Blogs & Opinion

Phil Clarke:

Most Popular Posts:

Recent Comments:

Trevor Fuller on Running on empty

"Hi Phil, Another interesting & thought-provoking article here! One thing I'd like to know is, if you compare this situation currently with clubs in the NRL in Australia or New ... " View all comments

Stats never lie!

Phil Clarke Posted 13th June 2013 view comments

Will England beat the Exiles and convince the country they can win the World Cup? All of the sound bites I've heard from the England camp tell me they 'believe' they're good enough to win the 'big prize'. However, on Friday night, they need not just a win, but to look like a team.

Steve McNamara's side will be minus any players that he might want to select from Down Under. James Graham, Sam Burgess, Gareth Widdop and Jack Reed could possibly make the side to face Australia in the opening game in Cardiff on October 26, but the first ones in the jersey have a great chance to make it impossible for Steve to take it off them.

Does Kirmond deserve an England jersey?

Does Kirmond deserve an England jersey?

Selecting a side isn't an easy task, and there's obviously no right or wrong. If you've ever watched the Stats Pack show on a Wednesday evening on Sky Sports you will have seen our Opta Team of the Week. This is a side compiled from the game scores awarded by Opta. They observe every action, both good and bad, where it takes place on the field, the time in the game and the score at the time.

One of the advantages of using a statistical approach is that it strips away any of the biases that we might subconsciously have.

Phil Clarke
Quotes of the week

You're given points for doing good things and have them taken away for mistakes. A try to win the match in the last minute of the game from your own half of the field gains you more points than a try in the first half when your team is already 30 points ahead and you simply put the ball over the line. They total all of these together for a player at the end of the game then end with an average score of around 350.

Not perfect

Obviously the scoring system isn't perfect, nothing is, but it does provide us with a consistent way to compare the performances of all the players across Super League. In fact, Opta are also starting to do the NRL games as well, so we'll look at the game scores of the English players Down Under to see how they compare later in the year.

Using a minimum of 10 Super League games to qualify, this was the side selected using the highest average game score.

1. Sam Tomkins
2. Josh Charnley
3. Leroy Cudjoe
4.Kallum Watkins
5. Ryan Hall
6. Kevin Sinfield
7. Richie Myler

I've not seen the team Steve has selected to start but I imagine that the back line is very similar to this. Clearly there's no chance of Watkins playing, he's injured, so the other options are Hardaker or Ferres, but I'd like to see Stefan Ratchford picked instead. I think he's brilliant. His average game score as a centre was higher than the two centres above, but he's only been selected there for one game this year. He's scored just less than Sinfield in his 11 games at stand-off and almost as high as Tomkins when he's played four games at full-back.

The pack proposed under the Opta game score will be quite different to the one that now runs out at Warrington on Friday evening. Here are the players with the highest Opta game score:

8. Jamie Peacock
9. Danny Houghton
10. Eorl Crabtree
11. Liam Farrell
12. Danny Kirmond
13. Jon Wilkin

It's interesting that after retiring from international rugby league, Jamie Peacock is possibly having his best ever season. My colleague at Sky, Ian Proctor, pointed out a very interesting fact recently when we were discussing the influence that Peacock has on the Rhinos. In his first four seasons at Leeds, he missed a total of 10 games, the Rhinos lost just once (90% success rate). In the last four seasons, he's missed 35 games for Leeds of which they've lost 12, drawn 2 and won 21 (60% success rate). Both his performances and his presence have a massive bearing on his team's chances of winning. A player's game time (how long he spends on the field) has some relevance to his game score, particularly for the forwards.

James Roby would have been selected with his average game score but he hadn't played enough games to qualify under our system.

I suppose the stand-out name on this list is Danny Kirmond. It can sometimes be hard for a player in a team in the lower half of the league to stand out and impress.

His club might not be that glamorous and he might not have played in any finals or Grand Finals, but one of the advantages of using a statistical approach is that it strips away any biases we might subconsciously have.

If you were sat with your mates and dreaming up your back row players, it's very easy to think of the players who've been selected before. Players like Gareth Hock or Gareth Ellis spring to mind, but I wonder how Danny Kirmond would look in an England shirt?

The thing that I learned whilst working in the Great Britain squad a few years ago was that the team that starts a tournament or Test Series is never the same one that finishes it. This year's England squad will probably lose three or four players due to injury/illness or even suspension. Keeping the fringe members happy when they're not in the squad or team is sometimes the hardest part of picking a team.

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

To Hull and back

Phil Clarke looks at the mental damage done to Hull FC and Huddersfield in the Challenge Cup....

Luke Dorn

Tackling the issue

Luke Dorn on the dangers involved in tackling and praises two legends of Super League....

Phil Clarke

Hero of our game

Phil Clarke pays tribute to Ray Unsworth, who helped change the face of rugby league in the UK....

Latest News RSS feeds

Rovers bring in Ulugia

Hull KR have signed winger Wayne Ulugia following his release by North Queensland Cowboys.

Hull KR v Hull FC: Teams

Hull KR and Hull FC both go into the first city derby of the season, which is live on Sky Sports, in fine form.

Broncos v Dragons: Teams

London Broncos will be without Jamie O'Callaghan when they welcome the Catalan Dragons to Hive Stadium on Thursday.

Bulls v Rhinos: Teams

Rob Burrow will bring up a personal milestone for Leeds on Thursday night, but the visitors are without Jamie Peacock.

Fan apologises to Burgess

A female fan has apologised to England forward Sam Burgess for attacking him with the stick of a flag.


Good week/Bad week: The winners and losers from the last sporting week

Good week/Bad week: The winners and losers from the last sporting week

It's been another incredible week of sport from Augusta to Anfield via Andalusia, but for every sporting hero there must be a villain.

Super League XVIV: Tony Rea looks at big weekends for Paul Wellens and Jamie Peacock

Super League XVIV: Tony Rea looks at big weekends for Paul Wellens and Jamie Peacock

St Helens shine on Paul Wellens' big day, but Cas earn plaudits, too

Super League: Castleford look to learn from mistakes following home loss to St Helens

Super League: Castleford look to learn from mistakes following home loss to St Helens

What would be the best word to describe Castleford’s 30-28 loss to St Helens in round eight of Super League – gutting? Devastating? Perhaps, even, undeserved?