Blogs & Opinion


Phil Thompson:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

Right man, right time

Roy can lead Reds to a top four finish

Phil Thompson - Phil Thompson Posted 1st July 2010 view comments

Roy Hodgson is definitely the right man for Liverpool.

I think it's a timing issue and the time is right for somebody like Roy, an Englishman, to come in and steady the ship.

This fella has a very impressive CV. He's got international experience with Switzerland and Finland, and also has experience managing at the top level of club football with no less than two spells at Inter Milan.

Hodgson: has an impressive CV

Hodgson: has an impressive CV

You can argue he didn't do well at Blackburn when he took over there back in 1997, and again maybe that was a timing issue, but he has certainly resurrected himself at Fulham in the last couple of seasons.

He got them to the Europa League final last season and that was an astonishing achievement really and he deserved to be named manager of the year by the League Managers Association.

He realises that there are big problems at Liverpool and his first priority will be to keep hold of Steven Gerrard and Fernando Torres, but it's not just those two. There are other players too and I think it's very important that he keeps all his top players.

Phil Thompson
Quotes of the week

What he will definitely bring is good man management skills. We've seen how he's got the best out of players at Fulham, players who had failed to deliver under previous managers.

Bobby Zamora played like a dream for him and Danny Murphy has performed wonders and he has a good manner in the way he talks to and deals with players.

He's also shown that he has a good eye for a signing having bought players like Brede Hangeland to the Premier League.

Murphy, from what I've been led to believe, has painted a really good picture of him to Steven Gerrard and Jamie Carragher and they are a big influence when it comes to the other players.

Advice

I think he would've probably sought the advice from his good friend and former Liverpool manager Gerard Houllier about the club as well.

OK you could say a lot of things have changed since Gerard was at the club, but he still knows exactly what it is like as a football club. And I'm 100 per cent sure he would have sung the virtues of the fans and the club as a whole.

But I don't think it would have taken Roy too much time to decide because this has probably been the ultimate job for him.

Problems

He realises that there are big problems at Liverpool and his first priority will be to keep hold of Steven Gerrard and Fernando Torres, but it's not just those two. There are other players too like Javier Mascherano, who has been linked with a move to Inter Milan, and I think it's very important that he keeps all his top players.

That said there are a few players that need to go. I think he has a kitty of about £15million to spend and if you sell a few you can probably take that up to about £30million to bring in two or three quality players.

He's said his objective is to get Liverpool back into the Champions League places, but it's going to be a tough task. We've gone from finishing second to seventh in the Premier League, which tells you that Manchester City are improving, Tottenham are improving and Aston Villa are improving.

So it's going to become more and more difficult, but I believe with a few good signings we will finish fourth and that's the aim he has to set for the players.

Comments (120)

Tom Broderick (Queens Park Rangers fan) says...

I agree with alot of the comments as there is uncertainty at Liverpool. I watch alot of football when not seeing my beloved QPR and I was at Birmingham when Benitez took off Torres and saw the reaction of joy from the blues and groans of despair from the Liverpool fans. I respect Liverpool fans loyalty to their previous managers and hope it lasts asI suspect it may take one or more steps back to step forward. Stick with Roy for a few years and change the ownership issue and Liverpool will return as a force. Fraternally Tom

Posted 19:04 1st August 2010

Sabbir Hossain (Liverpool fan) says...

According to the situation no one is better then roy. He is the perfect choice. Hopefully he will give some positive result. Its better to see rafa goes, if he stayes two more season at anfield he will destroy the club. Thanks him for signing torres and kuyt during his perod and win CL 2005. Roy will made some good signing for the club and good use of money, not like rafa who totally wasted money like a rubbish. I like to see roy sell useless players from the club like mash? Hopefully he let the player to play their natural game in their favorite position and play with 4-3-3 formation at home and 4-4-2 formation at away. Come on roy lets fell proud for the club and bring honour.we all are with you, cause we never walk alone. Rupak from Bangladesh.(With LFC 4 ever)

Posted 06:56 31st July 2010

Sabbir Hossain (Liverpool fan) says...

