Blogs & Opinion


Guillem Balague:

Recent Comments:

Cem Takaci on Making his mark

"Hi Guillem, all of this hype sourounding jose mourinho and the saying that the wave is swinging for real madrid right now. But once Jose leaves and it does seem that he will if not this... " View all comments

Siyavuya Zamxaka on Awesome foursome

"wonderfull column as always...I think Madrid have a better chance of winning the Cup game in all of these 4 games. This is because Mourinho can play any system and not worry about how ... " View all comments

Nicolas Kyriacou on Playmaker problems

"It's painful to watch someone like Ibrahimovic leading the line for Barcelona. He lacks pace, movement and reaction. He is slow and ponderous on the ball and slows the tempo of their ... " View all comments

Scott Mcclymont on Running out of time?

"Hi Guillem, With regards to Ronaldo coming back to United, I think this could happen after his contract has finished at RM. He's making all the right noises and isn't dismissing the ... " View all comments

End of an era

Guillem reflects on El Clasico and answers YOUR questions

Guillem Balague Posted 8th October 2012 view comments

Sunday's Clasico was the funeral of Pep Guardiola's Barcelona.

If I've learnt anything from writing Pep's biography - which will be published next month - it is that he wanted a way of playing that was a lifestyle and not just a football style.

He felt Barcelona were a big club and, as a consequence, had to dominate the games, go out to win them and impose their personality.

Changing times: Vilanova (right) has adopted a new philosophy at Barcelona

Changing times: Vilanova (right) has adopted a new philosophy at Barcelona

This led to pressuring high, starting the build-up from the back and keeping the ball for as long as was required to find the gaps, something Xavi, Lionel Messi and Andres Iniesta eventually did.

Now, though, Barcelona are trained by a coach who is less interested in big ideas and more in sorting out the football problems posed by a long injury list and the pressure of a Real Madrid team that keeps getting better.

Vilanova's main test will arrive with a couple of bad results. Will his proposals be accepted by everybody?

Guillem Balague
Quotes of the week

Tito Vilanova realises that to win games he has to transform Barcelona and make them more conventional, and we are now seeing a side that plays more long balls, doesn't keep the ball for as long, and defends more than other sides would do (less of the pressure in packs high up the pitch, more of the disciplined positioning and allowing teams to take a bit more of the initiative).

It is generally a more direct style, though this works against the strengths of Xavi and even Andres Iniesta, who need to pause and find themselves surrounded by team-mates to do harm.

This weekend's match had lots of chances but it wasn't a typical Clasico. Normally the match is an open game but this was very tactical; both teams had a very clear idea that they couldn't appear disorganised and tracked back in numbers and in order.

Madrid kept their lines very close together meaning Barcelona couldn't find any space, while Barca didn't allow many counter attacks, especially after Martin Montoya came on for Dani Alves following some disconcerting early moments.

Both Jose Mourinho and Vilanova agreed that it was a great game when they shook hands at the end and it was a match that Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi featured prominently in - for different reasons, I felt.

Real's pressure up high and counter-attacking football suits Ronaldo down to the ground and he now fits his side's style more than ever, while Messi wants more of the ball; he is dropping deep, appears everywhere and it looks like every time Barcelona attack they have to pass him the ball.

They are both extraordinary players, though, and make big impacts in big games; Ronaldo has scored in the last six Clasicos, which is a record, while Messi has scored 17 times in 22 Clasicos and with one more goal he will equal Alfredo Di Stefano.

Both teams were happy with the result and, again, for different reasons; Mourinho feels he has the side where he wanted, no matter how broken or not their team spirit is, while Vilanova will be pleased his side is still eight points ahead of Madrid.

But the Barcelona boss' main test will arrive with a couple of bad results. Will his proposals be accepted by everybody? Will that direct style, which in my eyes has put the nail in the coffin of Guardiola's team, reap enough benefits?

Guillem answers your questions...

Got a question for Guillem? Then send it in here or use the feedback form below, and then look out for his answer next week.

