield areas to the forwards provide the springboard for most of Madrid's counter attacks. Certain teams might be advised to put a man on Alonso, to try and disconnect the supply to Madrid's attacking players; but it's unlikely that Barcelona will man mark the former Liverpool midfielder, despite the fact that it might be to their advantage. Changing their style to stifle an opponent is simply not in Barça's DNA or in Guardiola's philosophy.

Guardiola loves to pull a surprise or two for the Clasicos; and this time around the big question is 'will he play with three or four at the back?' Several factors could push Barcelona toward playing a three-man defence: statistically they have been more effective playing with three this season and with Alves on the pitch, he can always drop back and defend in a four dependent upon how the game progresses.

Guardiola also believes in getting your best players out on the pitch in key games and since signing Fabregas, that means playing with an extra midfielder at the expense of a defender. Plus, the need to stamp their authority on Madrid and dominate the midfield could force Guardiola's hand into going for extra personnel in the middle.

The problem for Guardiola is that he has sought variety and alternatives to the playing system that has become so familiar in recent seasons, and that has led him to experiment with a different line-up and formation in every game (24 line ups in 24 games). Their success in recent season was founded upon their essential identity and the dominance in possession created by Xavi and Iniesta. The addition of Cesc Fabregas, for example, has been beneficial in terms of offering a directness and penetration from midfield previously absent (with nine goals he has scored as many as Villa, as Pep says, you shake him and goals come out of him); but at the expense of a level of control in game. Against Madrid, the loss of possession high up the pitch will play into Madrid's counter attacking capabilities.

Messi v Ronaldo

Predictable; but how could we ignore the two star attractions, especially when their roles have been subtly reversed this season. They're level in terms of goals scored this campaign (17 each), but their relationship with their team's dynamic has shifted.

Ronaldo used to try and win every game on his own, and when Madrid were playing badly, Ronaldo played well and often made the difference. Now, it's less about Ronaldo and more about the team; yet instead of marginalising the Portuguese winger, he's flourishing as a team player and contributing more all round.

In contrast, Barcelona are overly-reliant upon Messi; and it's affecting their overall play as they try to get the ball to him as often as possible. It's making the team more direct - as is the inclusion of Fabregas - and it's affecting the team's identity and even internal harmony (marginalising David Villa, for example). If they are reliant upon Messi at the Bernabeu, his solitary goal away from home this season is a worry.


Mourinho, in contrast with previous clashes, has kept silent in the build up: preferring to let his players do the talking this time around. That silence speaks volumes about he now see his sides chances against Barcelona. In his second season, this is now his team, his club, playing his way - and it shows.

Guardiola, on the other hand, has a few domestic issues to contend with: a drop in performance, an unhappy striker, a dependence upon individuals and concerns over the focus of others (Pique). It's the first time that Guardiola's Barcelona has taken on Mourinho's Madrid as slight underdogs - at least in terms of league position.

The visitors to the Bernabeu know that defeat could leave them with a nine point deficit in the New Year. For once, it's Barcelona feeling the heat; but this is a side full of World Cup winners that thrives under pressure, and a high stakes game may be exactly what they need to make them up their game to its astonishingly high level of recent times.

Are Barcelona deserving of an underdog tag in this game? No. Probably not. That defeat at Getafe was their first in 27 games after all: hardly a crisis. Guardiola's side remain an exceptional football team capable of stepping up a gear. This game really is too close to call.

Don't miss Guillem Balague's 'Legends Lunch', as he, John Toshack, Albert Ferrer and Michael Laudrup take an extended look at El Clasico!

Comments (32)

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

Okere Shedrack (Manchester United fan) says...

real =2 barcar=1

Posted 15:50 9th December 2011

Adewunmi Agbato (Chelsea fan) says...

Bacca 3-Madrid 1: Messi(2 goals), Ronaldo(1goal) Madrid(1 own goal).

Posted 15:22 9th December 2011

Kwame Ekyi (Chelsea fan) says...

