Blogs & Opinion

Familiar foe

United will have too much firepower for Gunners, says Jamie

Jamie Redknapp - Jamie Redknapp Posted 1st November 2012 view comments

Manchester United and Arsenal were involved in thrilling League Cup ties in midweek - but we'll no doubt see completely different line-ups when they meet in the Premier League on Saturday lunchtime.

Arsenal made 11 changes to the side that beat QPR for their game against Reading and I'm sure after 44 minutes Arsene Wenger was regretting every one of those changes! They were 4-0 down and seemed certain to exit the tournament.

Van Persie: the Dutchman is in fine form for United, says Jamie

Van Persie: the Dutchman is in fine form for United, says Jamie

Incredibly, they managed to claw it back and although it wasn't the first team that played, the atmosphere at the training ground would have been completely different had they lost that game. Now there is no doubt a real bounce around the place.

It's been a tough few weeks for Arsenal, though. We were saying a month or so into the season how well they were playing; they had three clean sheets from their first three games and we all thought: 'This is it, the new Arsenal has arrived'.

Someone on the Arsenal board has to start taking responsibility for letting players get into the last year of their contracts. That philosophy cost the club their captain, talisman and top scorer last season.

Jamie Redknapp
Quotes of the week

Man United v Arsenal
12pm, Sat, Sky Sports 2 HD
Also showing in Sky 3D
Watch on the move with Sky Go
How to remote record

Free £10 bet
New to Sky Bet? We're offering all new customers a free £10 bet. Claim now

Unfortunately the same problems from the last few years have resurfaced; they're giving away bad goals, the're conceding from set-pieces and they're looking vulnerable at the back.

On the up side, Jack Wilshere is back and you hope his partnership with Santi Cazorla can cause teams problems this season.

However, it will be a while before we see that combination in full flow because you can't expect Wilshere to come straight back in and be the player that he was before his injuries.


One player I expect to be involved on Saturday is Theo Walcott. He bagged a hat-trick on Tuesday, scored goals at vital times to keep Arsenal's League Cup dream alive and, at the same time, staked his claim for a spot up front.

However, the more pressing issue for me when it comes to Walcott is his future. Arsene Wenger came out and said he wants the contract situation resolved by Christmas.

Well I'm sorry, but it's Walcott who has all the cards at the moment; he's the one who's out of contract in nine months. Arsenal can't start giving him ultimatums.

Walcott is a very good player. Whether Arsenal fans think he's the best player in the world or not isn't really the issue. He's an asset to Arsenal and a player they don't want to be losing - certainly not on a free transfer or at a cut price in January.

Walcott has got all his options open, those three goals have helped his cause no end and I honestly think he's a good player for them: he's a cool finisher, he's young. There's no upside in letting him go on a free transfer. Even in January if they say they want to sell him he hasn't got to go anywhere.

Someone on the Arsenal board has to start taking responsibility for letting Robin van Persie, Samir Nasri, Theo Walcott and Bacary Sagna - players of quality - go to a year left on their contract. There has to be someone on the board signing them to 3-4 year contracts and once they get to two years to go saying: 'Do you want to stay?' If they say 'no' then Arsenal have to sell them.

At the moment Arsenal are getting it wrong. Considering how well they do in terms of their financial results and working within their limits, there is a real misjudgement being made allowing quality players get to within a year of their contract expiring. It shouldn't happen.


Last year that philosophy allowed their captain, talisman, top scorer Van Persie to join Manchester United - and the Dutchman has had a great start to life at Old Trafford.

He meets his old club for the first time on Saturday and I'm sure he'll get a bit of stick from the away fans in the corner of the stadium but it'll be easier for him as United are at home. It would have been a lot tougher if his first meeting with Arsenal was at the Emirates.

He'll be looking forward to this match and I'd be amazed if he doesn't score. His movement at the moment is exceptional and he's playing as well as he was last season for Arsenal. He'll be taking on some familiar faces when he lines up against the Gunners' defence but I'm sure they'll be a lot more worried about him than he is about them.

Van Persie will have some really good memories of playing for Arsenal but he's moved on now. I suspect like many players he won't celebrate if he scores against them but I don't like that. If a player likes a club so much that he won't celebrate scoring against them then he shouldn't have left them in the first place!

