Blogs & Opinion

Conference calls

What do the new changes mean for the college game?

Alex Ferguson Posted 29th June 2012 view comments

The King Is Dead, Long Live The King.

After more than 100 years of dissatisfaction, the College Football critics finally have their answer: They are getting a play-off.

Last week, the Presidents of College Football's biggest conferences (the SEC, Big 10, Big 12, Pac-12, ACC and Big East- as well as the University of Notre Dame)- announced that there would be a four-team play-off to decide who wins the National Championship.

How does the future look for college football?

How does the future look for college football?

It was an announcement more than 100 years in the making, and would finally put to death the annual arguments over the worthiness of a National Champion.

Starting in the 2014-15 season (no, I don't know why they couldn't have started this in the 2013-14 season), there will be two semi-finals and a final to decide College Football champion.

Despite this writer's cries to let a computer using a transparent system rank the teams, College Football's powers-that-be have decided that it's going to be better for a selection committee to rank the teams. We just can't wait to see how this one will turn out.

Alex Ferguson
Quotes of the week

In other words, if you're College Football's fifth-ranked team in December 2014, you'll be absolutely furious.

The games don't starve College Football's Golden Goose, which has been the Bowl Championship Series, either. The two semi-finals will be played in six stadiums on rotation, meaning that every big-time bowl will have their place in the sun.

There is a certain amount of intrigue as to which bowl is going be College Football's sixth bowl, although the indications are the decision of the Big XII and SEC to have a 'Champions Bowl' which will see the top teams in both conferences play each other (if the unlikely event happens that each conference don't have a representative at the top table) looks to have been a good one.

Having said that, other bowl games are also bidding for position, which means things could get every interesting (Tip: The sixth bowl will likely be College Football's highest bidder, so don't be surprised if Jerry Jones backs the SEC/Big XII Bowl in a bid to have the National Championship Game at his stadium).

But the most important question will be: How on earth do we pick the four best teams in College Football?

Despite this writer's cries to let a computer using a transparent system rank the teams, College Football's powers-that-be have decided that it's going to be better for a selection committee to rank the teams. We just can't wait to see how this one will turn out.

The play-off teams will be decided on win-loss record, strength of schedule, head-to-head results and whether a team is a conference champion or not (it should be noted that National Champion Alabama didn't even win the SEC last year but still managed to get into the National Championship Game, where they tore about SEC champion LSU 21-0).


The biggest question is going to be about strength of schedule. Notre Dame - the sport's most powerful university voice - wants it to be about strength of schedule.

The first reason is simple: Notre Dame doesn't want to get pushed into a conference if there is a play-off emphasis on conference champions or win-loss records, because they - as an independent - consistently put together a schedule of games which the media usually describe as being 'brutal' (2012 will be no different), and if they have a good record, will automatically mean a semi-final spot.

But the second reason is greener than the fields they play on: They don't want to give up their $15m-PER-YEAR deal with NBC to show home Fighting Irish games - the away ones are on ESPN generally - although they probably won't tell you that.

But although it's easy to be cynical, Notre Dame's Athletic Director Jack Swarbrick had a point on the conference call.

Notre Dame's Athletic Director Jack Swarbrick told an ESPN Radio show:

"If you choose not to challenge yourself, especially in the pre-conference games, it's going to impact your rating. That's another way we think we're contributing to the vibrancy of the regular season through this process."

I think that the bigger schools will simply talk up the importance of their conference, and therefore decide to schedule much poorer teams in an effort to stay unbeaten until conference time.

Their motto will be: "Get through the first three pre-conference games unscathed, and give ourselves a shot at the National Championship."

I believe that the Selection Committee should answer with: "If Alabama schedules Wyoming and North Mexico State every year, they WON'T have a shot at the National Championship".

But I don't think that's likely, since the Commissioners that govern College Football would not want to make things awkward for their all-powerful coaches and teams (most big teams are guilty of scheduling lambs to the slaughter, by the way).

According to Swarbrick, the committee, which will be made up of unbiased college football analysts would consist of around 12-15 people and have no school affilation. Gosh Mr Swarbrick, I hope you take me to school when I say these words: "I'll believe it when I see it".

On paper, all of this should look so good. College Football is getting its play-off - something that it's needed for years.

But with so many worries about strength of schedule and bias on the committee (which we don't know yet) , you can't help but think: Wouldn't all of this be made easier using a transparent computer system?

Check out Alex's previous blog on the decision before it was announced

back to top

Other Blogs:

Latest Posts in :

Alex Ferguson

King James reigns

Alex Ferguson celebrates a wacky, smile-inducing year in US sport - and salutes Miami's LeBron James....


Alex Ferguson

Start your engines!

Alex Ferguson predicts who will triumph in NASCAR's showpiece race, the Daytona 500....


