Blogs & Opinion

End of a legend

Toney has nothing left to prove in boxing, says Wayne

Wayne McCullough Posted 10th April 2012 view comments

I think most boxing fans ask the same question when they hear James Toney is still fighting - why?

He is a legend of the sport, was once one of the top pound-for-pound fighters around and he made a lot of money. But does he still have it?

He won three division championships and drew with Hasim Rahman for his fourth in March 2006. He lost the interim WBA cruiserweight belt to Denis Lebedev in Russia last November by a total shut out in every round.

Missing links: most of Toney's best skills and defensive moves have gone, says Wayne

Missing links: most of Toney's best skills and defensive moves have gone, says Wayne

Toney had some of the best skills and defensive moves of any fighter in any generation but most of this is gone. He is getting hit easily and, at 43 years old, he is truly not the same fighter he was back when he was campaigning at middleweight which, in my opinion, was his best weight class.

He won the IBF middleweight belt against Michael Nunn in May 1991 and defended it six times; including a draw to Mike McCallum, before moving up and defeating Iran Barkley in February 1993 for the IBF super middleweight title. He made three defences of that belt before suffering his first loss to Roy Jones Jr in November 1994.

As I suspected, Gunn had nothing in reply. Toney's skills have been long gone but Gunn didn't have anything to start with.

Wayne McCullough
Quotes of the week

After the Jones fight Toney moved up to light heavyweight where he did not win a major title, then on up to cruiser where dethroned Vassiliy Jirov in a great fight in April 2003 to claim the IBF belt.


A lot of big names have faced Toney and a lot of them have lost.

Now almost 23 years since his pro debut in October 1989, Toney fought Canadian Bobby Gunn, who had been knocked out by Enzo Maccarinelli in April 2007. Gunn's last fight was a loss for the IBF cruiserweight belt when the bout was stopped after the fourth round in a fight with Tomasz Adamek in July 2009.

Gunn had a record of 21-4-1 with 18 knock outs compared to Toney who had a 73-7-3 with 44 knock outs record. Toney had more ko's than Gunn had fights.

This fight was a spectacle for Toney and he probably didn't earn much money. He got a good payday when he talked Dana White into letting him fight in the UFC, saying it would be easy for him. He got his shot in 2010 when he faced Randy Couture who was at the end of his career. Toney was taken down in 15 seconds and submitted shortly after that - it was an embarrassment.

The Gunn fight proved nothing if Toney won. Gunn was 38-years-old and had never fought at Toney's level.

Toney weighed in over 48lbs heavier than his last fight and the second heaviest of his career. Gunn also weighed the heaviest of his career at 210lbs.

Toney was trying to be his usual defensive self, hiding behind his left shoulder and picking shots to his opponent's body and head. As I suspected, Gunn had nothing in reply. Toney's skills have been long gone but Gunn didn't have anything to start with.

Toney was winning the fight easily as there was nothing coming back at him. Sometimes he got hit but it was a mismatch from the get-go.

Even though Toney will never be the fighter he was, he still had more than Gunn. He was awarded the victory after five rounds when Gunn's corner pulled him out claiming he had a broken hand .

Older, heavier and half the talent he was in his heyday, Toney has nothing left to prove in boxing. Unfortunately he will probably fight again because he got the win so he will be on the lookout for a big name fighter for another big payday.

back to top

Other Boxing Experts:

Latest Posts in Boxing:

Johnny Nelson

Collisions, of course!

Johnny Nelson expects Carl Froch and James DeGale to get it on but will we see a Liverpool battle, too?...

Latest News RSS feeds

Chisora out of Fury fight

Dereck Chisora has been forced to withdraw from Saturday's fight with Tyson Fury in Manchester.

Sky Sports News HQ is coming

Sky Sports News will relaunch on channel 401 as Sky Sports News HQ from August 12.

Macklin lands WBC eliminator

Matthew Macklin faces Jorge Sebastien Heiland in Dublin in August in a final eliminator for the WBC middleweight title.

Fury unfazed by board's charge

Tyson Fury insisted he was not concerned by a misconduct charge before injury forced Dereck Chisora's withdrawal.

Smith handed world title shot

Paul Smith confident of beating WBO champion Arthur Abrahams after confirmation the bout will be held on September 27.


Ringside Toe 2 Toe

Ringside Toe 2 Toe

Welcome to the Ringside Toe 2 Toe podcast, an online offering from bringing you the latest news and views from the world of boxing.

Second Shout - 12th July

Second Shout - 12th July

Paul Smith and Ed Robinson discuss the results and reaction to a big night of boxing in Liverpool.

Cleverly the bookmakers favourite as rematch with Bellew nears

Cleverly the bookmakers favourite as rematch with Bellew nears

Online bookmaker Sky Bet have made Nathan Cleverly the odds-on favourite to win his highly anticipated rematch with Tony Bellew.