Blogs & Opinion

Struggling Sunderland could be deep in the mire come January, says Jeff Stelling

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 29th November 2012 view comments

After a fourth successive defeat, a lot of people in the North East are talking about Newcastle's plight and understandably so because they are seemingly in free-fall.

But the team I really fear for right now - especially after the week they've had - is Sunderland.

When people list their relegation candidates they tend to go with any three of QPR, Reading, Southampton, Wigan and maybe Aston Villa, yet on present form Sunderland surely have to fall into that category.

Simon Mignolet: Sunderland's player of the season so far, says Jeff - West Brom game aside

Simon Mignolet: Sunderland's player of the season so far, says Jeff - West Brom game aside

They looked devoid of ideas (and hence chances) in the 0-0 draw against QPR and I thought it was quite telling that afterwards Martin O'Neill was pretty much lost for words when he was asked if he was confident that the team could come through its current blip.

The record shows they've only won twice at home in the league since March - against QPR last season and against Wigan in September - and now there are fears that Lee Cattermole could be out for months rather than weeks. Everything suggests they are in trouble.


People will say Sunderland's biggest problem is that they can't score enough goals. To my mind the truth is they're not creating enough chances.

It says a lot that Sunderland's outstanding player of the season so far has been Simon Mignolet; that's if you discount the West Brom game, of course

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

The only time they've significantly dominated possession was against Newcastle - but that, of course, was against 10 men. In essence, they're struggling to get the ball, keep it and use it effectively.

It says a lot that their outstanding player of the season so far has been Simon Mignolet; that's if you discount the West Brom game, of course!

Sunderland are not a big side - they are not physically powerful either in midfield or defence - and that's definitely an issue, as is Adam Johnson's lack of form.

I also find the lack of depth in their squad a bit scary. On Monday they had Frazer Campbell, Louis Saha, Jack Colback and David Vaughan amongst the substitutes. On current form - in particular with Campbell and Saha - I'd suggest these are players who aren't really going to change a game.


The other concern, for Ellis Short in particular, is that crowds have tumbled at the Stadium of Light: a total of 36,513 watched the Rangers game.

Now I know that these are difficult times on Wearside and it's not cheap to go to a match - I absolutely understand that - but that means the ground is well over 10,000 down on capacity.

When you consider that they got 42,000 for the first home game of the season against Liverpool, I'd call that a significant drop.

Are things going to pick up soon? Looking at their upcoming fixtures it's fair to say I've got my doubts!

Of their seven Premier League fixtures in December, three are against Chelsea, Man City and Spurs, while they also have to go away to Old Trafford. There's a very good chance that come the January transfer window they could find themselves deep in the mire.

The best signing for Martin O'Neill at the moment would be John Robertson, who has been his sidekick for so much of his career. That might just be the winning partnership Sunderland need.

There's no question in my mind that Martin is a top manager but Short is simply going to have to back him with some money in January.

Spot on

I went along to another struggling club last night - Southampton - where Mark Clattenberg made his refereeing return.

The first thing to say is that I thought he had a fine game even though he got a fair bit of stick! I'm sure the two managers will both disagree with me, but I thought he got all of the big decisions right.

Under the circumstances it might have been easy for him to bend a little bit towards the home crowd but I thought he was spot on.

It was certainly good to see him back but I was surprised to read in at least one report that he received a standing ovation from fans. If he did, then I didn't see it!


On the subject of performances, I went along to the X-Factor this week. Let me explain...

I popped along after receiving an invitation to be a guest on the Xtra Factor and while I was there I learnt that one of the downsides of appearing on the X-Factor is how much weekend football the contestants miss because they are either rehearsing or performing.

To be honest, I was surprised at how many football fans there are on the show.

Dermot O'Leary, the host, is a massive Arsenal fan; Olly Murs, one of Xtra Factor hosts, has a box at Manchester United; James Arthur, who is my favourite to win it, is a huge Middlesbrough fan; Josh, from the boy band Union J, is a Chelsea fan.

