Blogs & Opinion

David Lloyd:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

Dots not so hot

Fewer dot balls and more boundaries are needed, says Bumble

David Lloyd - David Lloyd Posted 18th October 2011 view comments

I said the score in this series would be 5-0.

Sadly it looks like I picked the wrong team... I wonder if my bookmaker will still pay out on the correct score?

Maybe the best thing that could have happened to Duncan Fletcher was that some of India's iconic players pulled out through injury. He's ended up with a team of willing lads, who want to give as much as they can.

Trott: England's batsmen have struggled so far...

Trott: England's batsmen have struggled so far...

There's a very visible difference between India over here and what they were like in England a few weeks ago. Back then they were all falling over injured, apart from Rahul Dravid and MS Dhoni, but now they have a youthfulness about them.

You can see the difference in Dhoni six weeks on and he seems to be enjoying looking after these lads. There's no dead wood, no ulterior motives and it's just a bunch of youngsters who want to play - and play well.

They've looked angry with each other and they've fielded very poorly. People have been talking about Nasser Hussain's donkeys, but it looks like we've got two or three camels.

Quotes of the week

India v England

Third one-day international
9.30am, Thu, Sky Sports HD1

The selectors have decided to stick with the same squad for the rest of the series, which is significant, and if they keep winning they will keep some of the big shots out.

I assume Sachin Tendulkar and Virender Sehwag would open if they were fit - but the pair of them will need to pull their socks up in the field if they want to keep out Parthiv Patel and Ajinkya Rahane.

The players in the team now have a terrific opportunity in the rest of this series. I like the fact that when Ravi Shastri asked MS Dhoni if he was looking for 5-0, he dropped it like a stone.

He says all they're looking for is to continue to play well and improve. That's a good attitude.

What do England change?

England have had a poor time of things so far. They've looked angry with each other and they've fielded very poorly. People have been talking about Nasser Hussain's donkeys, but it looks like we've got two or three camels.

People are talking about making changes, but where can you improve the team? I'd suggest that while Steven Finn is an impressive bowler, the quicker you bowl it over here the further it will go. Perhaps that opens the door for Chris Woakes, who is a similar bowler to the Kumars and can bat and field as well.

The other issue is whether you can get Ian Bell into the team. It seems when the team is getting beaten then those who aren't in it become better players. He'll know as much as anybody that the reason he was left out in the first place was because his scores have not been there.

This isn't my opinion, but I've heard people saying that 12 months down the line Bell will be opening the batting with Ravi Bopara. That would obviously mean there's no room for Alastair Cook and that's an interesting view.

When a team is losing you get a knee-jerk reaction from people saying things need to change, but I don't think you can change the side too much. It's as good as we've got.

Instead, I'd pay attention to the way we play. For example, we have far too many dot balls. We should look at Gautam Gambhir, a player I really admire, who manoeuvres the ball and keeps things ticking over. We're unable to do that.

We're also far too reluctant to whack it. If you look at the statistics for ODI's in 2011 you'll see India have hit 528 fours to England's 496 - but significantly they have 92 sixes compared to England's 60. That's a massive difference.

I'm sure if you asked Samit Patel and Graeme Swann if they'd rather bowl at Kevin Pietersen and Jonathan Trott or Virat Kohli and MS Dhoni - who are going to come at you - then I know what they'd say.

From my point of view, England don't get enough boundaries and there are too many dot balls. But supporters mustn't lose track of the fact we had a fabulous time at home.

England's big challenge is to win in India, just as they wanted to win in England. But both teams have found that task hellishly difficult.

Down the line

Speaking of challenges, I went back to my old radio days last Friday as I delivered the first few overs of the first ODI down a phone line for Sky Sports.

We are reliant on the host broadcaster, Nimbus, and we have been caught up in their dispute involving the BCCI and the Indian government. As a result, we didn't have pictures for the first three overs and we didn't get a broadcasting licence in time, so were unable to bring you commentary for the rest of the game. I can tell you that our letters have now been stamped up to and including the third game.

I have been tweeting regularly throughout the series, but there has been some unbelievable filth posted on my page. It seems some people took exception to my predictions on this blog last week.

I have retweeted some of the bile to expose these people before blocking them. They're the dregs of society and I know the vast majority of India's supporters are embarrassed by it.

I suppose that among 1.2billion people there's always going to be one or two nutters....

Music and mountains

We've just arrived at the Mount View Hotel in Chandigarh which, as you might expect, has a view of a mountain.

The teams and officials are in a much posher place, but I like this one. It's a nice homely hotel and I like the area (Sanjay Manjrekar tells me it's the first laid-out city) and the ground is grand as well.

They have a surprising taste in music around these parts too. I was sitting in the lobby and you'd never guess what was being piped through as I was writing some emails: "Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree" by Dawn featuring Tony Orlando. I haven't heard that for a while and I definitely wasn't expecting to hear it over here!

Anyway, I'm off to the gym with my Real Mass weight gain. Speak to you next week.

Comments (11)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Benny Bowden says...

