Blogs & Opinion

Phil Clarke:

Most Popular Posts:

Recent Comments:

Trevor Fuller on Running on empty

"Hi Phil, Another interesting & thought-provoking article here! One thing I'd like to know is, if you compare this situation currently with clubs in the NRL in Australia or New ... " View all comments

Reaping the rewards

Investing in youth pays off, says Phil

Phil Clarke Posted 5th October 2011 view comments

Congratulations to Leeds and St Helens for getting to this year's engage Super League Grand Final.

Leeds will walk out for the fourth time in the last five years and, well, St Helens do it that often that some of their supporters just think that it's the last game of the season.

Both clubs seem to be built on strong foundations and have what people in sport and business describe as a 'winning culture'.

St Helens star Jonny Lomax

St Helens star Jonny Lomax

They must do the things behind the scenes that we never see but are essential in creating the environment to produce champions.

We often talk about the effort made with their junior development. Well I just want to tell you a brief story about how hard St Helens work at improving the players that they recruit.

They are a shining example, not just in rugby league, but to any football, cricket, rugby union or other team sport that attempts to develop young talent into first team regulars.

St Helens are a shining example, not just in rugby league, but to any football, cricket, rugby union or other team sport that attempts to develop young talent into first team regulars.

Phil Clarke
Quotes of the week

Super League Grand Final

St Helens v Leeds
5pm, Sat, Sky Sports HD1
Watch on the move with Sky Go
How to remote record

On Sunday, less than 24 hours after they've played in the Grand Final, several of their staff will take a tour party to Australia. The squad will be made up of the 16-and-17-year-old players that the club are looking to nurture.

They'll play against four teams in the Sydney area and get to experience the pace and intensity of Australian rugby league. There is a significant cost to all this and the staff have to work hard to fundraise for the tour, but it will certainly be worth it.

This isn't the first time that they've done it. The club took a squad of players there in 2004, of which Paul Cough and Scott Moore appeared. They did it again in 2006 when players like Lee Gaskell, Jonny Lomax, Gary Wheeler, Andrew Dixon, Matthew Ashurst, Shaun Magennis and Tom Armstrong had the experience of testing their skills against the best junior teams in the Sydney area.

Two years ago another party left St Helens, this time with players like Thomas Makinson, Nathan Ashe and Scott Hale representing the Saints Down Under.

If I told you that 14 of the 17 players who represented the club against Harlequins in Round 27 this year had been on a club tour of Australia you'd start to realise how successful they are at making dreams become a reality for so many youngsters.

The effort taken to organise and pay for a trip like this is massive. The staff involved have just completed a difficult and demanding season and yet will have their suitcases packed before the Grand Final kicks off to ensure that their conveyor belt of production doesn't stop.

Smith stands tall

I would also like to take this opportunity to thank Warrington coach Tony Smith.

Firstly for the way that his team have entertained us this season, scoring almost 200 tries and finishing at the top of the table, but more importantly for me, the manner in which he spoke after his team had lost last Friday.

My old PE teacher at school used to say that we had to win with humility and lose with dignity. That's quite easy when you're only talking about sport at school, but the Warrington coach managed to do it after his team had lost in such dramatic circumstances in a game that they were favourites to win.

He never looked for excuses, never questioned the officials and showed tremendous sportsmanship. If he can do that in professional sport, then I hope that so can all of the players, parents and coaches in all of the junior and amateur games that takes place this year.

Phil answers your emails...

Got a question for Phil? Email him at or use the feedback form below...

Play-off farce

Phil, clearly the play-offs provide a great spectacle and as a Rhinos fan I am more than happy that we have reached the Grand Final, but can the current system really be justified when Leeds, a team who finished fifth, have reached the final instead of the best team playing the most attractive rugby this year? What's more the club call decision has, for the first time, come back to haunt the choosers. Leeds' form has been inconsistent at times to say the least so surely these arguments only point to the fact that the play-offs are no reward for the top teams but for mediocrity. Surely a system like the Football League's involving four teams would be more appropriate?
Ben M

PHIL REPLIES: It's over a decade ago since the clubs in Super League decided to shift the big prize to the end of the play-offs. Some people like it, some people don't. As a player I was always taught to get on with things, not to worry about things that I couldn't control or influence, and as a result I haven't spent too long questioning the rights and wrongs of the current format.

It seems to add to the excitement for both the players and fans and I've never heard any of the players or coaches complain about it. I doubt you'll see an interview with a Warrington player who says that they are the real champions.

I'm not a fan of the club call decision, but again, if the people who get paid to decided these things can convince the clubs to go with it, then I'll accept that and see where it takes us.

I don't for one second think that Warrington's decision to play against Leeds gave them any extra motivation. You're not telling me that the Rhinos could try any harder than they were prepared to do after making sacrifices for 10 months and going through so much pain to get within 80 minutes of the Grand Final.

Every player, coach, administrator and supporter of rugby league knew the rules on the January 1. We all know that it was possible to finish eighth, lose more games than you won, concede more points than you scored and still get a chance to lift the Big Trophy at Old Trafford.

Personally, I think that a Top 8 play-off is too many from a 14 team competition, but again, I don't get paid to influence this. The rules are the rules.

In my mind professional sport is all about providing enjoyment and entertainment for others. From what I saw on the faces of the St Helens and Leeds supporters last weekend the play-offs certainly did that.

Widening the net

Phil, Do you think it is right that Steve McNamara is trying to 'poach' players from Australia? Apparently the latest player in his sights is Daly Cherry-Evans. What kind of message does that send out to some of our British born and bred players and about the quality we are producing in our leagues?
Simon Barlow

PHIL REPLIES: I don't know if the word is 'poach', that usually implies that you're catching something illegally on someone else's territory. As far as I can see he's doing nothing but widening his net when it comes to recruiting eligible players.