But Van Persie wanted to win trophies and he's moved to a club where he believes he'll have a better chance of doing that. A few years ago Manchester United v Arsenal matches were key title battles, six pointers which had a big say on who took the Premier League. Arsenal fans will admit United are now on a different level, though.

United look like they've got their form and rhythm back. Against Chelsea in the Premier League last week, for the first half hour, they were exceptional. After that Chelsea caused them a lot of problems but I think United are hitting their stride.

A key player for them in this match will be Antonio Valencia. He's a real power player, a left-back's nightmare and if he plays against Andre Santos I think he could really hurt him. Valencia will be too powerful and too quick for him.

That's an area where United can have a lot of joy on Saturday, because I don't think Santos is a good defender. If he can get at the Brazilian then I expect United to win comfortably.

United have got better players than Arsenal at the moment, Van Persie, for me, is a certainty to score, and I can see the hosts winning this one 3-1.

Bet on Jamie's Predictions

Comments (4)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Sardar Nizamee (Arsenal fan) says...

Great stuff Jamie. I agree United are favourites but I am still hopeful Arsenal will dominate the game with the midfield they have. None of the Man United midfielders, apart from evergreen Paul Scholes, would get anywhere near the Arsenal midfield.

Posted 12:20 2nd November 2012

Joe Sherry (Manchester United fan) says...

I think players not celebrating against their old club is a mark of respect! When Ronaldo scored at Sporting he was pure class and there's no way he'd celebrate at Old Trafford because it's United and SAF that made him the player he is. Some players like Tevez don't understand loyalty and it was no surprise when he went mad when he scored against United but most players have respect for their old teams and that is something that should be admired.

Posted 11:13 2nd November 2012

Spike Gunners (Arsenal fan) says...

Good article. However, I hope and I think Santos will not be the LB for this game. If so...then the key will be the middle of the park and I think Wishere/Cazorla/Arteta can outplay ManU midfield and hopefully it should be a great win for Arsenal.

Posted 11:04 2nd November 2012

Ste Smith (Manchester United fan) says...

I agree with most of what you say Jamie, but the not celebrating if scoring topic is a bit of a grey area. Van Persie wanted to win trophies which is why hes come to us, that doesnt mean all of a sudden he's forgotten his time at Arsenal, its about respect. Remember Denis Law backheeling us into division 2?? He felt awful about that because he had a lot of respect still for United......celebrate or not though, he will be trying his utmost to bag a goal or two.....

Posted 09:32 2nd November 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Andy Walker

Walker: Celtic must capitalise

Celtic are the ‘luckiest team in the world’ and must seize their chance against Maribor, says Andy Walker....

Guillem Balague

Balague's best buys

Guillem Balague picks his top 15 under-the-radar signings set for a big La Liga this season......

Martin Tyler

Tyler's stats and facts

Which team has lost the most Premier League games ever? Martin Tyler's stats and facts column is back!...

Latest News RSS feeds

Rojo completes United move

Manchester United have completed the signing of Marcos Rojo from Sporting Lisbon.

Celtic claim Maribor draw

Celtic claimed a 1-1 draw with Maribor in Slovenia in the first leg of their Champions League play-off clash.

Barcelona take appeal to CAS

Barcelona are appealing to the CAS after FIFA upheld their transfer embargo.

Live transfer updates

Man Utd confirm signing of Marcos Rojo, Edin Dzeko signs new Man City deal and QPR land Leroy Fer from Norwich.

Bruce: Hull eyeing Aboubakar

Hull City manager Steve Bruce has revealed the club are considering a move for Lorient forward Vincent Aboubakar.


Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

It’s not Arturo Vidal or Mats Hummels but it seems Manchester United finally have a new signing in £16million man Marcos Rojo. The Argentine defender will arrive at Old Trafford with more questions than those believing him to have the answers. No matter. Rojo has proved the critics wrong before.

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

It was a night that always threatened to be ghastly for Arsenal, the type of long European trip that smacks of the clichéd banana skin so early in the season.

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

In a recent statistical write up by, over 60 per cent of readers named Marco Reus as the much-needed forward they believe Liverpool should sign before the summer transfer deadline.