After realising we don't have an Adam Gilchrist, despite years of experiments by England's selectors, why not try the old-fashioned approach of picking one of our brilliant top keepers (Read or Foster), who won't open the innings but would get us more wickets, which I personally think would be quite useful. I'd never pick Prior but I'd give his publicity agent a job.

Posted 02:21 21st October 2011

Shrik Kk says...

I think the england squad is pretty good. just that conditions in subcontinent does not suit them. they need to concentrate on 2015 world cup and build towards it. i think they have good 15-17 players for that cup on aus/nz conditions. i think all the players in the world cup 15 should have played 50-100 games minimum. england needs to persist with kieswetter and dernbach and try some other new players. Some how i feel England does not have the same hunger in odi's as they have in test cricket. may be Andy is working on it.

Posted 19:23 20th October 2011

Tim Amor says...

Kieswetter lost us that game on his own, even though Dernbach and Cook did their best to help him do it. Tell Bumble that statistics on dot balls are nonesense - it's WHEN you fail to score, not how many times. Trott should be dropped for his plodding rate.

Posted 18:32 20th October 2011

Steven Downes says...

Paul Allott must be forgetting his own career. He had 15wkts at 36.80 in odi s and 26wkts at 41.69 in tests. That does not seem so great to me!! Maybe in his own mind he was better.

Posted 15:45 20th October 2011

Mike Shaw says...

Agree about Matt Prior - can't understand why he isn't in the team. Kieswetter has failed on many occasions, as a batsman; Prior is a better batter and also a good-enough keeper. So why do England persist with Kieswetter?

Posted 00:59 20th October 2011

Matt H says...

@Samuel - England have tried Prior several times, most recently earlier this year in Australia and the World Cup. It back-fired. He may be the best batsman-WK in Test cricket, but it hasn't clicked for him at ODI level. Whilst Kieswetter still has a long way to go, he's done much better than Prior.

Posted 21:36 19th October 2011

Steve Patel says...

wish u all the best england not!

Posted 18:28 19th October 2011

Simon Cooke says...

Don't let the "dregs" get to you... keep Tweeting; your incisive and entertaining opinions are head and shoulders above the rest.

Posted 17:32 19th October 2011

Lak Mak says...

I always enjoy your comments. But, I guess you were too harsh for our seniors. Sachin, Sehwag, Yuvi, Gambhir none of the them were part of ODI series. India played without 7 regulars, (world cup winning team) including seniors (we had Dravid though) at Endland in ODI series and still all games were very close. So same team is playing again, it just that they started finding their grooves and conditions are suited weel for home team.

Posted 15:10 19th October 2011

Rishabh Jain says...

Bumble, I have always immensely enjoyed your sporting views and commentary. A bit of needle between passionate supporters only adds to the game. In that spirit, your 5-0 prediction for England was funny and completely harmless. I saw the filth on your twitter account and blogs, and it was indeed embarassing to me as an Indian fan. However, you are wise to realize that the 'dregs' of indian society are a minority - equivalent to the English football hooligans. Hope you have a great trip in India, even if England are on the receiving side this time around!

Posted 18:34 18th October 2011

Samuel Mayer says...

I can't understand why England have left Matt Prior out of the one day side, for me he is one of the best batsmen in world cricket, and they haven't picked him, which is mystifying to me. I think Woakes also deserves a chance in the team, he's an accurate bowler, and will bolster the batting line up. Another bowler who I feel has been overlooked by the selectors is Graham Onions, he bowls accurately and wicket to wicket, ideal for the one day game.

Posted 18:24 18th October 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

Women's cricket

Kate Cross blog

The England Women star reflects on the ODI series with New Zealand and some stunning panoramic views....

Latest News RSS feeds

Ireland stun Windies

Ireland secured the first shock of the World Cup with a four-wicket victory over the West Indies in Nelson.

Pietersen signs for Sunrisers

Kevin Pietersen will play alongside Eoin Morgan for Sunrisers Hyderabad in the 2015 Indian Premier League.

Porterfield targeting quarters

William Porterfield expects Ireland to qualify for the World Cup quarter-finals following their win over West Indies.

Ireland 'on track for quarters'

Ireland’s hopes of reaching the World Cup quarter-finals are firmly on track after their win against West Indies, says Kyle McCallan.

Kate Cross blog

The England Women star reflects on the ODI series with New Zealand and some stunning panoramic views.


World Cup wallchart

World Cup wallchart

It's time to plan your next seven weeks around the cricket with the Sky Sports World Cup wallchart!

Sky Cricket Podcast: Bob Willis and Eoin Morgan on England's World Cup defeat to Australia

Sky Cricket Podcast: Bob Willis and Eoin Morgan on England's World Cup defeat to Australia

The 2015 World Cup has begun with thumping wins for co-hosts Australia and New Zealand.

Cricket World Cup: How the Associate members have stunned the big boys…

Cricket World Cup: How the Associate members have stunned the big boys…

Ireland, Scotland, Afghanistan and United Arab Emirates will be the Associate members mixing it with cricket’s powerhouses at the 2015 World Cup - but can any of them pull off an upset like these from yesteryear...