Blogs & Opinion


Phil Clarke:

Most Popular Posts:

Recent Comments:

Trevor Fuller on Running on empty

"Hi Phil, Another interesting & thought-provoking article here! One thing I'd like to know is, if you compare this situation currently with clubs in the NRL in Australia or New ... " View all comments

Moneyball!

Will Super League follow football's financial fair play rules?

Phil Clarke Posted 19th June 2013 view comments

Deloitte recently published their Annual Review of Football Finance and the wages paid to players is always one of the topics that catches the eye.

Just like in rugby league, the teams which pay the most always have the greatest chance of success - not every team in Super League spends the full salary cap, which is one of the reasons why we've only had six different teams in our Grand Final - but the introduction of the financial fair play rules in football are enforcing football clubs to think about the way that they pay their players.

Salford owner Marwan Koukash has brought financial stability to the club

Salford owner Marwan Koukash has brought financial stability to the club

Prior to 1996, most rugby league players received approximately 50% or less of their wages as a guaranteed amount, with the rest paid on appearance and success. If you were in the team and the team kept winning then you earned more money. This system of performance related pay was scrapped over the first few years of Super League and almost every player signed a contract that gave him a guaranteed salary.

I am aware of an NRL club who used to reward one of its players on the number of tries that he scored in season. He even came over and played in Super League at the end of his career. However, I don't think that this type of individual goal is a clever one. He's likely not to pass to a support player when he makes a break if he knows that he'll lose his reward.

Phil Clarke
Quotes of the week

At present the average salary of a Super League player is approximately £65,000 per annum. If he plays the majority of his team's games, and they were to win the Grand Final, he might receive a bonus of approximately £10,000. He's basically guaranteed about 95% of his money whether he's selected or not, and there's the potential of a small bonus if his team win. Only one team can win the Grand Final, I know £10,000 isn't 5% of £65,000.

When Wigan were the dominant team in the UK in that period 1990-1995, the majority of the financial reward was paid on an incentive-based system. If you weren't fit or good enough to be in the team for that match, you didn't get any of the 'carrot' at the end of it. The competition at training was as intense as ever.

Motivation

Many people in rugby league naively assumed that by spending the salary cap their team would have an equal chance to the rest of winning the prize. One or two clubs have spent the full salary cap and still finished in the bottom half, massively underachieving.

Other factors also come in to consideration and I think that how the money is paid is the next big change to happen in rugby league. Some coaches may disagree with me, but I believe that the players' motivation can be increased without disrupting player satisfaction or the team dynamic by using an incentive-based pay structure.

You might say that the players won't accept a shift back to performance related pay when they've become accustomed to having it guaranteed, but I disagree. Obviously they need a certain amount guaranteed, say 60% in my opinion, with the potential to earn 120% of their salary should they and their team hit all of the targets. The club and the player gain if the team is successful.

One of the reasons why I think this will come back into fashion is because it already has, in football anyway. Ferran Soriano is now the Chief Executive of Manchester City Football Club, and it's starting to happen there. He previously worked as Finance Director of Barcelona, where it was used to help the club become the champions of Europe. His ideas were ridiculed initially. Nowadays, more and more football clubs are using this model.

Banding

It's perhaps not a surprise that the clubs that have been most successful in the Super League have a 'banding' system for their players. They group their players into a pay structure which rewards their experience/success.

I am aware of an NRL club who used to reward one of its players on the number of tries that he scored in season. He even came over and played in Super League at the end of his career. However, I don't think that this type of individual goal is a clever one. He's likely not to pass to a support player when he makes a break if he knows that he'll lose his reward.

One of the reasons why this hasn't been introduced back into rugby league in the UK is because of the salary cap. Clubs say that the current rules make it impossible. Well, change the rules then!

It's not as if the salary cap's been working that well anyway. Salford, Bradford, Wakefield have all had their financial difficulties in recent times and the Celtic Crusaders went into financial meltdown. The rules are supposed to help the game, not hinder it.

I believe that it's still possible to have a 'salary cap' that accommodates a performance related pay model. We want to see the best rewarded for their efforts and I want to see them desperate to win each game.

What do you think?

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Martin Arkwright says...

Couldn't agree more really our game needs to do something it is dying under the current concept. We need to be innovative and come up with something new , I would like to see an overseas quota reintroduced with a maximum of 3 overseas players allowed per club . Also if we are to continue with the play offs we need to stop rewarding mediocrity a team finishing 6 , 7 or 8 for me hasn't played well enough all season to be in the play offs , but a team finishing top should make it straight to the final . I would also like to see promotion and relegation brought back because I believe to many teams have nothing to play for once we get to round 10 of the competition . I believe doing this will create intrest for fans to. Finally I would like to see Lancashire V Yorkshire return in an origin style format but pricing for tickets should be something like £10 for adults and £5 for kids and concessions and we persevere with concept for a few years . I believe if you get the fans intrested you will get the players intrested eventually

Posted 13:57 19th June 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

Rules of the gain?

Phil Clarke is worried some of the basic laws are being ignored just to make rugby league faster....

Barrie vs Terry

Barrie v Terry

Barrie McDermott and Terry O'Connor go head-to-head with their Super League predictions......

Latest News RSS feeds

Walker extends Bulls stay

Chev Walker has agreed a new one-year deal with Bradford meaning he will remain at at the Bulls throughout next season.

Bosc pens Catalan extension

Thomas Bosc has signed a one-year contract extension with the option of a further 12 months at Catalan Dragons.

Hauraki relishing Rhinos clash

Castleford's Weller Hauraki is relishing the prospect of taking on Leeds in Saturday's Challenge Cup final at Wembley.

Powell wary of McGuire backlash

Danny McGuire will have a chance to gain revenge on old Leeds boss Daryl Powell when he takes on the Tigers on Saturday.

Chan to return to Australia

Hull KR's on-loan forward Jason Chan has confirmed he is returning to Australia at the end of the Super League season.

Features

Tetley's Challenge Cup final: Castleford Tigers v Leeds Rhinos key battles

Tetley's Challenge Cup final: Castleford Tigers v Leeds Rhinos key battles

Ahead of Saturday's mouth-watering Tetley's Challenge Cup final from Wembley we break down where the game could be won.

Good week/Bad week: Best and worst from the sporting world in the past seven days

Good week/Bad week: Best and worst from the sporting world in the past seven days

Another busy period of action has thrown up plenty of contenders for our weekly pick of the winners and losers.