Blogs & Opinion


England batters in 'monumental block' in New Zealand, blogs Bumble

David Lloyd - David Lloyd Posted 26th March 2013 view comments

So England survived and held on to draw the series in New Zealand, but survival was not what they really came here to do.

They wanted to win this series and win it handsomely. That's not happened and listening to Alastair Cook afterwards, there was a sense of relief that they didn't lose but he will now look at what went wrong.

Root: England batsmen lacked aggression on tour, says Bumble

Root: England batsmen lacked aggression on tour, says Bumble

My concern is they've been pretty ineffectual in their batting efforts throughout this series. I want to see them batting with a lot more purpose and a lot more energy.

The pitches have been placid, but we just haven't scored enough runs. I would have expected our players to have scored as New Zealand have (although from what I saw, the home team were far better than their eighth-place ranking).

I'd like to see more strut, more swagger and more arrogance from our players. It seems to be in the mind; we seem to have got into a monumental block situation and they've found it difficult to get out of that.

Bumble
Quotes of the week

I might sound like a long-playing record, but here's a "for instance" for you. Monty Panesar has taken 164 Test match wickets and was hit for 12 sixes here whereas Bruce Martin has taken nine Test match wickets and we hit him for just one. Monty has done absolutely nothing wrong either, he's bowled absolutely fine.

What that shows is that England haven't had a batting head on and they've lacked any sort of aggression or energy. They've been out-thought and out-manoeuvred by New Zealand for long spells.

I'd like to see more strut, more swagger and more arrogance from our players. It seems to be in the mind; we seem to have got into a monumental block situation and they've found it difficult to get out of that.

I don't have any concerns ahead of the Ashes though (I'm not revising my prediction of 10-0...) and I would expect them to put it right very quickly.

They played terrific cricket in India, but were simply unable to bring that forward to New Zealand on docile pitches that were crying out for a batter to stay in for a long period and get 200 or more.

Lacking pace

The other thing that will concern the England management is that this pace attack that we glory in has not been as quick as New Zealand's.

Steven Finn was rocking up at 132kph (which is about 82mph); that's not what he's there for. This lad is a 90-92mph bowler, so where is he?

The home team have definitely looked stronger, in terms of fitness, than we did. They've come away with a draw and now our lads can head home for a rest before having a go at New Zealand again in English conditions with a different ball.

From an English viewpoint it will be a real frustration that they were unable to stamp any sort of authority on this series, but New Zealand have got some very good players. Kane Williamson and Hamish Rutherford are two excellent players in their early 20's and Dean Brownlie has performed well all series.

They've got quality players in Ross Taylor and Brendon McCullum and there is a good blend in the side, plus when Doug Bracewell comes back into the team they'll have an even better attack.

But from England's point of view, it's worth thinking about the absent players at this point. We have seen how they missed the influential Kevin Pietersen and Graeme Swann - and to a lesser extent Tim Bresnan. They've missed all three of those out here.

If I was England, I'd be treating it as a five-match series with three in New Zealand and two at home and then see where we are. We were resilient in Dunedin, frustrated by the weather in Wellington and outplayed in Auckland.

It's level after three games and now there's two more to assert our position.

Heading home

The final day produced epic Test match cricket, full of ebb and flow and drama and it's a shame that there were not many people in to watch it.

But overall, New Zealand has been a wonderful place to tour and this is the place to be. The stadiums have been stunning (although Auckland is clearly a rugby ground rather than a cricket ground) and the scenery has been great.

Off the field it's clean, tidy and orderly and full of fabulous people. That said, I'm looking forward to heading home for Easter.

The clocks go forward at the weekend to herald the arrival of spring... albeit under six feet of snow.

See you later.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Phil Rice says...

I think they should give Eoin Morgan an extended run. He is more aggressive and will provide a greater threat. England have been too quick to dispense with players when they have 2 consecutive average matches. They need to build a trust within the team which comes from continuity. Morgan is a rare talent and is not just a limited overs player.

Posted 14:04 26th March 2013

Niall Odonnell says...

Bumble -good to see name check for Bressie -think he adds a bit to the side that we have missed -steady and collected with hint of aggression and a cricket brain

Posted 11:19 26th March 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Add Comment*

Send us your views

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private

back to top

Other Cricket Experts:

Latest Posts in Cricket:

Bob Willis

Away for a while

Bob Willis thinks Jonathan Trott will be absent from England duty for some time following his latest setback....

Latest News RSS feeds

Cook: No Flower influence

England captain Alastair Cook insists Andy Flower will have no influence in the rebuilding of the national team.

'Moores to be judged on Ashes'

Surrey coach Alec Stewart says Peter Moores will ultimately be judged on whether or not he wins back the Ashes.

Morgan sympathy for KP

Eoin Morgan admits he has sympathy with those who believe Kevin Pietersen should still be playing for England.

Warner backs struggling Trott

Australia's David Warner has pledged his support for struggling England batsman Jonathan Trott.

Indian Premier League live!

Text commentary and scorecard from Rajasthan Royals v Kings XI Punjab.

Features

A look at the highs and lows of new England supremo Peter Moores' coaching career

A look at the highs and lows of new England supremo Peter Moores' coaching career

Following confirmation on Saturday that Peter Moores had been appointed as England head coach for a second time, we take a look back at the highs and lows of his coaching career.

Indian Premier League: Watch the best bits of this year's tournament on Sky Sports

Indian Premier League: Watch the best bits of this year's tournament on Sky Sports

Watch Kevin Pietersen's return to action - and the best of the rest of the Indian Premier League - right here on skysports.com.

Next England cricket coach: We look at the five contenders to replace Andy Flower

Next England cricket coach: We look at the five contenders to replace Andy Flower

With interviews already under way for the vacant England coaching position, we look at the five men in the frame to replace Andy Flower on a full-time basis.