Blogs & Opinion


Football fantasy

NFL in the Olympics is a crazy idea, says Simon

View from America Posted 6th August 2012 view comments

OK, now we know he's away with the fairies. NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell has a lot of fine points - steering the league through last year's minefield of the player lockout being a prime example - but suggesting, as he did last week, that American football should be in the Olympics is tantamount to calling for the men in the white coats.

At a time when the NFL is pretty much being assaulted on all sides by all manner of off-field issues - let's just START with the thousands of former players currently suing over the concussion problem, then add in the farce over bringing in replacement refs for the pre-season and top it off with the legal mess over the Bounty-gate suspensions at New Orleans - you'd think they might want to keep a low profile, especially in the file marked 'Fruit Loopy.'

Absurd: NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell's NFL Olympic hope is simply a dream, says Verness

Absurd: NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell's NFL Olympic hope is simply a dream, says Verness

And yet there it was, large as life on radio's Dan Patrick Show last week, insisting football "should absolutely" be an Olympic sport.

"Huhh?" And "Whhaaaaa???" To paraphrase a certain JP McEnroe - you cannot be at all non-jokingly somber-minded.

Now, you won't find many bigger fans and supporters of the gridiron game than me. I was a reporter when the World League kicked off in 1991; I've covered football for all of the intervening 21 years, including 14 Super Bowls. I've been there, done that and bought copious amounts of NFL-logo'd T-shirts.

If you thought The Longest Yard was brutal, it would be nothing compared to Olympic football, with players from, say, Lithuania going up against the likes of Mario Williams and Terrell Suggs.

Simon Verness
Quotes of the week

I've argued for years that football needs more coverage in the UK as it has a small army of devoted fans here, it draws rabid support right across the country and it could sell out the annual London game several times over.

And even I think the idea of "football" anywhere other than the United States is certifiably insane.

In case The Commish hasn't been paying attention, the NBA - sorry, the USA Olympic basketball team - just destroyed Nigeria by around 500 points (OK, it was "only" 156-73, but it was a record by some distance) and no-one else is likely to get close to Kobe Bryant, LeBron James and Co at this Olympiad.

What does he want? The USA football team to score MORE than 156?

Because that's what you'd get if anyone actually bought into this sporting fantasy, this contest of insane ideas.

It would be the biggest flight of fancy since Icarus waxed feathers to his arms and said "Hey boys, how about a little jaunt across the Mediterranean?"

Delusion

Here's what Goodell actually said during his radio delusion: "We're already taking steps to gain IOC recognition. We have, I think, 64 countries that are playing American football now, and that's one of the requirements. That's been growing dramatically. I think it was 40 just five years ago."

No, Roger, that is 64 countries that have HEARD of American football. If you're lucky. You couldn't put together a football team to play the USA from the rest of the WORLD.

He went on: "Our point is just to keep growing the game. We're having a tremendous reaction in London and the UK for the game of football, our regular season game over there is sold out again this year, we are seriously contemplating, as early as 2013, playing two NFL games there next season, and I think we'll do that."

Well, that's OK then. We can have the Wembley crowd take on the USA at the next Olympics. As long as we can play all 80,000 of them at the same time, we MIGHT just hold the American team under three figures.

But Roger had more: "It's a response to the tremendous fan reaction and the growth of the game. If we can continue to grow the game there and have the fan reaction that we have, there very well may be a franchise in London."

Yes, and it will still be 100% American, give or take the odd Brit that might get into the team as a kicker or receiver. Oh, wait. Germany has a player in the NFL. Perhaps they can build a team around New England's Sebastian Vollmer, as long as he can play on offence and defence, and probably special teams as well.

And then there's American Samoa. They have several dozen players in the league, and Troy Polamalu would make a great captain (provided he can shake off that concussion thing). There are all of five American Samoans at the current Olympics, but surely they could scrape up another 45 to field a football team?

Absurd

But then there's that whole 50-man team snag. With the Olympics already bulging at the seams with more than 14,000 athletes, the idea of adding, say, another 12 teams and 600 extra competitors is borderline absurd.

