Blogs & Opinion

Play-off problems

Alex reflects on college football's decision to have end of season play-offs

Alex Ferguson Posted 21st June 2012 view comments

If you want one big, sporting soap opera, look no further than the world of college football.

When the powers-that-be aren't putting schools on trial for their recruiting misdeeds, they are making changes to the game to make it either more exciting, or more safe, or both.

And popularity-wise, the sport has grown more and more, helped by the increase in gambling on the sport as well as the growth in interest of the NFL, which is populated by former college football stars.

College pick: NFL stars of the future, such as Robert Griffin III, come through the college football system

College pick: NFL stars of the future, such as Robert Griffin III, come through the college football system

But one of the biggest problems college football has had in its years is not being able to clearly define its National Champion. Where every other major sport seems to have play-offs to decide who's going to be number one, College Football left it to the pollsters to decide who was the best team in the country and after that, they tried to use the Bowl Championship Series, which has been accused a number of times of not only imperfection but also corruption.

On Wednesday, the Gods of Mount College Football told a cheering, rowdy, million-strong (and then some!) plebiscite what it wanted to hear: a consensus had been reached for a four-team play-off.

Alex Ferguson
Quotes of the week

On Wednesday, the Gods of Mount College Football told a cheering, rowdy, million-strong (and then some!) plebiscite what it wanted to hear: a consensus had been reached for a four-team play-off. The details were a little rusty, but something definite was going to happen, and college football's course will be changed forever.

The Gods make everyone fact, but one of their winged messengers informed the US media (as it always seems to, some days before the actual announcement) that the four best teams in the country would be selected by committee, who would have to consider such things as schedule strength and if they'd won their conference as important factors.

And to make it better for the existing bowl system - a system where the best teams play in end-of-season bowls against teams in other conferences for nothing more than pride, a better end-of-season record, and more importantly a nice holiday and a lot of cash (although if you don't bring enough supporters - like Connecticut didn't to the Fiesta Bowl in 2011, it'll end up costing you nearly $2m) , the two semi-finals will be played in the current system, meaning that schools will still have their tradition (or traditional paydays, as we'd like to put it). And the National Championship Game will be bid on in the same way as a Super Bowl is bid on - and cities like Jacksonville have already said that they will be bidding to have the Big College Day Out played at their stadium.

The money behind a college football play-off system is stunning - estimates are around $450m per year - and all the major networks are chomping at the bit to get a piece of the 'big games'. Expect the actual buyout price for the first contract to be in the $700m region as networks drive the price up on each other to get the final contract.

At last, the college football purists will get what they've fought for for years: certainty. At last, the Gods can say that they've done the right thing. And all will be good with the world.

Expect for me.

The problem

I don't like the idea that a 'selection committee' can decide who's going to play for our sport's biggest prize.

I worry that winning a conference championship will come before a team's strength of non-conference schedule. It'll mean that schools schedule more joke teams for their non-conference games, not less. While the Selection Committee for the NCAA College Basketball Tournament leave it in no doubt that who you play is of utmost importance, there has been wiggle room for slaughterfests for years, and the rate college football is going, nothing's changing any time soon.

And it's not just the TV fans who are getting killed - it's the fans at the turnstiles, too. For example, a Penn State fan should not expect to see his team lose a non-conference game at home this season. But then again, the Nittany Lions are playing a laughably easy non-conference home schedule (you can't do anything about in-conference scheduling), which should serve not only to give the team a good record in their new coach's first season, but also bore the pants off their fanbase. Sorry guys - you simply aren't selling me Navy at home, guys. The same goes for tens of other schools vying for a title, and it's all going to be helped by the slurry of an easy schedule. You need teams to be flexible, and pushing to play the best teams, knowing that if they want to schedule on Easy Street, then it's going to be a Hard Road to the Final Four.

Not only that, but I don't like the idea of a selection committe. Selection committees are human, and therefore will not only make mistakes, but are also going to go with the conference or the team they know best. And if they are a former coach, they are going to be favouring their team. Sorry, but it's true. Why not leave the selection process into the 21st Century, and let computers decide who's going to go, with a transparent process instead of the secrecy-laden one that have decided BCS Bowls (the major bowls) in the past? A computer can work out strength of non-conference schedule, schedule, wins and work out the best teams in the country much better than a human can - especially if that human is going to have to watch tens of games every weekend - which would be a superhuman task.

And I don't like any emphasis being given to winning a conference. We've seen some poor teams win some bad conferences this season, and then be shown up in the final bowl game (unless of course, you're West Virginia, which ruled the roost in their goddawful Big East conference in 2011, and then splattered Clemson for 70 points in 2012).

A solution

So what would I do?

First of all, I would go with the four-team play-off, and do it with the best four teams in the country. But a maximum of TWO teams - and I was toying with one - from any one conference would be allowed to play in the conference. Which means that if you finish third, then tough.

Then, I would determine the final four by a computer ratings system, which would be utterly transparent from the start. Non-conference strength of schedule will count MORE (and this will be done by computer) than in-conference SOS, to stop the rot we're currently having in non-conference schedules. The fans want to see MORE LSU-Oregon, not less. A neutral field victory will count less than an away victory and a little more than a home victory (ie: an Ohio State win at Texas counts for more than a LSU win against Oregon in JerryWorld). This will mean better non-conference games, which will mean a happier fanbase who are getting more value for money, both on the TV and actually at the stadia themselves.