Ali Ahmed, the writer is not biased against Barcelona. Truth hurts when it told to the face, and this is what he has done. Is it not true that Barcelona are too dependent on Messi nowadays while Madrid are less dependent on Ronaldo? Is it not true that Real Madrid are a well-balanced team this year, and Barcelona are finding it tough in away matches. Did the write not say "A high stakes game may be exactly what Barcelona need to make them up their game to its astonishingly high level of recent times." Take note that he did not predict the score; he said "This game really is too close to call." From this what makes the writer a real Madrid fan. May be you don't know how to digest a piece of writing. I am sorry it is you who is being subjective by refusing to alienate your admiration or love for Barcelona. I also say this game really is too close to call, may the team that play well win.

Posted 15:14 9th December 2011

Gigi Thompson (Arsenal fan) says...

I love that so many fans think the author of this article must be a Real Madrid fan because he's willing to point out the flaws in the great Barcelona team without whom which football would not have existed apparently. I think Real Madrid can win this one. They're a different team than the team that got destroyed by Barcelona last year. They're much more cohesive.

Posted 14:59 9th December 2011

Adam Britton (Liverpool fan) says...

I thought Liverpool vs Manchester United was the world's most watched game? In fact I'm sure of it

Posted 14:12 9th December 2011

Yemi Adelaja (Barcelona fan) says...

Valdes, mascherano, puyol, pique, abidal, alves, Cesc, xavi, Iniesta, Alexis, Messi..3,5 2...Common Barca..Visca el Barca Visca el Catalyuna!!! Final Score: 3 v 2 to Barca!! Call me the soothsayer!!

Posted 14:05 9th December 2011

Hayden O'connor (Arsenal fan) says...

I think Madrid will win but i can see goals from both teams, Madrid should approach the counter attack style, with there pace it is immense. Every aspiring young footballer should be tuning in tomorrow to see how football should be played..

Posted 13:52 9th December 2011

Richard Evans (Arsenal fan) says...

Hi, I hope this is the fall of the Barcelona side..i despise their play acting, rolling over as if they have been shot by a sniper in the crowd.. don't get me wrong some of the football they play is pure genius, they take keep ball to a level never seen before. Messi is mesmerizing..but i think Real will win and win the league... I only hope they draw each other in the champs league before the final.. come on Jose,,,, take the crown away and stop this machine called Barcelona..

Posted 13:40 9th December 2011

Paul Healy (Barcelona fan) says...

3-1 to the catalan giants barca will bring real back down to earth tomorrow night Form is Temporary Class is Permanent

Posted 13:28 9th December 2011

Adam Etchells (Manchester United fan) says...

Time for Barca to get their spanking me thinks, see Real cruising this one.

Posted 13:21 9th December 2011

Wyclif Kapiseni (Manchester United fan) says...

i think this Game will end up in adraw or Madrid can win usin home advatage

Posted 12:49 9th December 2011

Happy Spurs fan (Tottenham Hotspur fan) says...

Mourinho vs Messi. The best manager in the world vs one of the best players ever. This game will probably be a draw, but as long as we don't see more red cards than goals, it should be interesting to watch.

Posted 12:47 9th December 2011

Red Menace (Liverpool fan) says...

@Ali Ahmed yes this article does sound a bit bias towards Madrid but it would do when the stats speak for themselves Barca are having a poor season (by their standards) a bad away record, playing poor against weaker opposition. in contrast Madrid are on fire especially at home. as for the game hope its a cracker but think it will end up a score draw.

Posted 12:42 9th December 2011

Et Angula (Barcelona fan) says...

Our workload is only who to start among these stars: Alexis, Cesc, David Villa. But a start line-up of this form may give us a win: Valdes- Abidal, Pique, Puyol, Alves-Xavi, Sergio, Ineasta- Cesc, Messi, Pedro

Posted 12:37 9th December 2011

Eddie Mason (West Ham United fan) says...

