Blogs & Opinion

Jamie Redknapp: Pellegrini made tactical blunder in Manchester City's defeat to Bayern Munich

Jamie Redknapp - Jamie Redknapp Posted 3rd October 2013 view comments

Manuel Pellegrini made a massive tactical error that was crucial in Manchester City's humbling defeat to Bayern Munich, according to Jamie Redknapp.

City slumped to a 3-1 defeat to last year's Champions League winners in the Group D clash at the Etihad Stadium with Franck Ribery, Thomas Muller and Arjen Robben all scoring for Bayern before Alvaro Negredo pulled one back for City late on.

Manuel Pellegrini: major setback

Manuel Pellegrini: major setback

Bayern completely overran their opponents, which Redknapp believes was a result of Pellegrini electing to play Sergio Aguero and Edin Dzeko in the same starting line-up while Pep Guardiola packed his midfield with energetic and technically proficient players.

Asked if it was an error for City to play two up front, Redknapp told Sky Sports: "Absolutely, the biggest error. In modern football now, if you look at the best teams over the last few years - Barcelona, Bayern Munich and the best teams in world football - not many teams play with two up front.

I have never seen Yaya Toure so ineffectual because he could not get near anybody. It was the same for Fernandinho.

Jamie Redknapp
Quotes of the week

"You get that extra man in midfield when you play with the three and that is where they [City] were dominated. I have never seen Yaya Toure so ineffectual because he could not get near anybody. It was the same for Fernandinho.

"Kroos, Lahm, Schweinsteiger - Bayern had the run of that midfield. They were a different class."

"The system they [City] played is where they got it wrong. They gave themselves such a problem. They could not get near anybody in midfield, they were always out numbered."


Redknapp was also critical of City's defending and picked out Joe Hart's failure to deal with Ribery's effort and Gael Clichy's failure to track Muller's run in the build-up to Bayern's second goal.

Hart had a "a bad night", said Redknapp, but the Sky Sports pundit also highlighted the quality of Bayern's performance and believes the reigning champions are now an even better side since Guardiola took over as manager.

"Like Barcelona, they are happy to pass it short but they are also a bit more direct sometimes and are happy to hit longer passes."

Fellow pundit Graeme Souness agreed that Bayern have improved since their triumph last May and said that the quality they possess is a stark warning to British teams with aspirations of Champions League success this season.


"The big difference for me is that they hunt the ball further up the field," he said. "We got an indication from Arjen Robben in his interview at the start of the game, he said they now have one holding midfielder as opposed to two, which means they are pressing the ball further up the field.

"But when they had the ball they were just fantastic. The real scary thing for us is that I believe Man City are the best group of all the players in our league. They have quality throughout their squad. They were made to laborious tonight and pedestrian, and that is a worry."

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Jamie Redknapp

Jamie questions Remy move

Jamie Redknapp says Loic Remy will get nowhere near the Chelsea first team with Diego Costa around....

Gary Neville

Neville: Arsenal must sign a striker

Arsenal must sign a replacement for injured Olivier Giroud if they want to win the title, says Gary Neville....

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Top four in sight for Spurs

Spurs can make the top four, says Carra, depending on how seriously they take their European duties....

Latest News RSS feeds

Premier League round-up

Swansea, then Chelsea, move to the top of the Premier League, Stoke stun poor Manchester City and still no win for Louis van Gaal.

Live transfer updates

Arsenal and Chelsea battle for Loic Remy's signature, West Ham sign Alex Song and Man Utd agree deal for Daley Blind.

Chelsea hit Everton for six

Chelsea hit Everton for six in a goal-filled Premier League extravaganza at Goodison Park which finally ended 6-3.

Arsenal enter race for Remy

​Arsenal have joined Chelsea in triggering Loic Remy's release clause, according to some Sky sources.

United still waiting for win

Louis van Gaal continues to wait for his first win as Manchester United manager following a 0-0 draw away to Burnley.


Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

Mario Balotelli's track record on the pitch makes him a gamble worth taking for Brendan Rodgers and Liverpool

When it comes to the art of signing players, few did it better than Brian Clough and Peter Taylor. In the latter’s book With Clough by Taylor he explained some of the science behind it in detailing how Nottingham Forest actively sought to buy players they perceived to have personal problems.

Christian Eriksen masterclass

Christian Eriksen masterclass

Type ‘Christian Eriksen free-kicks’ into your internet search engine and you will not be disappointed.

Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Tottenham's Erik Lamela ready for Premier League lift off

Everyone agreed that Tottenham had acquired some fine players in the summer of 2013, but the notorious line that Spurs sold Elvis to buy the Beatles soon became a source of embarrassment. Not least because that cast young Erik Lamela as John Lennon, the most celebrated of the lot.