Blogs & Opinion

Reading issues too great for Nigel Adkins to resolve this season, says Jeff Stelling

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 28th March 2013 view comments

New Reading boss Nigel Adkins could not have a much tougher start than a trip to Arsenal on Saturday.

Nigel is an unassuming, hard-working and enthusiastic manager who was very unfortunate to get the sack from Southampton.

The man he's replacing at the Madejski Stadium - Brian McDermott - is also a diligent and thorough manager who was unlucky to get the boot at Reading.

Nigel Adkins: has a tough job on his hands at Reading, says Jeff

Nigel Adkins: has a tough job on his hands at Reading, says Jeff

Each sacking was tough to understand and that's the case even more so now given that each club has found a virtual like-for-like replacement for their former boss.

Don't get me wrong - I like Adkins and I respect what he achieved at Southampton; I thought the timing of his dismissal, coming as it did after the 2-2 draw at Chelsea, was ludicrous.

How galling would it be for Saints fans if, firstly, Reading beat Southampton and, secondly, Reading survived and Southampton didn't?

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week


To donate visit and search for Jeff's name

It's great that he's got another opportunity to manage in the Premier League but I suspect that even he anticipated that he might have to drop down to the Championship to get another job.


Adkins has got a tough job on his hands, make no mistake.

Inevitably Reading will make all of the right positive noises following Adkins' appointment but that can't hide the fact that the Royals have struggled all season long and relegation is looming.

But the fixture list does offer them hope. After going to Arsenal, they have two home games - the first of which is against Southampton.

How galling would it be for Saints fans if, firstly, Reading - with former Saints boss Adkins in charge - beat Southampton and, secondly, Reading survived and Southampton didn't?

I don't see that happening but I'm sure it has crossed the minds of plenty of Saints fans because Adkins left St Mary's with a lot of friends.

Reading have a very decent run after that with games against Norwich, QPR and Fulham so there is hope although the next few weeks will be mightily tough for them, particularly if they don't improve at the back.

Of late they just haven't been good enough defensively, even allowing for the injury to Adam Federici. Since his 'wobble' at the beginning of the season, he's shown great strength of character to come back strongly, so they've really missed him recently, particularly when it comes to marshalling the defence.

Reading have struggled in the heart of their defence and, in truth, I think they have too many issues for them to survive.


Southampton are in a healthier position but it's worth remembering that many people thought they were in the clear not too long ago and that's plainly not the case right now - even if they aren't far off.

Maybe they'll welcome playing Chelsea this weekend because they seem to perform best against the 'big boys'. They were fantastic against Manchester City and probably even better in their last Premier League outing, against Liverpool, when, for my money, a 3-1 home win in Southampton's favour really flattered the visitors.

In the early stages of that match Southampton tore Brendan Rodgers' side apart and I suspect it was probably their best performance of the season - and it came at just the right time.They've got a lot of energy in the team and a lot of quality, too. I like Adam Lallana a lot because he can go past players very easily indeed and has proved time and time again that he has real skill. Southampton could even afford to leave Jason Puncheon on the bench for the Liverpool game and he's been one of their players of the season!

Chelsea walloped Southampton earlier in the year in the FA Cup but this is a different Southampton side now - they play the game in a different way - and it will be interesting to see what team Rafael Benitez picks given his side face Manchester United in the sixth round of the FA Cup on Monday.

If you asked Chelsea what their priority for this season is, they'd say 'finishing in the top four' but is that Rafa's priority? Wouldn't another cup look good on his CV?

So I just wonder what side he will play at St Mary's at the weekend because he is his own man and time and again he's shown that he's not afraid to upset people - and why should he be, because he's only got a matter of weeks left at the club?

It wouldn't surprise me at all if Rafa played one or two of his second-string players and that would give Southampton a cracking opportunity to retain their Premier League status because I think they are not much more than a win away from securing survival.

Looking at Southampton's performances right throughout the season - from the early days when they played exceptionally well away at Manchester City and at home to Manchester United to this month's victory over Liverpool - I think that, generally speaking, they have done enough this season to stay up.