When I turned up one of the first things they all wanted to know was how their team was doing because they hadn't seen them for so long!

So if you support any of the teams above, you know who you should be voting for...

Jeff's Gem of the Week

I'm not messing about this week - it's Swansea beating West Brom. All of the stories we heard about disharmony under Michael Laudrup have disappeared as quickly as they emerged. His signings, pretty much without exception, looks as though they are coming off, in particular Pablo Hernandez, who has been a revelation in the past few weeks.

Swansea were impressive against Liverpool last week but they destroyed West Brom in that first half with some fantastic football. They've got some exciting players and aren't going to be a soft touch for anybody. I can certainly see them finishing in the top half.

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Cave Cats (Sunderland fan) says...

Everything you have said about Sunderland is 100% correct, apart from maybe one thing. Martin O'Neill WAS a top manager. The fans have been calling out for him to get John Robertson for a while as O'Neil looks lost without him, both tactically and motivational too. But Robertson has turned us down numerous times now. The signing of Adam Johnson was considered by every Sunderland fan to be a major coup, but all we have learned about him is that his place on the Man City bench was maybe not warranted as thus far he has looked like a terrible football player. Sadly James McClean has been found out too and is not intelligent enough to progress. The biggest issue seems to be the tactics which are always negative, especially when playing at home against the bottom club, 4 - 5 - 1!! O'Neil seems incapable of making the changes needed to turn it around and opinion is split on Wearside as to whether we should stick or twist. Whilst every Sunderland fan would prefer it to be O'Neill who get us out of this, it just doesn't look likely. We are being subjected to the worst football we have seen since the Howard Wilkinson days, even the Mick McCarthy team that sank showed more character than this current team. This Sunderland team hasn't been thrown together on a budget either, there has been a lot of money spent and we need O'Neill to get the best out of this squad. Nobody up here understands why we play for a draw at home or why Connor Wickham can't even get on the bench, never mind the starting 11. To be honest, the more you analyse the current situation, there is only one person to be held accountable.

Posted 16:55 29th November 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Redknapp

Jamie questions Remy move

Jamie Redknapp says Loic Remy will get nowhere near the Chelsea first team with Diego Costa around....

Gary Neville

Neville: Arsenal must sign a striker

Arsenal must sign a replacement for injured Olivier Giroud if they want to win the title, says Gary Neville....

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Top four in sight for Spurs

Spurs can make the top four, says Carra, depending on how seriously they take their European duties....

Latest News RSS feeds

Premier League round-up

Swansea, then Chelsea, move to the top of the Premier League, Stoke stun poor Manchester City and still no win for Louis van Gaal.

Live transfer updates

Arsenal and Chelsea battle for Loic Remy's signature, West Ham sign Alex Song and Man Utd agree deal for Daley Blind.

Chelsea hit Everton for six

Chelsea hit Everton for six in a goal-filled Premier League extravaganza at Goodison Park which finally ended 6-3.

Arsenal enter race for Remy

​Arsenal have joined Chelsea in triggering Loic Remy's release clause, according to some Sky sources.

United still waiting for win

Louis van Gaal continues to wait for his first win as Manchester United manager following a 0-0 draw away to Burnley.


Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

When it comes to the art of signing players, few did it better than Brian Clough and Peter Taylor. In the latter’s book With Clough by Taylor he explained some of the science behind it in detailing how Nottingham Forest actively sought to buy players they perceived to have personal problems.

Christian Eriksen masterclass

Christian Eriksen masterclass

Type ‘Christian Eriksen free-kicks’ into your internet search engine and you will not be disappointed.

Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Everyone agreed that Tottenham had acquired some fine players in the summer of 2013, but the notorious line that Spurs sold Elvis to buy the Beatles soon became a source of embarrassment. Not least because that cast young Erik Lamela as John Lennon, the most celebrated of the lot.