Blogs & Opinion

Swansea v Cardiff could be the last Welsh derby in top flight for some time, says Jeff Stelling

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 6th February 2014 view comments

It's been a historic season for Welsh football with two sides in the Premier League and a Swansea and Cardiff derby is as feisty and acrimonious as they come.

But the fans better make the most of it because it could be their last top flight derby for some time.

Both of the clubs started the season with such promise; in my opinion, had two of the best managers in place in Malky Mackay and Michael Laudrup, while there had also been a lot of money spent by both sides.

Jenkins: the Swansea chairman gave Michael Laudrup the chop this week

Jenkins: the Swansea chairman gave Michael Laudrup the chop this week

Cardiff were buoyant from their promotion to the top league of football for the first time since the 1961/62 season, and Swansea had silverware in the cupboard having won the League Cup.

What could possibly go wrong?

Now we have them both looking over their shoulders at potential relegation, two rookie bosses in charge and the pair of them going in to a derby that neither of side dare lose.


Laudrup has gone this week but his departure hasn't been condemned by Swansea fans, so they clearly weren't by any means behind him to a man.

How did we get to this position with both these clubs when the season started with such great potential?

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

Obviously that was partly down to results but he's an urbane, laidback character, not really a shouter or the sort that shows passion on the touchline, and maybe that's gone against him.

They haven't been the same team this season as they were last, there's no question about that, but they've played a huge number of games with the Europa League and the FA Cup as well.

They've missed Michu, in particular, who's been out for the last 10 games and one or two of the signings have not paid off, while plenty of players have been below form.

I wouldn't excuse Laudrup for the things that have gone wrong because every week it was change, change, change - there were more changes than Taylor Swift in concert!

It looks likes Laudrup may have been leaving at the end of the season anyway and I suspect that's one of the reasons why Huw Jenkins has decided to sack him because Swansea have got a great reputation for appointing good managers and giving them plenty of time.

I saw an article that quoted 'Wales Online' this week saying: "It could be his style works well at a different club.' Well, where exactly do Swansea see themselves?

They're in the Premier League at the moment, they may well be a Premier League side next season as well, they won silverware last season, they're in Europe.

It strikes me his style was working pretty well at this club not a different one! Do they believe they're going to be contenders for European places season in season out, because that's not going to happen!

I might be in the minority in terms of Swansea fans but I'm sorry to see him go but, having said that, you've got to say good luck to Gary Monk.

They've got some tough away games to come and they need to win their home matches but they've got Wilfried Bony, who has got 15 goals this season and really looks the part, and with him you've always got a terrific chance of survival.


And that brings us on to Cardiff.

Although they have brought Kenwyne Jones in, they don't have that goal scorer - Wilfried Zaha came on and made an impact in the game against Norwich but he's not prolific by any means.

Thirteen goals in 129 league games is one in 10 and a lot of those games were in the Championship. He's a game changer but not necessarily a match winner and that's a big concern for Cardiff and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.

They got that win against Norwich last week which reportedly prompted Vincent Tan to say afterwards: "I'm very happy with Solskjaer, he's much better than Mackay."

Two years down the line he might be saying the same thing and at that stage he might be saying it with some sort of credibility, but at this stage we give him none whatsoever.

Malkay got some terrific results and although Ole Gunnar may go on to be a great manager, not everything was perfect to say the least in that win over Norwich.

The Canaries had 27 shots on the Cardiff goal and you're not often going to win games when the opposition have 27 shots at your goal, while they've also not kept a clean sheet in the league yet under Ole.

It's very, very early days but they're going to look at their games to come and think they have a chance; they've got Villa, Hull, Fulham, Palace and Stoke all to come and they're going to be key.

But, how did we get to this position with both these clubs from a season that started with such great potential.


First of all I must mention Torquay, who went to Portsmouth and won 1-0 despite being woken at 2am the night before when their hotel started to flood. The squad were then left in the reception area to their own devices until 5am in the morning, which proves you don't necessarily need a good night's sleep to get a good result.

Under some circumstance they MIGHT have got 'Gem of the Week', but there were some great performances this week including Chelsea's win at Man City and Sunderland's at Newcastle but, I'm going for Leeds beating Huddersfield 5-1.

Obviously it was the circumstances of this victory. It says a lot about what the players and the fans think about Brian McDermott that they reacted in the way they did in a local derby and Ross McCormack's hat-trick spoke volumes. That was brilliant but I do wonder, who's turn it is this week to have a go managing Leeds?

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Redknapp

Redknapp: Costa's made a difference

Diego Costa has shown the impact he can have at Chelsea, but injuries are a worry, says Jamie Redknapp....

Gary Neville

Neville: Arsenal must sign a striker

Arsenal must sign a replacement for injured Olivier Giroud if they want to win the title, says Gary Neville....

Jeff Stelling

Stelling: Fears for Leeds

Jeff Stelling is worried that headline-making Leeds could end up slipping back into League One. ...

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Chelsea agree to loan Fernando Torres to AC Milan for two years, while Liverpool's Daniel Agger is linked with Brondby.

Torres heading for Milan

Chelsea striker Fernando Torres will have a medical at AC Milan on Saturday ahead of an agreed two-year loan deal.

Premier League preview

Chelsea travel to Everton for Saturday Night Football, while Super Sunday features Tottenham against Liverpool and Leicester versus Arsenal.

Top-four target for van Gaal

Louis van Gaal has set Manchester United an initial target of a top-four finish in this season's Premier League.

UEFA to revamp seeding system

UEFA has confirmed it is close to changing the seeding system for the group stages of the Champions League.


Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Everyone agreed that Tottenham had acquired some fine players in the summer of 2013, but the notorious line that Spurs sold Elvis to buy the Beatles soon became a source of embarrassment. Not least because that cast young Erik Lamela as John Lennon, the most celebrated of the lot.

Analysis: Everton's signing of Samuel Eto'o can be significant on and off the pitch for Roberto Martinez's side

Analysis: Everton's signing of Samuel Eto'o can be significant on and off the pitch for Roberto Martinez's side

Saturday’s opponents Chelsea might have expected Everton’s Romelu Lukaku to come back to haunt them, but Jose Mourinho surely thought he’d seen the back of Samuel Eto’o. Instead he’s back in the Premier League and eyeing another challenge in his remarkable career.

Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

When it comes to the art of signing players, few did it better than Brian Clough and Peter Taylor. In the latter’s book With Clough by Taylor he explained some of the science behind it in detailing how Nottingham Forest actively sought to buy players they perceived to have personal problems.