Blogs & Opinion

Ed Chamberlin looks forward to the Manchester derby and Arsenal v Stoke

Ed Chamberlin - Ed Chamberlin Posted 19th September 2013 view comments

It's so early in the season yet the big games keep on coming. The Manchester derby takes centre stage on Super Sunday this weekend, a fixture with all the ingredients for a brilliant spectacle.

It's guaranteed to be better than the offering at St Mary's last Sunday. The stalemate between Southampton and West Ham was a major anti-climax. Saints seem to have made a problem for themselves with the signing of Dani Osvaldo.

Manuel Pellegrini and David Moyes: facing each other for the first time

Manuel Pellegrini and David Moyes: facing each other for the first time

Mauricio Pochettino seems intent on playing both Osvaldo and Rickie Lambert in the starting XI, which has upset the 4-3-3 system that was working so well. However, it's early days and I'm sure a solution will be found.

Monday's show was quite a contrast as we got an excellent game at Swansea, largely thanks to Jonjo Shelvey, and had a couple of interesting debates in the studio. Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher discussing the cultural differences when it comes to defending was absolutely fascinating.

Kompany's such an important figure at the club and City have been a noticeably better side with him in it, winning 58% of those Premier League games compared to 47% without him.

Ed Chamberlain
Quotes of the week

They explained how in this country central defenders adopt a safety first policy to keep things tight at the back, while in Europe and South America centre backs are eager to step out, be more aggressive and take more risks.

Gary explained how Cristiano Ronaldo told him that when Gerard Piqué first arrived at Manchester United he was going to be one of the best defenders in the world. G Nev told Ronaldo he was mad. From a tough start in Manchester, Piqué has done pretty well!

This came to a head because of a couple of errors David Luiz made in Chelsea's defeat at Everton. Yet this is a player who captains Brazil, is prepared to take risks and can have a major influence on a game. Is that approach the right way or the old school English method of safety first? The debate will continue.

The other lively discussion was over who was the better midfielder: Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard or Frank Lampard. We needed to extend the show for another hour for that one.

Giroud health

On the pitch this weekend our first game is Arsenal against Stoke. Mark Hughes has got his team playing well but they face a tough test at the Emirates as Arsenal are on a real roll. It sums up our game when only a few weeks ago the club were meant to be in a crisis and fans were calling for Wenger's head, yet now they're going well in the Champions League, have signed one of the world's best players and are down to 8/1 with Sky Bet to win the Premier League.

Jamie Carragher was right when he signalled out Olivier Giroud for praise. Giroud had an impossible act to follow at Arsenal. He arrived at Arsenal as a direct replacement for Robin van Persie, who had just scored 30 Premier League goals in a season and been voted Player of the Year in England.

Giroud was on a hiding to nothing but after some early criticism has quietly gone about his business and is now starting to get the recognition he deserves. Giroud has started to make the Arsenal fans sit up with his involvement in play and subtle touch on the ball. His near post finish in the north London derby was exquisite.

He then became just the eighth player in Premier League history to score in the first four games of a season. Ozil and Wilshere will get the column inches but with their limited resources up front, Giroud holds the key to Arsenal's season.

For all their brilliance, with Aaron Ramsey again to the fore, there were still signs of vulnerability against Sunderland and big tests are still to come when their back five are up against top class opposition. Until Arsenal have beaten a Napoli, United, City or Chelsea all the old questions still remain.

Derby day

After the game at Arsenal all eyes will be on the Etihad for the 166th Manchester derby. It's been an autumn of debuts for David Moyes but this time it's also the first taste of this derby for his opposite number Manuel Pellegrini.

It will be strange not having Sir Alex Ferguson involved on the touchline as this is the first derby since October 1986 that Sir Alex has not been Manchester United manager. That day Ron Atkinson's side drew 1-1 against Jimmy Frizzel's City at Maine Road - Frank Stapleton opened the scoring before Mick McCarthy equalised. Atkinson lasted just three more games before being sacked.

What a welcome sight it must have been for City fans this week to see Vincent Kompany leading the team out at Viktoria Plzen. He's such an important figure at the club and City have been a noticeably better side with him in it, winning 58% of those Premier League games compared to 47% without him.

An equally pleasing sight for United fans was Wayne Rooney scoring twice in in Tuesday's Champions League win to become only the fourth player to score 200 goals for Man Utd - Sir Bobby Charlton (249), Denis Law (237) and Jack Rowley (211) are the others. Rooney's 200th came in his 406th appearance - a strike rate of nearly a goal every two games goals. Impressive.

The away side won both games last season. In fact the visitors have won five of the last six meetings in all competitions including the 2011 Community Shield when United won 3-2 and were allocated the 'away' dressing room.

At this early stage of the season both teams, and particularly their managers, will be desperate not to lose. It will be intriguing, intense and tight and is such a tough game to call. We start at 12.30pm on Sky Sports 1. Hope you can join us.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Paul Merson

Still in the frame

Paul Merson says Everton's top-four bid and Man City's title hopes won't be derailed on Wednesday....

Guillem Balague

Making it for Messi

Barca and Madrid are in it but the best side in Spain isn't in the Copa del Rey final, says Guillem Balague....

Chris Kamara

Twists and turns

Kammy rounds-up the weekend talking points and says nothing is decided at the top or bottom....

Latest News RSS feeds

Wenger hails important win

Arsene Wenger hailed the importance of Arsenal's victory over West Ham as his side came from behind to win 3-1.

Mentality key for Martinez

Roberto Martinez believes Everton's strong mentality could be a crucial factor in the battle for fourth place.

Allardyce frustrated by loss

West Ham boss Sam Allardyce admitted his frustration at his side's inability to hold their lead in the loss at Arsenal.

Gundogan signs new deal

Borussia Dortmund midfielder Ilkay Gundogan has signed a new deal which ties him to the Bundesliga club until June 2016.

Transfer latest

Keep up to date with all the latest news, deals and speculation.


Sky Sports Scout, in association with Wyscout, reports on Swiss striker Josip Drmic

Sky Sports Scout, in association with Wyscout, reports on Swiss striker Josip Drmic

Sky Sports Scout is our exciting feature where we scour the globe, in partnership with Wyscout, looking out for the best talent and bring you a report on what we find.

Hillsborough tragedy: What they said

Hillsborough tragedy: What they said

Football across the country will today remember the Hillsborough tragedy. We recall the reflections of some of those affected by the disaster at the FA cup semi-final between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest 25 years ago.

Whelan remembers

Whelan remembers

Former Liverpool player Ronnie Whelan talks to Geoff Shreeves about the Hillsborough Disaster.