Blogs & Opinion


David Lloyd:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

Wise to franchise?

Fans should pay to see the team, not individuals

David Lloyd - David Lloyd Posted 21st June 2012 view comments

I'll start this week's blog by saying how sad I was to hear the tragic news about Tom Maynard.

It was an enormous shock to the cricketing world and there has been tremendous sadness among everybody involved in the sport.

I cannot contemplate how the family must feel and my thoughts go out to them. It's absolutely devastating news.

Narine: struggled against England's openers

Narine: struggled against England's openers

The news obviously cast a shadow over the one-day series, which has been dominated by England. The West Indies should be a lot better than what they've shown.

The bowling seems to be letting them down. They brought in a mystery spinner - Sunil Narine - and the mystery seems to be that there is no mystery!

I've never seen him before, but he doesn't look accurate enough, there's little spin and crucially, all the England batsmen have picked him. The openers have scored hundreds in the first two matches and I don't think they've really been stretched.

You go to see the team, not one individual player. Are people really turning up in their droves just to watch Tim Bresnan?

Bumble
Quotes of the week

LIVE ON SKY SPORTS
England v West Indies
Third ODI

10.30am, Fri, Sky Sports 1 HD
Watch on the move with Sky Go
How to remote record

England have played very well, but it's what I'd call organised cricket against a disappointing West Indies outfit. At least they've had a good run-out ahead of the visit of Australia.

They're resting three players - Stuart Broad, Tim Bresnan and Graeme Swann - for the final ODI and I think that's very sensible. The job's done, they're 2-0 up and if I was the boss I'd want to see what Stuart Meaker and Chris Woakes can do.

I don't understand it when people complain about "the person who's bought a ticket". If you go and watch a football match you watch whoever the manager has picked and it should be the same for cricket.

You go to see the team, not one individual player. Are people really turning up in their droves just to watch Tim Bresnan?

You can't win sometimes. If they didn't try out some youngsters then you'd have a lobby of people wanting to know why. These guys are very good up-and-coming young cricketers, in particular Meaker who can bowl 90mph.

Andy Flower wants a squad of players and this approach ensures that the ones in possession have to perform at their best - and by resting them he's making sure they're ready for Australia and South Africa.

Time for a franchise

Away from international cricket I have covered a few t20 matches this week and I've found them to be a bit low key.

Compared to the atmosphere and the quality of the IPL and the Big Bash, the English competition is definitely second fiddle.

We've talked about a franchise system in England for a long time and we need to find a window for a new competition and a way to attract the best players in the world including, of course, the England players.

I would like to see "Lancashire United" and "Leeds Rhinos", but I'm not talking about joining counties together. I know a lot of people are opposed to that.

I would want to create a blocked-off period when franchises would play t20 cricket. The counties would still be there and they would get some of the new money that would be brought in.

The franchises would be totally different from the counties and they would bid for players. The caveat would be, as in the IPL, that they'd have to have a certain number of English players - which would benefit the future of the sport in the country.

It would definitely bring in a lot of fresh money to the game, the counties would be on a better financial standing and the spectators would see the best players in the world.

I see it as a win-win. If only people were open to the idea.

Something fishy

It's been a demanding week for me with just under 1,000 miles clocked up on the speedometer.

I stayed with the Brigadier while I was working at Taunton and I went to visit Whimple Cricket Club. They've got an enormous ground these days and if they didn't put a boundary line in then you'd be able to run a seven!

I was hoping to try some Scrumpy while I was down there, but I didn't see any, so I was on the Otter ale instead. Very nice it was too.

I also attended the Fishing for Heroes event in the Meon Valley. The first part of the day was clay pigeon shooting and to be honest I couldn't see the point of that. I had a go and then very politely gave the gun back. It's not my bag at all.

Thankfully we went fishing in the afternoon and even though the fish were very wary by then, I caught one nice big one on the last cast.

Beefy and Athers were there as well, but I don't know how they got on. I also met Adam from Countryfile, who was a lovely fellow and was the business when it came to clay pigeon shooting!

He had all the gear too. I turned up in a t-shirt and a pair of jeans, but most of them had Hunter Wellingtons, tweeds, plus-fours, deerstalkers and all the rest of it - and I include Botham in that.

It was a damn good day though and we raised lots of money for Help for Heroes.

Comments (4)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Nic Fisher says...

The potential problem I see with the franchise idea is that it could potentially cut out members and supporters of the smaller counties. With these new franchises being independent of the counties, surely they have no obligation to play at all the grounds? Their motivations would be largely financial, and surely it makes the most financial sense to play at the grounds with the largest capacities - the test match grounds. Meaning fans of smaller counties not actually being able to see all these great players. I for example, as a somerset member, would probably have to travel to Cardiff, or even London. Surely this takes some of the soul out of what is so important about English domestic cricket?

Posted 08:01 25th June 2012

Bandon Decker says...

I would not watch a fanchise T20 tournament. I quite like the current model; unlike the IPL I don't think it is too over the top. Most of all though, I watch the FPT20 because Lancashire play and Lancashire are my team. 'Lancashire United' would not be and I would not watch.

Posted 19:15 22nd June 2012

Steve St.kennett says...

On 'resting' players couldn't agree less. The difference is that international football friendlies are advertised as such and you know what you are getting. I got my ODI tickets months ago,at £50 a throw no less and now they decide its to be a bit of a run out for fringe players. It would be fair do's IF we got a £20 note to spend at the bar but £50 for what is a trial match is not on. Now,on T20. It does need a make over. First up get it off Sky and on terrestrial tv. We are raising a group of nippers who know more about Indian club cricket than our own. Form a six club league with six 15 man squads and release the England lads to play in it across 10 games and a finals day. The clubs to be based at Leeds,Manchester,Nottingham,Birmingham,Cardiff and The Oval. Finals at Lords. Play it over 21 days in August with the finals on the bank holiday Sunday. You can still run the current competition for the counties with players attempting to impress and get a franchise contract.

Posted 07:25 22nd June 2012

Tejinder Jutley says...

Franchise can only be viable if ECB embraces the concept, otherwise they will stuck to their traditional English Cricket. May be a change in management will probably be better who have vision of the future of T20 in this country.

Posted 21:01 21st June 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

David Lloyd

Bumble's blog

Bumble's calendar is stacked, with ODI commitments, a potential trip to India and a spicy Boxing Day....

Latest News RSS feeds

Middlesex reward Malan

Middlesex batsman Dawid Malan has been rewarded for his good form with a new three-year contract.

Cairns bailed on perjury charge

Former New Zealand captain Chris Cairns has been bailed after appearing in court in London to face a charge of perjury.

Yorkshire dominate PCA awards

Yorkshire dominated the PCA Awards with openers Adam Lyth and Alex Lees scooping two of the top honours.

Players behind captain Cook

Jimmy Anderson says England's players never had any doubt Alastair Cook would remain captain for the 2015 World Cup.

New Zealand recall Bracewell

Doug Bracewell has been recalled to the New Zealand Test squad for next month’s three-match series against Pakistan.

Features

Division One review

Division One review

The summer sun slowly begins to make way for frost and fog as another domestic season is ticked off with mixed results for the 18 first-class counties.

Division Two review

Division Two review

Hampshire and Worcestershire clinched promotion but things are going from bad to worse at Leicestershire. We review the Division Two season club-by-club...

ICC Cricket World Cup 2015: our pundits pick their England starting XIs

ICC Cricket World Cup 2015: our pundits pick their England starting XIs

England’s World Cup campaign begins in a little over five months’ time when they take on co-hosts Australia at the MCG.