Oh great, can't wait for another show of handbags and theatrical diving Tom Daley would be proud of. What a joke these games are, such a waste of merged talent. What's the gap between these two teams and the rest of the league already? 50 points?

Posted 12:16 9th December 2011

Sam Williamson (Manchester United fan) says...

Ali you have just proven the point he has made about Barcelona relying on individuals by stating that the only way they can win is through performances from Iniesta abd Messi. It isn't biased he provides arguments for both sides throughout the article, if one side sounds stronger its because evidence says it is e.g. Real are at the top of the table Barca are not and are struggling internally with problems with David Villa and Pique losing his place in the team. Overall a very informative article

Posted 12:06 9th December 2011

Liam Barnett (Manchester United fan) says...

Out of order to suggest Guillem is a Madrid fan, Ahmed. If you watched La Liga this season, you would realise that he is spot on is his assessment both as a journalist and a fan. Barcelona have been less than average on the road. They've become easily flustered, for many times before this season did you see Barca pumping balls into the box from free kicks and corners!?-not to mention crossing it. However, this season when things don't go their way and their attacking football doesn't work after 30 minutes, they switch to the complete opposite of the football they've become known for. Madrid on the other hand have finally got everybody pulling in the right direction. Ronaldo is maturing into an even better player-contributing all round, Ozil, Di Maria, Benzema and Higuain put in good performances consistently, no matter how many minutes they get. Couple the good performances with the the great work ethic and winning mentality that Mourinho has instilled, you get a Real Madrid side ready to go 6 points clear tomorrow night.

Posted 11:49 9th December 2011

Solomon Adjei-ankrah (Barcelona fan) says...

yea, it has always been th same for the past 4yrs! barca has neva lost under pep at the benabeu! this factor ll see us through and also the lion ll once again roar......

Posted 11:14 9th December 2011

Ranti Shoks (Manchester United fan) says...

People are talking about how good barca is, whta they are forgetting is that barca is not that good.Against Real they always keep diving and pretending and ensuring that Real gets a red card which has made them win the few times that they have met.Without the red card, there is no way barca can comfortably beat Real in a very competitive game. BARCA STOP DIVING AND PLAY WITH DIGNITY

Posted 10:45 9th December 2011

Shahed Yousaf (Barcelona fan) says...

Barca to play 3-4-3 and blow Madrid out the water...Madrid and Jose will get fraustrated and the game will turn ugly! Barce to win...HAIL HAIL!

Posted 10:27 9th December 2011

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Chelsea in good shape for PSG

Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho is likely to have a strong squad to select from for their Champions League game with Paris Saint-Germain.

'Let's throw some punches'

New Aston Villa manager Tim Sherwood says he is planning to install a more attacking approach at the club.

LVG: We must sign a midfielder

Louis van Gaal has confirmed that Manchester United will attempt to sign a creative midfield player this summer.

Live transfer updates

Live transfer news as Louis van Gaal makes the signing a creative midfielder his top priority this summer.

Bony trains with new team-mates

Wilfried Bony has trained with Man City for the first time after winning the Africa Cup of Nations with Ivory Coast.


Tim Sherwood's to-do list: Five things the new Aston Villa manager must make a priority if he is to succeed

Tim Sherwood's to-do list: Five things the new Aston Villa manager must make a priority if he is to succeed

As Tim Sherwood settles into his first day at work as Aston Villa manager, the challenge of keeping the Premier League perennials in the top flight begins.

Pogba? Verratti? Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal wants a creative midfielder but who should he sign?

Pogba? Verratti? Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal wants a creative midfielder but who should he sign?

Only a fortnight after the transfer window closed, Louis van Gaal has set tongues wagging again by admitting that Manchester United need to sign a creative midfielder.

Xabi Alonso impressing at Bayern Munich under Pep Guardiola and eyeing a third Champions League medal

Xabi Alonso impressing at Bayern Munich under Pep Guardiola and eyeing a third Champions League medal

Adam Bate looks at Xabi Alonso's fine form with Bayern Munich and why he can make history this season.