One of Southampton's former strikers, Kevin Davies, learnt this week that Bolton would not be offering him a new contract at the end of the season.

I read that Kevin was shocked at the timing of the news but I suspect that manager Dougie Freedman simply wants to put his own stamp on the club - it's what happens in football, you clear out the old and bring in the new.

Kevin has had a fantastic run and he's done a fantastic job for Bolton and I'm sure he'll get another club but I can understand why Freedman has reached that decision.


Meanwhile, my preparations for June's attempt to climb Mount Kilimanjaro are going well.

Earlier this week I popped along to the London Altitude Centre, who over the years have advised quite a number of Premier League clubs about the benefits and risks of training and playing at altitude. I underwent a number of tests, including one where they reduced the oxygen level to that which you might experience at 5,000m.

I came through the breathing tests with flying colours so I'm feeling a bit more confident about the expedition now. In fact, I'm sure I heard my assessor say 'I think we've found the new Chris Bonington...'

To find out more about Jeff's Mount Kilimanjaro climb - in aid of the Finlay Cooper fund - click here .

The easiest way to donate is to visit and search for Jeff's name. Any donations large or small will be more than welcome.

Jeff's Gem of the Week

Bournemouth continued their fine run with a 4-1 win over Bury. After the five consecutive defeats they suffered from mid-February onwards, it would have been easy for them to spiral down the table but they've rallied and secured three straight wins and now I fully expect them to fill one of the automatic promotion spots. If they were to go up, they are equipped ok for the Championship. Their story is one that should give hope to any club suffering from financial problems of what they might achieve given time. When you are in that position you fear the worst but hope for the best and Bournemouth, after having severe financial issues a few years ago, have managed to attract new financial investment and with the right man at the helm in Eddie Howe they are now flourishing.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Alan Smith

Smith wants Welbeck at Arsenal

Danny Welbeck could be the man to replace Arsenal's injured striker Olivier Giroud, says Alan Smith....

Phil Thompson

Thompson: Lampard an icon

Frank Lampard is a football icon and can be proud of a ‘stellar’ England career, says Phil Thompson....

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Everton present Samuel Eto'o, Troy Deeney set to pen new deal at Watford and Angel di Maria signs for Manchester United.

Di Maria blasts Real 'lies'

Manchester United signing Angel di Maria has claimed he never wanted to leave Real Madrid.

Van Gaal not shocked by defeat

Louis van Gaal insists he was not shocked by Manchester United's 4-0 defeat at MK Dons in the Capital One Cup.

Clarke out of Palace running

Steve Clarke has been ruled out as a candidate to take charge of Crystal Palace, who are set to name their new manager.

Arsenal v Besiktas preview

Arsenal and Besiktas meet at Emirates Stadium with their Champions League play-off locked at 0-0 from the first leg.


If the 106-cap career of Frank Lampard is regarded as an England disappointment, then so is everyone's since 1966

If the 106-cap career of Frank Lampard is regarded as an England disappointment, then so is everyone's since 1966

They say there’s no worse feeling than losing in a final. Presumably that’s exacerbated when there’s so much at stake. One look at the forlorn figure of Lionel Messi ascending the steps at the Maracana this summer would certainly suggest as much.

Man Utd confidence 'shot' after 4-0 MK Dons defeat, says David May

Man Utd confidence 'shot' after 4-0 MK Dons defeat, says David May

Louis van Gaal’s first task in the wake of Manchester United’s shock second round Capital One Cup defeat to MK Dons is to rebuild the team’s broken confidence, says former United defender David May.

Where will Angel di Maria fit in at Manchester United?

Where will Angel di Maria fit in at Manchester United?

It was only May that Angel di Maria was receiving the man of the match award in the Champions League final. It was his slaloming run beyond three players that provided the catalyst for Gareth Bale’s crucial goal, putting Real Madrid ahead in extra time and all but securing La Décima.