And the reason why my idea is so simple is that this really should be simple and clear to work out.

Just wait for the powers-that-be in college football to provide the mud.

back to top

Other Blogs:

Latest Posts in :

Alex Ferguson

Clowney's no joke

US sports expert Alex Ferguson profiles Jadeveon Clowney, the biggest defensive pick of the draft....

Alex Ferguson

King James reigns

Alex Ferguson celebrates a wacky, smile-inducing year in US sport - and salutes Miami's LeBron James....


Alex Ferguson

Start your engines!

Alex Ferguson predicts who will triumph in NASCAR's showpiece race, the Daytona 500....


Alex Ferguson

A perfect union?

Alex Ferguson looks at the possible unionisation of college football and how he would handle the issue....

Alex Ferguson

Call of the century

Spacemen Portland pick Bowie over Jordan - Alex Ferguson ranks the biggest decisions in US Sport....


Alex Ferguson

Independence aces

Alex Ferguson kicks off his Independence Day fun by picking his 20 best bits of American sport....


Jamie Redknapp

Toffees come unstuck

Man Utd's men with a point to prove can take advantage of Everton's midweek blow, says Jamie Redknapp....

Paul Merson

Merson's predictions

Paul Merson says Liverpool WON'T beat Norwich - and Chelsea and Man City will close the gap....

Ed Chamberlin

Van the man?

Ed Chamberlin explains why Tejay van Garderen is capable of plucking the Tour de France's Yellow Jersey....


Jamie Carragher

Bruce almighty

Steve Bruce deserves a mention when this year's managerial awards are handed out, says Carra....

Dewi Morris

Heart and soul

Dewi Morris looks at a crucial weekend in the Championship as we head towards the play-offs....

Stuart Barnes

Ups and downs

Stuart Barnes says the drama of relegation must be kept in rugby, but the play-offs need changing....

Phil Clarke

To Hull and back

Phil Clarke looks at the mental damage done to Hull FC and Huddersfield in the Challenge Cup....

Bob Willis

Away for a while

Bob Willis thinks Jonathan Trott will be absent from England duty for some time following his latest setback....

Rob Lee

Pinky and perky

Rob Lee blogs on his vivid Masters Breakfast attire and the men that made waves at Augusta National....

Mark Petchey

Fillip for Ferrer

Mark Petchey marvels at David Ferrer's win over Rafael Nadal but downplays it's long-term significance....

Barry Cowan

Heavy burden

Great Britain's best Davis Cup since 1986 fails to mask their reliance on Andy Murray, says Barry Cowan....

Alex Hammond

Just Cause

Alex Hammond reveals her tips for the Irish Grand National and the other decent racing in Ireland this weeend....

Alex Hammond

Going the distance

Marathon entrant Alex Hammond previews the Newbury action and Scottish National meeting at Ayr....

Alex Hammond

Rocky's road

Alex Hammond explains why she is backing Rocky Creek and Lion Na Bearnai at the Grand National....

Jim Watt

Quigg as a flash

If he can control the pace Scott Quigg should see off challenger Tshifhiwa Munyai, says Jim Watt....

Johnny Nelson

The best of friends

It will be tough but Johnny Nelson expects mates Anthony Crolla and John Murray to serve up a classic....

Glenn McCrory

Manny happy returns

Manny Pacquiao is back to his best and could yet get it on with Floyd Mayweather, says Glenn McCrory....

View from America

Desperate deals?

Simon Veness reviews a crazy week in the NFL's free agent frenzy, as sides splash out over $1bn....


Neal Foulds

Trump tip

Ronnie O'Sullivan is favourite for the Worlds - but Judd Trump could spring a shock, says Neal Foulds....

Neal Foulds

Night at the Circus

Neal Foulds is looking forward to another fun, raucous Snooker Shoot-Out - but can't pick a winner....


Neal Foulds

Simply the best?

Five-time Masters champion Ronnie O'Sullivan may be the best snooker player ever, says Neal Foulds....


Kelvin Tatum

The contenders

Kelvin Tatum runs through the teams and riders ahead of the 2014 Elite League Speedway season....

Kelvin Tatum

Kelvin's 2013 Review

Kelvin Tatum salutes Poole's hierarchy and Tai Woffinden in his round-up of the speedway season....


Kelvin Tatum

Rich re-Ward

Poole, and the dynamic Darcy Ward, will wrap up the Elite League title at Perry Barr, says Kelvin Tatum....


Richard Moore

The final curtain

Richard Moore reflects on Sunday's Closing Ceremony to an unforgettable Olympic Games......


Richard Moore

A lasting golden glow

Richard Moore suggests all the British Olympians should visit schools and talk about their experiences....


Richard Moore

Favourite Froome

Richard Moore reveals his predictions for the 100th Tour de France, which starts on Saturday....


Wayne McCullough

Wonderful Davis

Wayne McCullough watched Antonio Rogerio Nogueria take on Phil Davis at UFC Fight Night 24. ...


Wayne McCullough

Jones shines bright

Wayne McCullough was highly impressed as the talented Jon Jones made short work of Mauricio Rua....


Wayne McCullough

A bloody marvel

Wayne McCullough salutes Diego Sanchez as he edges out Martin Kampmann in a UFC humdinger....