Let me ask you a question: "What was the nationality of the player who scored the winning try for New Zealand against Australia in last year's Four Nations Final?"

I'll let you think for a while and say that my initial reaction was one of disappointment when I heard about Rangi Chase making the England squad. He's a brilliant player and I've loved watching him play this year if we are not careful we'll end up with Australia playing Australia A.

Nathan Fien was the try scorer in Brisbane last year for the Kiwis. He's Australian and was born in Queensland. Just like Rangi Chase, he qualified under Residency rules and has been an important part of their squad for the last few years.

I've almost stopped worrying about where people come from in international sport and just try to enjoy the game. The same thing happens in cricket, athletics, rugby union and football even, although more in other countries than here. I'm just going to go along and try to enjoy it.

Comments (4)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Ross Jervis says...

Phil. This is the first time I have ever written an e-mail of this nature to an individual or organization before. I am writing to talk about my utter disappointment of the anti St Helens presence in the Sky Sports studio on Saturday night. You made a number of comments during the game and it was all about Leeds. Leeds this, Leeds that. I understand that yourself and Brian Carney have an affinity with the Wigan Rugby League club but still you work for a national TV channel and you should have a totally un-biased opinion. Not once did you talk about how St Helens played during the game. You didn¿t highlight anything positive about them and would rather talk about the un-doubted talents of Leeds. Yes Leeds are champions but St Helens could quite easily have won that on another day. We had two big injuries along the way on Saturday with both Wellens and Shenton leaving the field. St Helens also had five youngsters playing in the backs. Gaskell and Lomax are barely out of nappies and yet they gave Leeds one hell of a fight. A bit of un-biased appreciation wouldn¿t go a miss. Thank you. Ross

Posted 15:19 9th October 2011

Harry Foster says...

Phil, I would appreciate your opinon on the following, which may produce a solution to the farce of a team finishing third or fifth to be crowned Champions ! I am a Saints fan but in my opinion the real Champions are Warrington as they have been the most consistant team over a season, not just one game.1. I suggest that the RFL purchase a new trophy worthy of presentation to Champions 2.The playoffs to be retained with the top eight teams but on a knockout basis with a proper draw similar to the Challenge Cup selecting the venue and teams. The final being played at Old Trafford with the current trophy being presented to the winners. This would ensure the exitement and revenue the playoffs produce would be retained, without the farce element. The winners of the Leauge and the Playoffs could then play each other with the winners of thatt game going on to play in the World Club Challenge. Obviously if the winners of the League and the playoffs are the same team they could play the winners of the Challenge Cup.

Posted 08:57 7th October 2011

Max Stewart says...

Phil, Just a quick question, in your opinion, how come Kevin Sinfield never seems to get mentioned when it comes round to man of steel time, if there is a more influential player in the superleague, I've yet to see him, there's no biast in my question, I'm a Wigan fan but nearly every time I have watched Leeds on tv Kevin Sinfield either baffles the opposition with his brains to gain advantage or manages to win a game with his kicks under massive pressure, do these things not count for anything????

Posted 11:28 6th October 2011

Dave Hickson says...

Phil, For an English player, does playing 1st team rugby in the NRL guarantee a starting spot in the national side? The standard of the NRL is higher than ESL and with Gareth Ellis, Chris Heighington possible second row canditates do they automatically command a starting spot due to the higher standard of the league they play in? With Eng RL not having a rule whereby players not playing in the ESL are not eligible to be selected to play in the national team it is a very difficult task for Steve Mac to fairly judge because although Ben Westwood & Jamie Jones Buchanan say for example have been form 2nd rower's but are acknowledged to be playing in a lesser competition. Should Gareth Widdop be chosen before Danny Brough will more English players be tempted to go to the NRL because they are more likely to start for the national team. Should an international playing rule simiar to Austrialia be considered whereby players only playing in their national competition be eligible to play for the national team? Our problem is lack of depth and competition for places and Steve is trying to increase this via controversial means but also importing NRL playing resources. If I was a form centre playing in ESL should I be worried of a starting place because Jack Reed, an extremely talented option, is a NRL player? I don't envy Steve's selection choice but should NRL players be chosen ahead of ESL players Buderus's thoughts could prove correct.

Posted 17:26 5th October 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Latest News RSS feeds

Koukash will not quit Salford

Salford owner Marwan Koukash is not walking away from the club and is bringing in Australia coach Tim Sheens to help.

Hock among six to face charges

Six players face RFL disciplinary charges from last weekend's games with Salford's Gareth Hock charged twice.

Hat-tricks win it for Wakefield

Chris Riley and Jacob Miller scored hat-tricks as Wakefield beat Hull KR 44-24 in the Super League.

Wakefield boss hails Riley

Wakefield coach James Webster praised Chris Riley following their 44-24 home victory over Hull KR.

Wildcats sign Arundel

Wakefield Trinity Wildcats sign Arundel from Super League rivals Hull FC until the end of the season.


Rugby League Rocks!

Rugby League Rocks!

Get your tickets for Rugby League Rocks as we get set to usher in an exciting new era for the sport.

Top five rugby league moments of 2014

Top five rugby league moments of 2014

We look back on a memorable year of rugby league that includes one heck of a tackle, some trying-scoring acrobatics and THAT punch...

Our experts gives their view on what we can expect from Sam Burgess

Our experts gives their view on what we can expect from Sam Burgess

Sam Burgess has been named on Bath's replacements bench for Friday's clash with Harlequins at the Recreation Ground and much is expected of the former rugby league star known as 'Slammin Sam'.