According to the situation no one is better then roy. He is the perfect choice. Hopefully he will give some positive result. Its better to see rafa goes, if he stayes two more season at anfield he will destroy the club. Thanks him for signing torres and kuyt during his perod and win CL 2005. Roy will made some good signing for the club and good use of money, not like rafa who totally wasted money like a rubbish. I like to see roy sell useless players from the club like mash? Hopefully he let the player to play their natural game in their favorite position and play with 4-3-3 formation at home and 4-2-2 formation at away. Come on roy lets fell proud for the club and bring honour.we all are with you, cause we never walk alone. Rupak from Bangladesh.(With LFC 4 ever)

Posted 06:54 31st July 2010

Veli Mncwango (Manchester United fan) says...

Let''s face it, with the poor season liverpool had last season anyone who came in would be hailed as The messiah. Is hodgson the right man for the job? Who cares the problem Liverpool has are their owners. Untill that is resolved nothing will change unfortunatley Liverpool will finish outside of the top four again this comming season

Posted 11:22 30th July 2010

John Orr (Liverpool fan) says...

i have a feeling this is the manager to get us back on track, his pedigree speaks for itself ,if any manager can motivate a team he is the 1 and all us liverpool supporters should give him our full backing and get behind our team ,good luck Roy YNWA

Posted 13:35 29th July 2010

Kev Moore (Aston Villa fan) says...

Mr Thompson Mr Roy Hodgson does not seem to stay at a club more than four years hope you don¿t have a five year plan ? ?

Posted 08:08 29th July 2010

Mark Lackey (Liverpool fan) says...

You know what, he wasn''t my first choice, but since Roy has been Liverpool Manager, he has come across as totally professional, believable and above all else, talks sense. My only reservation is that we could have done with recruiting Roy 5 years ago!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Shankly would be proud, and I hope Roy can build a legacy over the next few years to pass on his expertise to his successor after the club is sold to new investors. I think over the short period he has been in charge he has already proved himself to be astute. I really hope he wins some silverware over the next few years to back up his professionalism. I really hope you get the budget to mold the future LFC success Roy, and you will be revered in our history. YNWA.

Posted 01:58 29th July 2010

Jacko Jakovljevic (Liverpool fan) says...

Having read all these responses all i can say is that at last for the 1st time in nearly 20 years we have a LIVERPOOL Manager! I wasn''t convinced when they got him but now we will be the surprise package next season and stop Man U overhalling our unbeaten record of 18 titles. Putting my neck out Roy will wihn us the ultimate prize!!!!!! Whether or not Mascherano is with us or not--Do we really need him? No-.one is bigger than Liverpool Football Club.

Posted 00:43 29th July 2010

Connor B (Newcastle United fan) says...

Roy hodgeson is the best English manager at the minute and I wish him all the best with Liverpool I hope they can get back to what they were 20 years ago and play good football I think Roy hodgeson is the man to get them back !!!

Posted 12:06 28th July 2010

Matthew Stanley (Liverpool fan) says...

i am extremely happy with the appointment of Roy hodgson because he actually has a clue about what he wamts with his team unlike benitez. remember v birmingham when they were drawing, he took torres off just before the end, UNBELIEVABLE, but hodgeson is a good manager and a person which the players can relate to and he has brought in Joe Cole which was a very good signing and had talks with Gerrard and he is certain to stay so all good there, the only thing to do now is to convince Torres and mascherano that they belong at anfield. I know that this is a big jump, but i think Liverpool will win the league, don''t laff but i belive we have abetter squad than manchester united, thier only good player is rooney and he is no in good form, not scared of them AT ALL

Posted 20:26 27th July 2010

Guy Anderson (Liverpool fan) says...

Roy is the right man for the job, all we need kim to do is to get us back were we should be in the next 5 to 6 years

Posted 12:52 26th July 2010

Maggie Pearce (Liverpool fan) says...

Give Roy a chance personally speaking as a liverpool fan for over 30 years he is just what Liverpool need right now ...Stability ....and hopefully keeping things behind closed doors ...not on the back pages of newspapers...the why it used to be.

Posted 20:55 25th July 2010

Ian Fairclough (Liverpool fan) says...

Ive just watch the post match interview with Roy Hodgson after the Kasierslauten game. I just want too add that it is such a breath of fresh air to hear a liverpool manager being honest, concise and optomistic. I am used to the same scripted answers that was Benitez. I wish him, the new players and the academy players all the best for the upcoming season, I am without doubt, that we the fans, will be behind them all the way. YNWA

Posted 19:39 24th July 2010

Brian Hamill (Barcelona fan) says...