Alex Ferguson

Clowney's no joke

US sports expert Alex Ferguson profiles Jadeveon Clowney, the biggest defensive pick of the draft....

Alex Ferguson

Call of the century

Spacemen Portland pick Bowie over Jordan - Alex Ferguson ranks the biggest decisions in US Sport....


Alex Ferguson

A perfect union?

Alex Ferguson looks at the possible unionisation of college football and how he would handle the issue....

Alex Ferguson

Independence aces

Alex Ferguson kicks off his Independence Day fun by picking his 20 best bits of American sport....


Jamie Redknapp

Double delight?

A year on from 'bite-ban', Luis Suarez should clinch the title and PFA Award on Sunday, says Jamie Redknapp....

Paul Merson

Arsenal must win

Paul Merson says Arsenal have to have a right go and beat West Ham to keep their top-four bid alive....

Peter Beagrie

Transfer target

Beags says top sides are after Ross McCormack and picks his Championship boss of the season....

Ed Chamberlin

Van the man?

Ed Chamberlin explains why Tejay van Garderen is capable of plucking the Tour de France's Yellow Jersey....


David Jones

Ryan's big Gig

Can Ryan Giggs restore the United way or will he fall to a desperate Norwich, asks David Jones....

Stuart Barnes

Rhythm and flow

Stuart Barnes says video referees are ruining the rhythm of games and causing too many delays....

Bob Willis

Away for a while

Bob Willis thinks Jonathan Trott will be absent from England duty for some time following his relapse....

Rob Lee

Out of the woods

Rob Lee heralds the return to form of Lee Westwood and says he could yet win multiple majors....

Rob Lee

Pinky and perky

Rob Lee blogs on his vivid Masters Breakfast attire and the men that made waves at Augusta National....

Barry Cowan

Barcelona bounce

Barry Cowan says Rafa Nadal must bounce back in Barcelona and hails the form of Stan Wawrinka....

Mark Petchey

Fillip for Ferrer

Mark Petchey marvels at David Ferrer's win over Rafael Nadal but downplays it's long-term significance....

Alex Hammond

Just Cause

Alex Hammond reveals her tips for the Irish Grand National and the other decent racing in Ireland this weeend....

Alex Hammond

Going the distance

Marathon entrant Alex Hammond previews the Newbury action and Scottish National meeting at Ayr....

Alex Hammond

Rocky's road

Alex Hammond explains why she is backing Rocky Creek and Lion Na Bearnai at the Grand National....

Glenn McCrory

Change is coming

The Klitschko brothers' heavyweight domination will be over within two years, says Glenn McCrory....

Johnny Nelson

Battle of Manchester

From Crolla's derby delight to Munroe's emotional farewell - Saturday had it all, says Johnny Nelson....

Glenn McCrory

Manny happy returns

Manny Pacquiao is back to his best and could yet get it on with Floyd Mayweather, says Glenn McCrory....

View from America

The Fog of War

Simon Veness reviews the "torturous" hype ahead of the NFL Draft and why it's so hard to predict....

Neal Foulds

Trump tip

Ronnie O'Sullivan is favourite for the Worlds - but Judd Trump could spring a shock, says Neal Foulds....

Neal Foulds

Night at the Circus

Neal Foulds is looking forward to another fun, raucous Snooker Shoot-Out - but can't pick a winner....


Neal Foulds

Simply the best?

Five-time Masters champion Ronnie O'Sullivan may be the best snooker player ever, says Neal Foulds....


Kelvin Tatum

Gear shift

Wolverhampton and Belle Vue will want to kick-start their seasons on Tuesday night, says Kelvin....

Kelvin Tatum

The contenders

Kelvin Tatum runs through the teams and riders ahead of the 2014 Elite League Speedway season....

Kelvin Tatum

Kelvin's 2013 Review

Kelvin Tatum salutes Poole's hierarchy and Tai Woffinden in his round-up of the speedway season....


Richard Moore

The final curtain

Richard Moore reflects on Sunday's Closing Ceremony to an unforgettable Olympic Games......


Richard Moore

A lasting golden glow

Richard Moore suggests all the British Olympians should visit schools and talk about their experiences....


Richard Moore

Favourite Froome

Richard Moore reveals his predictions for the 100th Tour de France, which starts on Saturday....


Wayne McCullough

Wonderful Davis

Wayne McCullough watched Antonio Rogerio Nogueria take on Phil Davis at UFC Fight Night 24. ...


Wayne McCullough

Jones shines bright

Wayne McCullough was highly impressed as the talented Jon Jones made short work of Mauricio Rua....


Wayne McCullough

A bloody marvel

Wayne McCullough salutes Diego Sanchez as he edges out Martin Kampmann in a UFC humdinger....