Anyone unlucky enough to be in the USA's group (and there would have to be qualifying games, of course, unless the IOC just had a competition to decide who plays America for the gold medal, which wouldn't sit well with the whole Olympic ideal) might also need to bring a couple of hundred replacements for the unfortunate souls who would get the 'privilege' of going up against the NFL's finest - along with a one-way ticket to the nearest intensive care unit.

If you thought The Longest Yard was brutal, it would be nothing compared to Olympic football, with players from, say, Lithuania and Nigeria (two of the current London basketball crop) going up against the likes of Mario Williams and Terrell Suggs.

And, unless you expected the teams to be able to turn around and play something like eight games in 14 days like the basketball and soccer schedules, an American football tournament could easily need six to seven weeks to complete, which would be patently absurd.

Nonsense

The ultimate nonsense, of course, is the real giveaway right in Goodell's own quotes, where he makes the 24-carat mistake of calling it "American" football.

It is an American sport, played professionally exclusively in North America (i.e. the USA and Canada), along with significant armchair followings in Britain and Germany and a handful of other European countries, plus, to a lesser extent, Mexico and Japan.

Yes, that's right, of the 205 countries represented in the current Olympics, only TWO could actually field a team for "American football," and that's hoping Canada could re-train its players for the smaller field and other rules that would presumably need to be implemented for the "American" game.

And, as good as the London Blitz (the reigning three-time Brit Bowl champs and arguably the best team outside North America) might be, it would be generations before they could even hope to be competitive against any unit drawn from the NFL, although team GB against any of the Netherlands, Serbia, Finland, Denmark or Germany might be a decent contest.

Perhaps that's the answer. We CAN have American football in the Olympics. As long as America doesn't play.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Trevor Gordon says...

having american football in the olympics would be absurd.its not an international sport.they only have 2 professional leagues.one in canada and the u.s.first of all,no one understands the game outside the u.s. it takes 4 hours to play.they tried this with baseball.a boring game.its more exiting watching paint dry.thank god they threw it out of the olympics.basketball is the most global of american sports.its a lot simpler to play and watch.outside of the u.s who's heard of the green bay packers or the miami dolphins?go to any country in africa or europe,no one knows what the superbowl is and don't care.leave the olympics the way it is.

Posted 22:40 9th August 2012

Brian Johnson says...

1. There are indeed 64 countries that have american football federations that qualified for the IFAF. That does not include some countries that I know of, China for example, that do play football, but do not have a federation for it that has qualified for the IFAF. So, yes, there are 64+ countries that play american football, not 64 countries that "have HEARD of" it. 2. The world has fielded an U-19 team that has beaten a team of US U-19, so the world can... and has fielded a team that can beat the US. 3. When basketball became an Olympic sport in 1936, do you think NBA players got to participate? That would have resulted in the routs that you expect to happen if american football becomes a Olympic sport. NFL players would play whenever the international crowd was prepared for it, and not a day sooner, remember, it took basketball almost 60 years to do so. 4. There was even an example to use here--the IFAF World Cup. They do not allow NFL players, and the games can be quite competitive. In the first year that the USA participated in the IFAF World Cup, they won against Japan for gold after enduring 2OTs. 5. Calling the sport "american football" isn't a goof--it's 100% correct, that is the name of the sport internationally. It's in the name IFAF--International Federation of American Football. 6. Using the length of the soccer tournament at this year's games, about 2 and a half weeks, an IFAF schedule should be easy to complete within the allotted time. 7. Looking several years down the road (which is when it would be an Olympic sport anyway, if it ever did) I see, outside of Canada and the US, Japan, Germany, Austria, France, Mexico, and even more countries being more and more competitive. Plus, becoming an Olympic sport would just cause the expansion of american football to explode.

Posted 12:03 6th August 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other American Football Blogs:

Latest Posts in American Football:

View from America

Draft developments

Simon Veness reviews the aftermath and fallout from an exhausting, rollercoaster 2014 NFL draft....

comments