Blogs & Opinion


Diamond display

Midfield system was key to win, says Sky Sports expert

Alan Smith - Alan Smith Posted 7th October 2012 view comments

Alan Smith says Sir Alex Ferguson pulled off a tactical masterstroke by employing a diamond formation against Newcastle.

Manchester United came into the Super Sunday clash on the back of a home defeat to Tottenham and an unconvincing midweek Champions League victory over Cluj, but produced an impressive performance as they claimed a 3-0 victory at the Sports Direct Arena.

Rooney: thrived in role at forefront of diamond

Rooney: thrived in role at forefront of diamond

The Sky Sports pundits attributed the win to Ferguson's midfield system, which saw Wayne Rooney at the forefront of a diamond ahead of Michael Carrick, Tom Cleverley and Shinji Kagawa.

And Smith said the tactics allowed them to pack their much-criticised midfield, as well as getting the best out of Rooney.

"It's a good way to come to come to grounds like this and it's a good say to shore up that midfield with bodies," he told Sky Sports.

"We were wondering after the Tottenham match how they were going to cope with the power of Newcastle and protect the defence a little bit more.

"I think it was an inspired team selection by Sir Alex Ferguson and Wayne Rooney, at the head of that diamond, makes everything happen for them with his work rate.

"All the other boys had a good game. Tom Cleverley and Michael Carrick hardly put a foot wrong, so they all played their part.

"They were all fired up to do well today, as champions are, after getting a bit of criticism.

"They weren't overly convincing and conceded a soft goal to Cluj in midweek, but came out here determined to put things right.

"That system did it for them. So often when Sir Alex is under fire he comes out and goes on the front foot.

"I wondered whether they'd be a bit more conservative, sit tight and counter. They did do that, but they took the game to Newcastle and they were too good."

Sealed

Manchester United's win was sealed with a long-range goal from Cleverley and he later insisted he had intended to curl it into the top corner.

But Smith was unconvinced and suspects he was attempting to cross the ball to Robin van Persie at the far post.

"It doesn't matter, it ended up in the net," he said.

"When he looked up and set on the ball he seemed to be looking for Van Persie, but he'd have been delighted to see it float over Steve Harper.

"Clearly he's not prepared to admit it. He might have admitted it to his team-mates when they went in for the huddle, but he'll say it was a great finish.

"He played well though."

Newcastle thought they had pulled a goal back through Papiss Cisse in the second half, but Smith agreed with the decision of the officials, who insisted David De Gea had saved it before the ball had crossed the line.

However, he felt Manchester United benefitted from a stroke of fortune in the first half when the home side's penalty claims were turned down.

Patrice Evra appeared to clearly pull the shirt of Cisse in the penalty area and Smith was surprised that referee Howard Webb didn't spot the infringement.

"You could imagine Sir Alex if they had conceded a penalty," he said.

"Patrice Evra took a huge chance in taking a fist full of Cisse's shirt. I don't know what he was doing because the shirt was being pulled away from the body.

"Howard Webb might have seen that and I'm surprised he didn't, to be honest with you. It wasn't a bad angle for him and he was looking right down at it.

"He was pulling the shirt and it is a penalty. They were lucky, Manchester United."

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Drop Mario for Madrid

Jamie Carragher says Liverpool must leave out Mario Balotelli to get a result against Real Madrid in the Champions League....

Gary Neville

Nev: United not hitting heights

Gary Neville says Manchester United must not be afraid to “lump it forward” against Chelsea on Sunday....

Graeme Souness

Souness: City must adapt

Graeme Souness says Man City shouldn't play two strikers if they want the win they need in Moscow....

Latest News RSS feeds

Sky Sports Today

Reaction to Man Utd's 2-2 draw at West Brom, Champions League build-up plus breaking football news in our live blog.

Nev: United not hitting heights

Gary Neville says Manchester United must not be afraid to “lump it forward” against Chelsea on Sunday.

Souness: City must adapt

Graeme Souness says Man City shouldn't play two strikers if they want the win they need in Moscow.

Carra: Drop Mario for Madrid

Jamie Carragher says Liverpool must leave out Mario Balotelli to get a result against Real Madrid in the Champions League.

CSKA Moscow v Man City preview

Manchester City take on CSKA Moscow at an empty Arena Khimki in Champions League Group E on Tuesday (kick-off 5pm BST).

Features

West Brom 2 Man Utd 2: Five talking points including Saido Berahino, Robin van Persie and United's defence

West Brom 2 Man Utd 2: Five talking points including Saido Berahino, Robin van Persie and United's defence

West Brom led twice through fine goals from Stephane Sessegnon and Saido Berahino but each time were pegged back by equally impressive strikes from the visitors. Marouane Fellaini finally found the net for United with a superb finish before Daley Blind’s measured effort secured a point.

Champions League: From Caen to Roma via Lille, Rudi Garcia has beaten the odds and is ready for Bayern Munich

Champions League: From Caen to Roma via Lille, Rudi Garcia has beaten the odds and is ready for Bayern Munich

When Caen were promoted to the French top flight for the first time in their history in 1988, nobody gave them a chance. This was a league full of stars. A glance of the top scorers in Ligue 1 that season reveals the scale of the task: Papin, Hoddle, Weah, Blanc, Cantona and more.

Barcelona and Ajax: They wore both shirts

Barcelona and Ajax: They wore both shirts

A little over a year ago, Barcelona and Ajax met for their first ever competitive fixture against each other. Such is the way of things, Tuesday’s game at the Camp Nou will be the third of four matches between the sides in just 14 months.