Blogs & Opinion


Luke Dorn:

Most Popular Posts:

Opinion Archive:

More is less when it comes to Super League reforms, says Luke

Luke Dorn - Luke Dorn Posted 31st May 2013 view comments

It seems Super League wants to change... again. Plans (and several of them) are afoot for the competition to be restructured in 2015.

Of the four options presented to the clubs, there's little doubt that the most talked about is the idea to have two divisions of 12 then split into three leagues of eight after 11 games, with the bottom four from the top league joining together with the top four from the second tier.

Tony Smith: Has strong views on 'innovation' within rugby league on these shores

Tony Smith: Has strong views on 'innovation' within rugby league on these shores

For starters, let's scrap that way straight away. It sounds like too much messing around to me. I'm all for forthright thinking and changing the game, but moving yourself around inside a competition like that would not be great for the game. That just seems too radical, too gimmicky.

The other options are much more simple. There could be a return to two divisions with promotion and relegation back, or a move to a three-tier system with 10 teams in each.

It's almost at the point with rugby league in this country that they're trying to find something that will revolutionise the game quickly and make it the most amazing sport in the country.

Luke Dorn
Quotes of the week

Warrington coach Tony Smith had his say after hearing of the plans to change, and they were strong words indeed...

"I'm over the innovative tag for rugby league, that we are innovative as a sport. What about being stable, strong and consistent? What about those being our traits? We are judging the current systems in the midst of the worst economic crisis since the great depression."

Tony makes some very, very valid points. It's almost at the point with rugby league in this country that they're trying to find something that will revolutionise the game quickly and make it the most amazing sport in the country. That is obviously never going to happen.So, instead, there needs to be some consolidation of what we have got and making the most of the product in the best possible way. I just think that we have to find something within our game and stabilise it, making it as strong as possible. Splitting into three leagues, for instance, is just not feasible in this current climate.

I have spoken before about having too many teams in Super League because I don't think the spread of talent allows for a really competitive competition with 14 sides, which is not through mismanagement of clubs but just a statement on the talent pool to choose from.

By narrowing the number of teams it would increase the funding to those in the top flight and also increase the quality of the squads. That is the type of consolidation the game needs. In tough economic times, companies don't try and go for broke - they downsize, look to re-structure and find a way to maximise what is working for them.

I don't think rugby league is currently in a state that can handle a return to promotion and relegation, either. In football it's fine, because there are quite substantial (and that is something of an understatement) sums of money given to those who drop out of the Premier League. That is because the game as a whole develops so much revenue.

In Super League, though, I'd fear for the long-term future of any side that goes down, particularly those currently in the bottom four. They've been financially run to try and be successful in the top flight, yet suddenly would have to cut their cloth accordingly. I'm not certain they'd be able to compete to get back in the short term, and the longer you are on the outside the tougher it becomes.

Personally, I feel the licensing system works. I don't think it has been done very well at times in the past, but in principle I like the formula. It's got to be simplified down in the Super League and Championship, giving everyone the chance to make the top division by running their club in a financially sound way.

Yes, people will say the Championship clubs have nothing to play for, but if everyone is on a clean slate and has their finances in the right order, then there's no reason why they should have a weaker case than those clubs that aren't being so fruitful or successful in Super League.

If we have promotion, where does the team coming up get its talent from in October? We already have concerns over the drain of talent to the NRL and rugby union, but now we're asking a side that is suddenly well behind its future competitors to find players in a pool that is already small enough as it is.

A team that is going to get promoted is never, for instance, going to be able to buy a Sam Tomkins, just as no club promoted to the Premier League is going to fork out for Gareth Bale.

In rugby league you've just got to consolidate - sure promotion and relegation adds a bit of excitement at the back-end of a season, but the NRL doesn't have it and that competition is still working just fine.

It's about planning and helping the clubs. By managing the game in the right way it can flourish. If they truly want to make it a national game, then so many years down the line they should look to have teams in all areas of England.

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

It's Grand Final time!

Phil Clarke looks at previous finals between rivals Wigan and St Helens, but who does he think will win?...

Latest News RSS feeds

Cunningham 'immensely proud'

New St Helens coach Keiron Cunningham struggled to put into words what it meant to take charge of his home-town club .

Lenagan accepts responsibility

Chairman Ian Lenagan has accepted full responsibility for the Wigan Warriors’ below-par Super League season.

Wakefield sign winger Owen

Wakefield Wildcats have completed the permanent signing of Castleford winger Richard Owen on a three-year deal.

St Helens appoint Cunnningham

​Super League champions St Helens have appointed Keiron Cunnningham as their new head coach.

Huddersfield sign Roberts

Huddersfield have signed promising back-row forward Oliver Roberts from relegated Bradford.

Features

Sky Sports will show more rugby league than ever before in the 2015 season

Sky Sports will show more rugby league than ever before in the 2015 season

Sky Sports will show more rugby league than ever before next year, with around 100 live matches from the First Utility Super League, Kingstone Press Championship, Challenge Cup and World Club Series.

Sky Sports YouTube top five: Shocking rugby moments plus Boris Johnson

Sky Sports YouTube top five: Shocking rugby moments plus Boris Johnson

Our official YouTube channel is a great way to catch up with some of the best Sky Sports videos. From top highlights and big-name interviews to funny moments that showcase the lighter side of sport, here's what you've been clicking on in the last seven days...

Barrie v Terry: Our duo discuss their favourite - and funniest - moments of the season

Barrie v Terry: Our duo discuss their favourite - and funniest - moments of the season

The Super League has drawn to a close but don't worry, Barrie and Terry are still in the mood to talk rugby!