NEW ROLE FOR MESSI?
Great read as always, Guillem. I know Lionel Messi is still a player very much in his prime and his goalscoring is phenomenal. But as he gets older and loses that burst of speed do you see him playing deeper and performing a Xavi role? Harvey Sharpe

GUILLEM SAYS: Messi won't play the Xavi role but he will have the freedom that he has always had. When he was young coaches asked him to do things but they soon realised he did whatever he wanted. The coaches now trust him to do what he wants because of the experience he has got and what he brings to the team. They are happy for him to drop deep or play as striker and for the team to move around because he is just that good.

DEFENSIVE DILEMMAS
Should Barcelona have Alex Song and Javier Mascherano at the back, or should Tito Vilanova replace Song with a youth like Marc Bartra or Andreu Fontas? I know Song is doing fine at the back, but I'm still unsure about him as I have a feeling he doesn't have that original centre-back spark. via e-mail

GUILLEM SAYS:The idea is to use Gerard Pique and Carles Puyol at the back but they can't at the moment because of injuries. Barta hasn't been given a chance because Tito feels he is not ready and would find it difficult to cope with mistakes at this stage and he wants to bring him along gradually, so Song is the fourth centre-back after Mascherano at the moment. Now, though, Adriano gives them a new possibility because he is very fast over the first five-to-10 metres which is what you need as a centre-back. However, they do need a Puyol to provide aggressive pressure and have experience of keeping the line, something Adriano and Mascherano do not have.

A REPRIEVE FOR KAKA?
Hi Guillem, I love your articles, keep up the good work! I wanted to ask whether this is the dawn of a new age for Kaka given his performances recently, and if so, will it be enough to persuade him to stay at the club? He had a renaissance at the start of last year before Angel Di Maria hit form, only to pick up a niggle and never recover his place. Another thing is, while Michael Essien is a good squad player, do you see his future at Madrid? Especially since his displays have not been as energetic as Lass' in the last season. If not, who will Madrid target in the market? Could Nuri Sahin return? Jann

GUILLEM SAYS: It was quite clear that Real asked Kaka to leave this summer. He has gained a bit of confidence now and Real can take advantage of that but he will only appear every now and again. Mesut Ozil is still ahead of him and while Mourinho has been disappointed by Luka Modric, he is going to push him to work harder defensively. As for your other questions, I don't think Essien will stay unless he is dirt cheap in terms of wages, while I think Nuri Sahin will be sold; he is not a Mourinho-type player.

Keep your questions coming in and don't forget to follow Guillem on Twitter: @GuillemBalague

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Ray Wilkins

Shortlist of three

Ray Wilkins says Phil Neville, Glenn Hoddle or Gareth Southgate should replace Stuart Pearce....

0 comments

Martin Tyler

Final thoughts

Martin Tyler reflects on Spain's triumph and England's woes in his final blog from the U21 Euros....

Latest News RSS feeds

Carroll seals West Ham move

England forward Andy Carroll completes his permanent transfer to West Ham United for an undisclosed, club record fee.

Zaha return down to United

Crystal Palace chief executive Phil Alexander says a return for Wilfried Zaha is down to Manchester United.

Isco price won't be dropped

Malaga have warned those looking to snare highly-rated forward Isco that they will not be dropping their asking price.

Sagna is still talking terms

Bacary Sagna has played down transfer gossip by revealing that he remains in talks with Arsenal over a new contract.

Tottenham confirm Baldini role

Tottenham Hotspur have confirmed the appointment of Franco Baldini as their new technical director.

Features

Ten of the best

Ten of the best

Now the fixtures have been released we have picked out ten clashes that immediately catch the eye.

Fixture lists gallery

Fixture lists gallery

Check out our bespoke club-by-club 2013/14 fixture cards for every Premier League outfit.

Steve McClaren believes England should follow Spain's approach

Steve McClaren believes England should follow Spain's approach

Spain not only has the Under-21 European Champions again but also a footballing blueprint the rest of the world should follow.