Blogs & Opinion

It's win time in Paris

Can anyone upset world's best two at Roland Garros, asks Barry?

Barry Cowan Posted 1st June 2010 view comments

All of the talk before the French Open men's singles was of Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer and, as everyone expected, they've looked exceptional so far.

It appears as though the stage is set for the World's top two to meet in the final - but will it be plain sailing? Here are my thoughts on how the competition will pan out, from the quarter-finals onwards...

Roger Federer v Robin Soderling

Like Rafa Nadal, Federer has looked exceptional so far but he has a couple of tough opponents in front of him starting with Soderling.

First-class service: Federer will have to be on top of his game to beat Soderling

First-class service: Federer will have to be on top of his game to beat Soderling

The Swede will believe he can win this match and I've been very impressed with his rise over the last 12 months. He's a much better player now than he was a year ago - he's improved in all aspects of his game. For the first time I feel he has a game that is capable of beating Federer; his slice has improved, his net play has got better. We'll just have to see if he can make that next step and take it to the World No 1.

Berdych's power gave him the edge of Murray - he was more assertive and looked more at ease with the conditions.

Barry Cowan
Quotes of the week

That's going to be important because Soderling is a much better player when he's on the offensive, which is very difficult to do on a consistent basis against someone of Federer's quality. Soderling looked comfortable against Marin Cilic in the last round - that's the level he's at now. Even when he had a couple of difficult weeks in Rome, Madrid and then Nice the week before the French he hasn't allowed it to trouble him too much and I think he's a really good outside bet to win Wimbledon. I'm expecting this one to be a very tight match - but Federer should have just too much quality.

Tomas Berdych v Mikhail Youzhny
There have always been question marks in the past about Berdych's attitude but they seem to be vanishing. When he walked onto court ahead of his fourth-round match against Andy Murray he looked relaxed and ready to play.

In the past he's been too highly strung and hasn't performed when the pressure was on. I expected him to really kick on after winning the Paris indoor title in 2005 but he didn't because he expected it to just happen and didn't work on his game to the levels he should have done. But now, having done so well in Miami, he is ready to get back inside the world's top 10. His power gave him the edge of Murray - he was more assertive and looked more at ease with the conditions.

In Youzhny, Berdych is up against someone who has been phenomenal in the last nine months, winning in Munich earlier this month. His tennis is back to the level it was at when he reached the semi-finals of the US Open in 2006. I actually thought that was never be possible and that his best days were behind him. However, I still don't think he's got enough in his tank to beat Berdych who has to step up and reach his first major semi-final.

Jurgen Melzer v Novak Djokovic
One thing you can never question about Djokovic is his competitive nature. I still feel he isn't playing his best tennis (he's dropped sets in each of the last two rounds) but he's able to win matches on sheer guts.

He's always had great speed and athleticism around the court and now looks as though he is gaining more confidence; he is building his level again but it still has some way to go to rival Nadal. Melzer is one of the best ball-strikers on tour and will give him a decent run. I'm not surprised the Austrian has reached the quarter-finals because he has the quality. I felt Wimbledon would be his best chance so in many ways this is a bonus.

There have always been big doubts about whether he has the self-belief to get over the finishing line but I expect him to go out in this quarter-final and take it to Djokovic. Will that be enough? I doubt it. Deep down I feel Djokovic will simply make too many balls for Melzer.

Nicolas Almagro v Rafael Nadal
Almagro is saying all of the right things - he's mentally and physically stronger now than he's ever been and won the opening set when these two met in Madrid. Significantly, though, that was as poor a first set as I've seen Nadal play on any surface for about a year. Even at that stage I did not see it in Almagro's eyes that he believed he could beat his compatriot.

Almagro might talk a good game but he'll need a miracle to win this one. He's reached the last-eight of a major once before - at the French Open in 2008 - and is a very talented ball-striker but his movement is questionable and Nadal will take advantage of that. Against someone as good as Rafa is on clay you've got to go into the match with the complete package; you've got to be able to serve big, hit consistently from the back of the court and you've also got to have the confidence to come forward. As Federer found out when he played Rafa in Madrid, you can't rely on hitting winners against Nadal on a clay court.

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Dexter Medier says...

Hi Barry, After watching Federer lose to Soderling today my question is about the rankings system. As i understand it Federer will drop to 8390 pts and if Nadal wins RG he will move upto 8700 pts and thus gain the number 1 spot. So, in order for Federer to retain his number 1 spot Nadal must not win RG. However, isn't Nadal all but guaranteed the number 1 spot as he can do nothing but gain pts at Queens Club and Wimbledon (a possible 2250 pts !) and Federer cannot gain any pts at all? If this is correct do you agree with the current rankings system as it seems to reward a players efforts one year only to punish them the next.

Posted 23:39 1st June 2010

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Tennis Experts:

Latest Posts in Tennis:

Latest News RSS feeds

Murray into Valencia final

Andy Murray is in to the final of the Valencia Open after a straights-set win over David Ferrer.

Valencia Open - latest

Click for score updates from the Valencia Open. Watch Andy Murray v David Ferrer live now on Sky Sports 3 HD.

Fed's Swiss roll continues

Top seed Roger Federer beat Ivo Karlovic 7-6 (10-8) 3-6 6-3 in Basel to reach a ninth consecutive Swiss Indoors final.

Serena edges out Wozniacki

Serena Williams fought back to beat Caroline Wozniacki and reach the title match at the WTA Finals.

Nadal pulls out of ATP Finals

Rafael Nadal has pulled out of the ATP Finals in London next month to have appendix surgery.


Good Week/Bad Week: Sky Sports take a look at the winners and losers from the past seven days

Good Week/Bad Week: Sky Sports take a look at the winners and losers from the past seven days

Another week has passed in the world of sport and, yet again, heroes and villains have been made. From the enthroned to dethroned, Sky Sports pass judgement on the unadulterated highs and soul-destroying lows.

Sit-down with Rafa

Sit-down with Rafa

Sign in to hear Rafael Nadal discuss his 2015 hopes, recent injury set-backs and the ATP Tour Finals.

Roger Federer: Barry Cowan says Swiss is in the best form of his tennis career

Roger Federer: Barry Cowan says Swiss is in the best form of his tennis career

Sky Sports tennis commentator Barry Cowan explains why Roger Federer is better than he has ever been - and why he must be classed as the greatest of all time...