Blogs & Opinion

Bob Willis:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

The timeless texts

'KP's refusal to clarify position on texts sent out wrong message'

Bob Willis Posted 13th August 2012 view comments

As a batsman Kevin Pietersen is a rare breed.

There are plenty of match-winning bowlers in world cricket, but very few players who can grab a Test by the scruff of its neck and impose their will with the bat.

As a consequence he will be dreadfully missed when England play South Africa in the final Test of the series at Lord's later this week. It's all very sad.

Caught out: Pietersen is available for all international formats but has been axed for Lord's

Caught out: Pietersen is available for all international formats but has been axed for Lord's

However, Pietersen's thoughts and actions in recent months - in particular the strange press conference he gave after the Headingley Test - have been bizarre to say the least. He's thrown a real spanner into the smooth running of this England cricket team.

While I didn't expect the selectors to drop him from the squad, now they have it is doubtful whether Pietersen will play again for England in any form of the game.

England have played better at Lord's in recent years but they are up against a world-class South African side and the Pietersen distraction has worked in the tourists' favour.

Bob Willis
Quotes of the week

England v South Africa

Third Test, day one
10.30am, Thu, Sky Sports 1 HD
Watch on the move with Sky Go

Pietersen's refusal to deny allegations that he sent text messages to South African players during the Headingley Test appears to be the straw that broke the ECB's back.

They've simply lost patience with him and until he changes his tune - or perhaps his advisors - the road back to redemption seems at best long. We've reached an impasse.

The England management seem unwilling to take Pietersen's insistence (in his unauthorised video on YouTube) that there is no problem between him and his team-mates at face value.

That level of distrust suggests it will be no easy task to patch things up with his team-mates - if at all. A large slice of humble pie wouldn't go amiss to start with. Pietersen has got to regain the respect of the management and the players in the dressing room.

Andy Flower and Andrew Strauss have done such a fine job for England since Strauss took over as captain from Pietersen, whose nose still seems out of joint from losing the captaincy following his rift with former coach Peter Moores.

The selectors will sit down after this Test match and decide whether to include Pietersen in the World Twenty20 squad.

But at the back of their collective minds will be this nagging doubt: what happens if they pick Pietersen for that tournament only to see him retire again and go off to play in the IPL after the series against India and New Zealand?

They'll need some assurances that is not going to happen.


Pietersen's banishment presents Jonny Bairstow with another opportunity - but is he up to the job?

After watching him struggle to play the short delivery against the West Indies, I'm not full of confidence about his ability to fend of Dale Steyn, Morne Morkel, Jacques Kallis and Vernon Philander.

England's selectors have refused to budge from their policy of playing four bowlers and I think they will probably stick to that formula at Lord's, so I expect Bairstow to play.

If that's the case, then it's likely that Steven Finn would have to make room for Graeme Swann - but I don't know if they fancy Graham Onions over Tim Bresnan. Personally, I would think seriously about playing the Durham seamer ahead of Bresnan.

In the absence of a genuine all-rounder who can bat and bowl (rather than one who bats and keeps wicket) there is a strong argument to play the extra seamer and, on balance, it is probably worth taking the risk.

I can't see the groundsman, Mick Hunt, making the Lord's pitch too sporty; it is likely to be a pretty flat deck and by the time fourth and fifth days come around it will be getting flatter and flatter.

England have played better at Lord's in recent years but they are up against a world-class South African side and the Pietersen distraction has worked in the tourists' favour.

I'd be very, very pleasantly surprised if South Africa tripped up and lost at Lord's.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Mukundan Srinivasan says...

Personally feel, England would do well without Peterson and what the board has done is the right decision. No player is bigger than the team and a country can't be hostage to one Individuals whims and fancies. Having said this, it's also disheartening to see the bull headed decisions of the board. They don't seem to know how to handle special talents. You can't treat them the same way, you treat regular members as their ego is larger. Truly a sad day for cricket as a whole. I also feel that if England has to sustain their No.1 ranking, the best way for them is to blood youngsters from within England and not depend on borrowed resources.

Posted 06:05 14th August 2012

David Mckeown says...

Im a huge Onions fan , he's the nearest thing to McGrath we've had . He's close in ( not to close Finny ! ) and nags away on a line n length. And he's capable of bowling jaffas. I'm sorry but despite his stats I don't get Bresnan as a test bowler at the top level. To often he looks straight up and down and unthreatening.And I cringe when I hear bowlers are being selected because they can get 20 or 30 with the bat. Pick your best bowlers. There's no way they'll only play 5 batsmen with young Taylor being one of them , so no doubt it'll be four bowlers again . Swann definitely , Onions for me , and both Anderson and Broad , who have done pretty well without always getting the rewards they deserve. Unlucky on Finn whos an exceptional talent , but that four was a bit samey whereas Onions gives different skills.Come on guys !

Posted 21:48 13th August 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

Latest News RSS feeds

Raina shines as India win

A century from Suresh Raina and four wickets for Ravindra Jadeja helped India thrash England by 133 runs in Cardiff.

South Africa duo stun Aussies

Centuries from Faf du Plessis and AB de Villiers helped South Africa chase down Australia’s 327-7 with ease in Harare.

Dhoni delighted with ODI win

Mahendra Singh Dhoni felt a change of format helped India find some form - and heaped praise on centurion Suresh Raina.

Morgan: Recipe for success

Eoin Morgan believes England's busy one-day schedule provides the perfect platform for World Cup success.

England to tour New Zealand

England's women will tour New Zealand in February to play five One-Day Internationals and three Twenty20 Internationals


Cricket Podcast

Cricket Podcast

Nasser Hussain discusses the One Day Series between England and India and the World Cup.

Sir Ian Botham: England to win ODI series against India with Hales and Moeen to shine

Sir Ian Botham: England to win ODI series against India with Hales and Moeen to shine

Sir Ian Botham is backing Alex Hales to make a huge impact in England's five-match ODI series with India, starting at Bristol on Monday.

Sky Tickets: Royal London Cup offer!

Sky Tickets: Royal London Cup offer!

Sky tickets have a fantastic offer ahead of this summer’s Royal London One Day Cup Final.