I think Hodgson is a very good choice. Many ''fans'' demand a big name purely for the lustre of having a big name, but is someone like Rijkaard who has managed in Spain & Turkey, and who has never even played in England, really going to arrive in the Premiership and do a better job right off the bat than a guy who knows the club and the league like the back of his hand? Liverpool do not have big money for a manager nor for players, and here they have a manager with international experience, a guy who has proved he can operate on a limited budget, and a guy who is of good standing and is well-respected in the game - and they have not had to break the bank in doing so. It''s a very shrewd move. And his reign has started brilliantly, getting £5.5m for Benayoun then getting Cole for nothing!! Hodgson will have Liverpool back in the top four next year. There was no better candidate.

Posted 20:09 23rd July 2010

Craig Phillips (Liverpool fan) says...

every1 needs to calm down give roy a chance and our club end of the day every1 is putting us down as we finished 7th so what there wasn't actually that many points between us and the 4th place

Posted 14:05 23rd July 2010

Ste C (Liverpool fan) says...

Liverpool will win or come very close to winning the pl this coming season. Firstly i believe we already have the squad to compete but Benetez never organised them correctly. The FA cup will be ours also. Honest!!

Posted 21:23 20th July 2010

Richard Green (Manchester City fan) says...

you all thought benitez was the right man, you all thought houillier was the right man, now hodgsons the right man, why don't you liverpool fans actually look and realise roy is not the right man, no money and no talent, mid table obscurity for you.

Posted 20:46 20th July 2010

Pete H (Liverpool fan) says...

I think Roy is a great appointment......He will steady the ship and get the best out of all the players. To secure the likes of Joe Cole shows he can attract top players. I think Joe Cole is just the sort of creative player we have been missing and will prove to be a great signing

Posted 16:18 20th July 2010

Dan Morehead (Manchester City fan) says...

Good eye for a signing? Hodgson has bought some complete dross throughout his managerial career. Hangelaand is often cited as his ability to pick gems from Scandanavia, but Hodgson coached him at Viking. Kevin Davies for £7.5 mil, (£17 mil in today's money). Christian Dailey - £5.35m (£13m) Nathan Blake - £4.25m (£10.4m) Callum Davidson - £1.75m (£6m) from his time at Blackburn More recently Andy Johnson - £10.5m Andreason - £2m Stoor - £2m Nevland - £2m He's made a few good signings for Fulham, don't get me wrong, but he's not this European wheeling dealing genius which has been painted in certain areas of the press.

Posted 02:21 20th July 2010

Pete Naulls (Liverpool fan) says...

I think Roy is good for the team and I'm glad we have signed Joe Cole, I'm buzzing about it, I think its just what the team need. If things go wrong don't jump on the band wagon. We could do with a new striker aswell. I have been a fan for 20 years and its a nice birthday present for me. Roll on new season.

Posted 15:32 19th July 2010

Add Comment*

Send us your views

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Graeme Souness

Im-pressed by Bayern

Graeme Souness explains why Bayern's pressing game will yield many more positives than negatives....

Guillem Balague

Choose Van Gaal

Louis van Gaal is ideal to replace David Moyes at Manchester United, says Guillem Balague....

Latest News RSS feeds

Liverpool set to strengthen

Ian Ayre is confident Liverpool will be able to attract their top targets in what promises to be a busy summer.

Moyes 'lost players' support'

Sky sources understand that David Moyes lost the support of his senior players before his sacking on Tuesday.

Januzaj to represent Belgium

Manchester United youngster Adnan Januzaj has chosen to represent Belgium at international level.

Chelsea trio charged by FA

Chelsea trio Jose Mourinho, Rui Faria and Ramires have all been charged with misconduct by the Football Association.

LMA critical of Moyes exit

The LMA has issued a statement describing the manner of David Moyes' departure from Man Utd as 'unprofessional'.

Features

Andy Walker: Rangers fans deserve more than just promotion

Andy Walker: Rangers fans deserve more than just promotion

Sky's live showing of Saturday's home game with Stranraer should be a carnival atmosphere for every Rangers supporter as they celebrate seeing Ally McCoist and his players raise the SPFL League 1 trophy.

Sky Sports Scout, in association with Wyscout, reports on Italian keeper Simone Scuffet

Sky Sports Scout, in association with Wyscout, reports on Italian keeper Simone Scuffet

Sky Sports Scout is our exciting feature where we scour the globe, in partnership with Wyscout, looking out for the best talent and bring you a report on what we find.

El Nino's return

El Nino's return

Some see Fernando Torres as a figure of fun but he saved face in front of his own, writes Adam Bate.