Blogs & Opinion

David Lloyd:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

The white approach

England should revert to an old-fashioned 50-over approach

David Lloyd - David Lloyd Posted 14th June 2012 view comments

With a white ball at each end, I think we could see more of an old-fashioned approach from England in this one-day series.

There's been two phases in 50-over cricket. More recently we've seen a phase where you wanted pinch-hitters in the side to come belting in, but with a ball that's damned-near brand new at each end things will be slightly different.

Cook, Bell & Trott: not exactly 'bish-bosh' players

Cook, Bell & Trott: not exactly 'bish-bosh' players

I think we're going to go back to ticking over and keeping wickets intact for the last 10 overs. Of course, we've got to score and look to be aggressive, but in the past we've been guilty of not batting 50 overs - and it's an absolute given that you need to do that.

You've got to try to play to your strengths and England's strength will be to keep hold of their wickets, then kick on with everybody playing their part.

A commentator does exactly what it says on the tin - he makes comments. If Sir Viv said it's about time Ramdin got some runs then he was exactly right.

Quotes of the week

England v West Indies, First ODI

10.30am, Sat, Sky Sports 1 HD
Watch on the move with Sky Go
How to remote record

The reason I say that is because England's top three - Alastair Cook, Ian Bell and Jonathan Trott - are really good players, but they're not Jayasuriya, they're not Gilchrist and they're not Gayle.

And they're not Kevin Pietersen either. He would have been the one expected to fulfil that role but he can't do it now he's retired.

England's top three will all play in a similar way and must look to set the game up. I can promise you they won't be dawdling, but they can't play like the aforementioned either. They need to rely on their skill instead.

There are all different types of one-day players and those three must look to play like Mahela Jayawardene. Now there's somebody who looks to bat all 50 overs - and when he does he'll get loads of runs. Kumar Sangakkara is the same. It's not all bish-bash; you can go a long way by moving the ball around.

That's the way for England to progress because we don't have another type of player. People say we should have brought a young big hitter to replace Pietersen, but I'm struggling to come up with any names.

The only one that I would have seriously considered - and he's definitely not a youngster - is Michael Carberry. I think he's a terrific player, a magnificent fielder and that could have been a really good selection. I'm all for promoting young players, but in this case, he's the man I'd have gone for.

However, Bell is a terrific batsman and England have made a big investment in him. He's had lots of chances and they've given him another one. Let's see if he takes it.

For me though, one-day cricket is still England's weak suit In contrast, it's the West Indies' strong suit and in Chris Gayle, Dwayne Bravo, Lendl Simmons, Andre Russell and Kieron Pollard they've got some jolly good players.

My two bob on this series would be going on the West Indies.

Ramdin was wrong

It was an awful five days at Edgbaston, but there were some nice pockets of play.

Denesh Ramdin played exceptionally well and the partnership he had with Tino Best was absolutely sensational.

But I thought waving that piece of paper with a message for Viv Richards was really poor. I've been amazed by the number of people on Twitter who've said he deserved his right to reply, but for me, it was totally the wrong thing to do.

A commentator does exactly what it says on the tin - he makes comments. If Sir Viv said it's about time Ramdin got some runs then he was exactly right - and I'm sure he would praise a terrific effort when he got his runs.

The majority of the time you'll hear a commentator talking about great games of cricket, wonderful batting performances and terrific bowling, but every now and again he has to say that someone is a bit off the pace or hasn't played very well. That's why we're there.

We will make our opinions and we're not here to say that those opinions are always right. Whenever we say something on air, we get a shedful of emails from people disagreeing with us and that's absolutely fine.

I'm not going to name the player, but a few years ago I said something on commentary and the player in question came up to me afterwards to give it the big "I am".

I pointed out that I didn't think his performance was very good. I told him I'd be happy to buy him a drink afterwards, but I'm paid to comment on what the players do. It's not that I didn't like him, I just made a comment.

I also pointed out that he'd never come up to thank me when I'd said he was brilliant...

Who'll be top rod?

I've been everywhere this week. I went straight from the Test match to Leicester and then it's Sussex, the Rose Bowl, Taunton and over to London.

Somehow I've managed to find time for a day off on Monday and I'm going Fishing for Heroes; a fishing competition in the Meon Valley for the Help For Heroes charity.

Beefy will be there. Atherton will be there. I fancy my chances of beating the pair of them, but I'm sure they're thinking the same.

You can find out more on this website

I'm also pleased to report I'll be staying with The Brigadier when I'm down at Taunton. He lives somewhere around Exeter, so he's taking me to the Thirsty Farmer.

No doubt I'll have to have a cider or two!

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Mat Richards says...

another huge step backwards by England, until we learn to play modern attacking day ODI cricket we might as well give up and go home, but then don't worry ECB will get counties to produce green tops so that score are dragged down and England stand a chance and we will again like last summer look fakely good, then we will go abroad and get smashed up as per usual, Its about England started to produce flat wickets like the rest of the world do and learn how to score 300+, but then with Bell, Cook & Trott top 3 wasting 10 of the 15 overs of PP all 3 are cracking test players but all lack the power and attacking flair to get off to that flyer you need in the PP's how many of countries have 3 defence players If were really looking at the 2015 WC then we wouldn't be sticking with the solid players Bell & Bopara who are decent at best nothing special in the ODIs Also are bowlers will be made to look great in conditions that will suit them, just a shame 90% of ODI's are played in conditions and more importantly on pitches so much different, then we wonder why we struggle 1. Bairstow (wkt) 2. Stokes 3. Cook (cpt) 4. Bell/Trott 5. Taylor 6. Buttler 7. Patel/Bresnann 8. Bresnann/Woakes 9. Broad 10. Swann 11. Finn With the new rules meaning that 10 out of the 15 power plays overs are the first 10 overs, I have gone with Stokes & Bairstow & I would push Cook down to bat 3. Trott to bat 4 as i would like 2 explosive big hitting batsman to make use of those PP overs, plus it would let Trott & Cook do what they do best anchor the Innings I have gone with Taylor & Buttler at 5/6 simply because we know what Patel, Bopara & Kies offer us and it isn't anything great and i would like to see what these 2 can do for England The bowling unit picks it self really with the exception I would with go with Woakes or Patel pitch depending instead of Dernbach Mat Richards P.S Bumble love to know your thoughts

Posted 08:01 15th June 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

Latest News RSS feeds

England fold in final

England folded to 166 all out to lose the Carlton Mid Tri-Series final to Australia by 112 runs in Perth.

Morgan bemoans England batting

Eoin Morgan says poor batting, not Mitchell Johnson, was the reason for England's 112-run defeat to Australia at The WACA.

Warne: Australia need Clarke

Shane Warne says Australia cannot win the 2015 World Cup without Michael Clarke captaining the side.

Lloyd: England lacked power

England's inability to hit regular boundaries is a concern heading into the World Cup, says David Lloyd.

Weather hampers England Lions

England Lions were unable to seal a series win as their third one-dayer against South Africa A was abandoned due to rain.


Lloyd on World Cup

Lloyd on World Cup

In the first of our new series, two-time winning captain Clive Lloyd tells us why he loves the Cricket World Cup.

World Cup Flashback

World Cup Flashback

Andy Bichel’s 7-20 and 34no destroyed England in 2003. Has there been a better all-round display?

Big Bash Best Bits

Big Bash Best Bits

A look back at some of the best bits from this year's Big Bash - including Bumble in the commentary box!